/
file_sizes.txt
107 lines (67 loc) · 10.7 KB
/
file_sizes.txt
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
In this example, the ParseMultipartForm method is called with a 1 MB argument, which means that files up to 1 MB will be stored in memory and the rest will be stored in a temporary file on disk. This is a more scalable approach for handling large files.
Note: This code does not implement chunked transfer encoding or upload resumption, which are more advanced features that would require a more complex implementation, possibly involving JavaScript on the client side and additional server-side logic to manage file chunks and support resuming. You might want to look into third-party libraries or services that specialize in large file uploads if you need these features.
To handle the upload of multiple large files, such as files that are 6GB each, you would need to make several changes to the Go code. Here's what you need to consider:
Remove Memory Limit in ParseMultipartForm: Instead of setting a high memory limit, you should set this to a minimal value and stream the file directly to disk to avoid using too much memory.
Handle Large Files: Ensure that your server's file system can handle files larger than 4GB. This is typically an issue on older file systems that do not support large files.
Server Timeouts: Set the server timeouts to a high value or no timeout at all to allow for the long duration it might take to upload a large file.
Client-Side Considerations: Ensure that the client-side (browser or other HTTP client) does not have restrictions on file size and that it can handle such a large upload without timing out.
Network Stability: For such large files, any network instability can cause the upload to fail. Implementing a resumable upload feature might be necessary.
HTTP Server Configuration: The HTTP server should be configured to handle large content lengths.
To address the requirements you've listed, we would need to make several changes to the code. However, some of these changes, such as implementing chunked transfer encoding and resumable uploads, are non-trivial and would require a more complex solution than can be provided in this format. These typically involve client-side JavaScript to handle the chunking and server-side logic to manage the reassembly and resumption of file chunks.
This code increases the memory limit for multipart form parsing and sets a longer timeout for the HTTP server. It also creates a unique file name for each uploaded file to avoid conflicts.
For chunked transfer encoding and resumable uploads, you would need to implement a more complex system that handles file chunks on both the client and server sides. This would likely involve JavaScript on the client side to break the file into chunks and send them sequentially, and Go on the server side to receive these chunks, store them, and reassemble them once all chunks have been received. Additionally, you would need to keep track of the upload progress and allow for resumption if the upload is interrupted. This is beyond the scope of a simple script and would require a full application to manage.
The provided Go file uploader program has a few points that could be causing issues with uploading large files:
Memory Limit in ParseMultipartForm:
The ParseMultipartForm function call has a parameter that sets a maximum memory usage during the file upload process. In the provided code, r.ParseMultipartForm(10 << 20) sets this limit to 10 MB. This means that the file being uploaded is stored in memory up to 10 MB, and the rest is stored in temporary files on the disk. When uploading large files, this could lead to performance issues or even crashes if the server runs out of memory or disk space.
HTTP Server Timeouts:
The default HTTP server settings in Go may have timeouts that are too short for large file uploads. If the upload takes longer than the timeout, the server may close the connection, resulting in a failed upload.
Client-Side Timeouts:
Similarly, the client (browser or HTTP client) may have timeout settings that are exceeded when uploading large files.
Lack of Chunked Transfer Encoding:
The program does not implement chunked transfer encoding, which is a method that allows a browser to send a large file in smaller chunks. This can be more efficient and reliable for large file uploads.
No Handling for Connection Interruptions:
The code does not handle potential network interruptions or allow for resuming uploads, which can be problematic when dealing with large files.
File System Limitations:
If the server's file system has a file size limit (like FAT32's 4GB limit), it could prevent large files from being saved after being uploaded.
Browser or Network Issues:
The browser or the network might have issues handling the upload of large files, which could be due to memory usage, browser limitations, or network reliability.
Lack of Feedback Mechanism:
There is no progress feedback mechanism for the user. When uploading large files, it's helpful to have a progress bar or some indication that the upload is still ongoing, to prevent users from assuming the upload has stalled and cancelling it.
To address these issues, you could:
Increase the memory limit in ParseMultipartForm or handle the file streaming directly to disk to avoid loading the entire file into memory.
Configure the HTTP server to have longer timeouts or no timeouts.
