Issue: ngForm validation inside a table

[uqee]

Hi, guys, I've created a fiddle to show what I mean, please have a look: http://jsfiddle.net/wisard/0csmenje/1/

[Narretz]

Hi @uqee, please note that you should ask support questions on other channels, such as the mailing list (Google groups), the IRC or Stackoverflow. The angular repo is only for bugs and features.

That said, the issue with your example is that the html spec / parser does not allow tags other than td inside tr. You can see in the DOM that your ng-form is actually placed outside the table. You must set ng-form as an attribute on the tr

[uqee]

Great thanks, @Narretz. Will be more attentive hence.

[abobwhite]

Just so you know, I am seeing issues with this in Angular 1.3.15. When used as an attribute of <tr>, ng-form cannot find my parent form controller.

[gkalpak]

@abobwhite, do you have a demo that shows the issue ?

[abobwhite]

I will do that soon. Is there a stubbed jsbin or jsfiddle I can use as a template to start from?

I confirmed that this issue is not related to tables as I converted it just div tags and it still gave me the same error when using ng-form="" as an attribute. If I use as an element (<ng-form name="">), it works fine.

[abobwhite]

I have now confirmed that this is related to ng-repeat and ng-form being used on the same element. I don't think my issue is relevant to this issue but it's still an issue. I will search elsewhere - thanks.

[abobwhite]

@gkalpak Looks like you're actively involved on this issue #10165 which seems to open on my issue.