deno_registry2 must reject broken module

[elycheikhsmail]

I think deno registry must check the module befor add them to deno.land/x store, if the code is invalid (like deno deploy check) or have'nt description inform the contributor. this will be help develop to get "save" code from deno.land/x, this may need some convention about enty/entries poins for modules or manifest.

[wperron]

We already have process that goes through every file to deno cache them to analyze the dependencies (which is then reflected on the build status returned by the webhook) -- is that what you had in mind?

[elycheikhsmail]

We already have process that goes through every file to deno cache them to analyze the dependencies (which is then reflected on the build status returned by the webhook) -- is that what you had in mind?

I deploy test_manager, I clean (not intended) one file content commit this brok my code, then I publish can't be used by any body because is invalid I'd like deno registry to reject invalid code and notify dev deploying this.
if my not clear a nought I will rewite it.

[wperron]

Yeah I'm sorry, I'm not 100% clear on what you're asking here? "Broken code" could mean a couple of different things, it could mean that imports and broken, it could mean that there's syntax errors and it doesn't parse in v8, or it could mean a variety of other things. What's the flow you're looking for? What kind of errors do you want the registry to catch and how?

[moncefplastin07]

Yeah I'm sorry, I'm not 100% clear on what you're asking here? "Broken code" could mean a couple of different things, it could mean that imports and broken, it could mean that there's syntax errors and it doesn't parse in v8, or it could mean a variety of other things. What's the flow you're looking for? What kind of errors do you want the registry to catch and how?

I think he means that you should check if the third party modules is work before publishing them on the Deno registry
I think the piece of code below explains what he means 😄

if(checkIsValidThirParty(incomingThirdPartyModule)){
     publishToDenoRegistry(incomingThirdPartyModule)
}else{
     makeReportToModuleOwner(incomingThirdPartyModule)
}

[MierenManz]

Yeah I'm sorry, I'm not 100% clear on what you're asking here? "Broken code" could mean a couple of different things, it could mean that imports and broken, it could mean that there's syntax errors and it doesn't parse in v8, or it could mean a variety of other things. What's the flow you're looking for? What kind of errors do you want the registry to catch and how?

I would assume that broken code means that it is code that won't run.
like

functi on ree() {
  return "ree";
}

And if things like this happen then the registry should reject the code.

[elycheikhsmail]

Yeah I'm sorry, I'm not 100% clear on what you're asking here? "Broken code" could mean a couple of different things, it could mean that imports and broken, it could mean that there's syntax errors and it doesn't parse in v8, or it could mean a variety of other things. What's the flow you're looking for? What kind of errors do you want the registry to catch and how?

thanks for response.
essentialy I mean by broken have invalid syntax
or import inexisting code at publish time.
or code wrtien to work with nodejs only
sorry I'm not always online.