Implement chunked transfer encoding for the file upload.
Add a mechanism to handle upload resumption in case of network interruptions.
Ensure the server's file system can handle large files.
Provide user feedback during the upload process, such as a progress bar.
For handling very large files, it's often better to use a dedicated file transfer protocol like FTP or SFTP, or to use a service specifically designed for large file transfers.
When attempting to move several large files (~6GB each) fileUploader.go will not transfer them. Can we reason about what might be preventing large file transfers here?
ChatGPT
ChatGPT
When dealing with the inability to transfer large files using fileUploader.go, there are several potential factors to consider:
Server Configuration Limits: The Go server might have limits on the request body size. By default, Go's HTTP server does not impose a limit on the size of the request body. However, if there's a reverse proxy or load balancer in front of the Go server, such as Nginx or Apache, it might have its own limits that need to be configured to allow large file uploads.
Client-Side Limits: The browser or client used to upload the files might have limitations or settings that prevent large file uploads.
Timeout Settings: Both the server and the client might have timeout settings that are exceeded when trying to upload large files, especially if the network speed is not fast enough to transfer the file before the timeout period elapses.
Memory Usage: Uploading very large files can consume a significant amount of memory, as the file might be read into memory before being written to the disk. If the server does not have enough memory to handle the uploaded file, this could cause the process to fail.
File System Limitations: The file system where the files are being uploaded might have file size limitations. For example, the FAT32 file system has a maximum file size of 4GB.
Browser or Network Issues: The browser might crash or the network connection might be interrupted during a large file transfer, especially if the browser or network hardware is not equipped to handle such large transfers.
Programming Logic: The Go code itself might have logic that inadvertently restricts the size of the files being uploaded. For example, it might use data types or buffers that are not capable of handling large files.
To troubleshoot the issue, you can:
Check the server logs to see if there are any errors when attempting to upload large files.
Increase the timeout settings on both the client and the server to accommodate the time it takes to upload a large file.
If using a reverse proxy or load balancer, check and adjust the configuration to allow for larger uploads.
Monitor the memory usage on the server during the upload process to see if it's running out of memory.
Ensure that the file system where the files are being saved supports large files.
Test the upload with different browsers and networks to rule out client-side issues.
Review and test the Go code to ensure that it can handle large files without issues.
If you're using a standard Go HTTP server without additional middleware that limits the request body size, and you're still encountering issues, you might need to implement a more robust file upload handling mechanism that supports streaming the file to disk, rather than reading it all into memory, and that can handle network interruptions and resume uploads.
Different web browsers may have their own built-in limits for file uploads. Does Chrome set such limits?
ChatGPT
ChatGPT
Web browsers like Google Chrome do not typically impose their own limits on the size of files that can be uploaded. Instead, they rely on the server's configuration to dictate the maximum allowed file size for uploads. However, there are practical limitations that come into play, such as:
HTTP Server Configuration: The server handling the file upload will have its own limits, which are often set to prevent denial-of-service attacks or to manage server resources effectively. For example, web servers like Apache and Nginx have configuration directives (LimitRequestBody for Apache and client_max_body_size for Nginx) that define the maximum allowed size for an uploaded file.
Browser Stability and Performance: While the browser may not explicitly limit the file size, uploading very large files can lead to high memory usage and potential instability in the browser. This is more of a practical limitation rather than a hardcoded limit.
Network and Connectivity: Network conditions and the reliability of the connection can also impact the ability to upload large files. Timeouts or interruptions in connectivity can cause large file uploads to fail.
Server-Side Script Limits: If the server uses a backend script to handle the upload (like PHP, Node.js, etc.), there will be configuration settings in those environments as well that limit the maximum file upload size (e.g., upload_max_filesize and post_max_size in PHP).
Browser Timeouts: Browsers may have timeouts for network requests, and if an upload takes too long due to a large file size, it may time out.
In summary, while Chrome itself does not set a specific file upload limit, the practical limit is determined by a combination of server settings, browser performance, and network conditions. It's always a good practice to handle file uploads in a way that accounts for these variables, such as providing informative feedback to the user when a file is too large or an upload fails, and implementing chunked uploads for very large files.