New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
P2999 R3 Sender Algorithm Customization #1670
Comments
D2999R1 Sender Algorithm Customization (Eric Niebler) |
Library Evolution Telecon 2022-11-06D2999R1: Sender Algorithm Customization 2023-11-06 Library Evolution Kona Minutes Champion: Eric Niebler Chair: Inbal Levi / Fabio Fracassi Minute Taker: Ben Craig Start: 2023-11-07 SummaryPOLL: We want to add late customizations (as proposed by D2999R1)
Attendance: 27 + 7 = 34 # of Authors: 1 Author Position: SF Outcome: Strong consensus in favor SA: Worried about the increasing complexity, and how it will impact user adoption. Would like to see investigation on removing early customization first POLL: We should explore getting rid of early customization (paper required)
Attendance: 27 + 7 = 34 # of Authors: 1 Author Position: N Outcome: Consensus WA: "If we just did this, we could make the whole thing simpler" around early customizations. We should just do that. POLL: We generally approve on the customization mechanism presented in D2999R1
Attendance: 27+7 = 34 # of Authors: 1 Author Position: SF Outcome: Consensus SA: Would like to see investigation in higher granularity than domains The proposed mechanism for CPs was supported by LEWG. Requested additions:
Next StepsDuring the next meeting we will take the following steps:
|
D2999R2: Sender Algorithm Customization |
Library Evolution Telecon 2022-11-09D2999R1: Sender Algorithm Customization 2023-11-09 Library Evolution Kona Minutes Champion: Eric Niebler Chair: Inbal Levi / Fabio Fracassi Minute Taker: Ben Craig SummaryPOLL: Remove the sender_of concept (without prejudice, can be readded later, possibly with a different semantic)
Attendance: 22 + 4 # of Authors: 2 Authors’ position: SF SF Outcome: Consensus in favour SA: This removes functionality that is too useful. In case I want a different version, it helps to have this one in the standard. Next StepsThe authors will remove the "sender_of" concept from this version (we would like to re-design the shape of the concept). LEWG will spend additional time on this paper during the Kona meeting. |
Library Evolution Telecon 2022-11-10D2999R2: Sender Algorithm Customization 2023-11-10 Library Evolution Kona Minutes Champion: Eric Niebler Chair: Inbal Levi, Ben Craig Minute Taker: Andreas Weis SummaryPOLL: Approve design of D2999R2 (Sender Algorithm Customization). (not a forwarding poll)
Attendance: 27+5 # of Authors: 1 Author Position: SF Outcome: Strong consensus in favor Next StepsThe design was approved. The P paper should get back to LEWG to make sure the wording fits the design intent. |
2023-12-05 Library Evolution TeleconP2999R2: Sender Algorithm Customization 2023-12-05 Library Evolution Telecon Minutes Champion: Eric Niebler Chair: Fabio Fracassi Minute Taker: Ben Craig SummaryThe wording of the paper was reviewed (requires more time). No polls were taken. Next StepsLEWG needs to continue reviewing the wording in P2999R2. |
2023-12-12 Library Evolution TeleconP2999R2: Sender Algorithm Customization 2023-12-12 Library Evolution Telecon Minutes Champion: Eric Niebler Chair: Fabio Fracassi Minute Taker: Ben Craig
SummaryThe topic of removing early customization was brought up, and as the Kona discussion suggested it requires more exploration (but shouldn't block the work on P2999) LEWG still asks for a paper for that (this was referred to and polled during Kona). The wording of the paper was reviewed:
To be continued at [exec.start.detached] in R3 with the changes above incorporated. No polls were taken. The author will produce a new revision (R3) that incorporates the points mentioned. We will finish the review of [exec.start.detached], [exec.sync.wait] and [exec.execute]. Next Steps
|
P2999R1 Sender Algorithm Customization (Eric Niebler) |
P2999R2 Sender Algorithm Customization (Eric Niebler) |
P2999R3 Sender Algorithm Customization (Eric Niebler) |
2023-12-19 Library Evolution TeleconP2999R3: Sender Algorithm Customization 2023-12-13 Library Evolution Telecon Minutes Champion: Eric Niebler Chair: Fabio Fracassi Minute Taker: Ben Craig SummaryShort review of the remaining wording. No further changes were requested POLL: Send "[P2999R3] Sender Algorithm Customization" to Library Working Group for C++26, to be confirmed by electronic polling.
SA: Complexity of S/R is getting too complex, the complexity was not discussed here. Attendance: 20 # of Authors: 1 Author's Position: SF Outcome: Consensus in favour Next StepsP2999R3 was forwarded to LWG (applied on P2300) to be confirmed with an electronic poll. |
P2999R0 Sender Algorithm Customization (Eric Niebler)
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: