Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Drag and drop manager fails to find proper drop zone #204

Open
tedbeer opened this issue Jul 15, 2015 · 0 comments
Open

Drag and drop manager fails to find proper drop zone #204

tedbeer opened this issue Jul 15, 2015 · 0 comments

Comments

@tedbeer
Copy link

tedbeer commented Jul 15, 2015

The bug show case - http://codepen.io/tedbeer/pen/MwXEZg
It happens when a drop zone inside another drop zone is bigger than the parent.
DnD manager looks for a drop target and selectы the smallest. It does not take into account that a child node can be bigger than a parent node.

I propose changing the algorithm a bit:

  • find all targets intersecting with the drag source
  • from related targets (parent-child-descendant) leave the deepest (descendants) only
  • among remaining targets choose the target with the biggest intersection

The pen using patched amplesdk - http://codepen.io/tedbeer/pen/KpeBBz

Here the patch implementing the algorithm and solving the problem:

--- /amplesdk3/ample/runtime/managers/DragAndDropManager.js
+++ /ample-patched/ample/runtime/managers/DragAndDropManager.js
@@ -242,10 +242,19 @@

        // fill in array with drag targets
        var aElements   = fElement_getElementsByTagName(oBrowser_modalNode || this.documentElement, '*');
-       for (var nIndex = 0, nLength = aElements.length; nIndex < nLength; nIndex++)
-           if (aElements[nIndex].$droppable)
-               aDragAndDropManager_dropTargets.push(aElements[nIndex]);
-
+       for (var oRect2, nArea, nIndex = 0, nLength = aElements.length; nIndex < nLength; nIndex++)
+           if (aElements[nIndex].$droppable) {
+               oRect2 = fElement_getBoundingClientRect(aElements[nIndex]);
+               nArea = (oRect2.right - oRect2.left) * (oRect2.bottom - oRect2.top);
+               //skip invisible
+               if (nArea > 0)
+                   aDragAndDropManager_dropTargets.push({
+                       elm: aElements[nIndex],
+                       rect: oRect2,
+                       area: nArea,
+                       intersection: 0
+                   });
+           }
        //
        nDragAndDropManager_dragState   = nDragAndDropManager_STATE_DRAGGED;

@@ -274,41 +283,32 @@
        nDragAndDropManager_scrollTop   = oScroll.top;
    }

-   var oDropTarget = null,
-       oRect2,
-       nAreaSource =(oRect.right - oRect.left) * (oRect.bottom - oRect.top),
-       nAreaTarget,
-       nAreaTargetMin  = nInfinity,
-       nIntersection,
-       nPartialMax = 0;
-
-   for (var nIndex = 0, nLength = aDragAndDropManager_dropTargets.length; nIndex < nLength; nIndex++) {
-       // if source is the target, continue
-       if (aDragAndDropManager_dropTargets[nIndex] == oDragAndDropManager_dragSource)
-           continue;
-
-       // if target contains source, continue
-       if (fNode_compareDocumentPosition(aDragAndDropManager_dropTargets[nIndex], oDragAndDropManager_dragSource) & 8 /* cNode.DOCUMENT_POSITION_CONTAINS */)
-           continue;
-
-       oRect2  = fElement_getBoundingClientRect(aDragAndDropManager_dropTargets[nIndex]);
-       nAreaTarget =(oRect2.right - oRect2.left) * (oRect2.bottom - oRect2.top);
-       nIntersection   = fDragAndDropManager_intersectRectangle(oRect, oRect2);
-       if (nIntersection < nAreaSource) {
-           // partial intersection
-           if (nIntersection > nPartialMax) {
-               nPartialMax = nIntersection;
-               oDropTarget = aDragAndDropManager_dropTargets[nIndex];
-           }
-       }
-       else {
-           // complete intersection
-           if (nAreaTarget < nAreaTargetMin) {
-               nAreaTargetMin  = nAreaTarget;
-               oDropTarget = aDragAndDropManager_dropTargets[nIndex];
+   var aCandidates = aDragAndDropManager_dropTargets.filter(function(one) {
+       if (one.area === 0 || one.elm == oDragAndDropManager_dragSource ||
+           fNode_compareDocumentPosition(one.elm, oDragAndDropManager_dragSource) & 8)
+           return false;
+       one.intersection = fDragAndDropManager_intersectRectangle(oRect, one.rect);
+       return one.intersection > 0;
+   });
+   var oElm, rel, oldLen = 0;
+   //filter out related candidates (leave the deepest)
+   while(aCandidates.length > 1 && oldLen !== aCandidates.length) {
+       oElm = aCandidates[0].elm;
+       oldLen = aCandidates.length; //to break the loop if no changes in the candidates array
+       for (var ind = aCandidates.length - 1; ind > 0; ind--) {
+           rel = fNode_compareDocumentPosition(oElm, aCandidates[ind].elm);
+           if (rel & 8) {
+               aCandidates.splice(ind, 1);
+           } else if (rel & 16) {
+               aCandidates.splice(0, 1);
+               break;
            }
        }
    }
+   //find maximum intersection among candidates
+   var oDropTarget = aCandidates.reduce(function(prev, cand) {
+       return cand.intersection > prev.intersection ? cand : prev;
+   }, {intersection: 0}).elm;

    // if there was a drop target and it is different from a new one
    if (oDragAndDropManager_dropTarget) {
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

1 participant