You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
I was wandering around the community feed and found this gem in the license for the keyfinder package (line-wrapped for readability):
3RD-PARTY SOFTWARE
OPENCANDY END USER LICENSE AGREEMENT
January 26, 2010
This installer uses the OpenCandy network to recommend other software you may find
valuable during the installation of this software. OpenCandy collects *NON-personally
identifiable* information about this installation and the recommendation process. Collection
of this information ONLY occurs during this installation and the recommendation process; in
accordance with OpenCandy's Privacy Policy, available at www.opencandy.com/privacy-policy
OpenCandy is considered adware according to Wikipedia; in addition, I didn't even have to look it up to know what it was. Since this package has been marked as trusted, I assume that this adware is not installed by default. However, I cannot see any code in the installation script that explicitly bypasses the adware. What might well have occurred is that this adware is no longer included with the software, considering the date in the snippet above; it may be worth mentioning this fact in the package description. (Of course, if it transpires that the adware is not bypassed, this package should be removed from public view immediately.) Thanks!
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Sorry, I must have missed this somehow.
I believe the opencandy adware module is no longer a part of keyfinder (based on that additonal programs installed, no additional dlls and no background web request detected through fiddler).
However, since it is part of the official license provided by the developers, we cannot remove that text from the included license.
Also to note.
Adware is not the same as malware (which is disallowed on chocolatey.org of course), as such it wouldn't really make sense to remove it from public view even if the module was still included.
Is adware undesired by many users? Of course, it most likely is.
Is it grounds to remove software containing adware? No, not unless it also contains malware or viruses.
@AdmiringWorm Thank you for your response; that is what I thought. Re the adware-vs-malware issue you mentioned: This is definitely something where there is difference of opinion between various users. My belief is that Chocolatey should have a zero-tolerance policy towards bundled adware that has not been bypassed, but I do not run Chocolatey, now do I? 😄 Thank you for your response regardless.
I was wandering around the community feed and found this gem in the license for the
keyfinder
package (line-wrapped for readability):OpenCandy is considered adware according to Wikipedia; in addition, I didn't even have to look it up to know what it was. Since this package has been marked as trusted, I assume that this adware is not installed by default. However, I cannot see any code in the installation script that explicitly bypasses the adware. What might well have occurred is that this adware is no longer included with the software, considering the date in the snippet above; it may be worth mentioning this fact in the package description. (Of course, if it transpires that the adware is not bypassed, this package should be removed from public view immediately.) Thanks!
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: