Logos Round 2! [Deadline: Feb 2]

[ebullient]

Focus on shape and theme/concept, not color. We're trying to narrow it down from 4 concepts to 2 (even better would be 1).

Additional positioning and sizes

We'll narrow the poll question:

1. Choose your favorite concept (row: A, B, C, D).
2. (🚀, optional) Specific number if you have a favorite
3. (👎, optional) Specific number if it is an absolute no

Constructive comments help.

We can further explore a concept once we narrow to a favorite (and if we haven't otherwise picked a winner).

[insectengine]

Zoomed in with details.

Category A (Row 1)

Category B (Row 2)

Category C (Row 3)

Category D (Row 4)

[maxandersen]

5,6 and 8.

Fyi: cant Access the doc without red hat login

So now James comment shows up: B.

Dont like Any of the others as i prefer organic :)

[ebullient]

We're already in trouble from a narrow down point of view. :-P

1. concept: A (I like stained glass)
2. 🚀: 2. It has a "nestled in" feeling that I dig.
3. 👎: 17. It has the totally wrong feel for me.

[kenfinnigan]

1. concept A (though B is a close second as it's reminicent of LiveOak's logo, and I'm only thinking of this now, but maybe there's an opportunity for a variation of B where the roots are actually in the ground like LiveOak to have the roots not be in nothing)
2. 🚀: 1 or 2. (Note, I prefer 1 over 3 because of the rounded doorway)

[cowtowncoder]

1. Concepts A and B preferred (not sure which one I prefer of the two)
2. A2 or B8

[sigrunixia]

Just like a flag, a logo should be something a child can draw.

1. Row B, Row D should also be there and present on official documents.
   1.a. As much as I like A, in smaller sizes, those extra stained glass lines will get lost. :(
2. 🚀 5, 6, 8
   2.a. Of Row A, 2 is my favorite. If they can simplify the stained glass and maybe build the house more into it, I would jump for it in a heartbeat.
   2.b. For Row D "more official" icon, 13 and 16 look the best to my eye- rule of thirds maybe.
3. 👎 7 and 17.

[angellk]

🚀 Concept A
🚀 Concept B
👎 Concept C
👎 Concept D

🚀 A2 - i love the concept of this one and how the path leads to the house and the door connects to the path as well
🚀 B6 - love the simplicity - would look great anywhere

[Sanne]

A series is my favourite; I particularly love A1, would look great in glass, perhaps some colour.
Minor drawback of A series: it might not be very clear that it's a house in a tree.

All Bs are nicely playful sa the treehouse concept is more explicit, except I'd avoid B8 as it's overly complex; they are less fascinating that As though.

C series is acceptable, however I don't like C12 as the "house" is not visible which is the only point in favour compares to A series, which I'd highly prefer.

D series doesn't speak to me.

HTH

[jonatan-ivanov]

I think a logo should be simple, I like B and A (B > A) but not so much C and D.
In the spirit of being simple: B6, B5, A4, A2.
(I know that this is not about colors but I would be careful choosing them in a way so that branches in A do not look like roads and trunk in B does not look like an explosion catapulting the house into the clouds.)

[gavinking]

I conferred with my wife, and our position is -1 to the broccoli and to the churches.

As a first impression, I like A1, and A4.

[ebullient]

broccoli and churches.. 🤣🤗

[cealsair]

• My favorite concept is D
• My favorite design is D-17

[aalmiray]

🚀 D17
Runner ups: A1, B8

[aalmiray]

I just discovered https://github.com/tree-sitter/tree-sitter and its logo

[ebullient]

I am telling you. Everyone loves treehouses. ;)

[ebullient]

Closed for now. Next round soooon. ;)