Docker doesn't start after 4.29 upgrade without installing Rosetta

[xeron]

Description

M2 Pro MacBook Pro.

Docker used to work just fine without installing Rosetta. Just pressing "Not now" on installation request and disabling it in Docker for Mac settings.

After 4.29.0 upgrade this doesn't work anymore. After pressing "Not now" it says Rosetta installation failed. There's "Disable rosetta" button but it doesn't do anything, it tries to install it again and fails again after pressing "Not now".

Reproduce

1. Mac without Rosetta installed
2. Start docker 4.29.0
3. Press "Not now" for Rosetta install request

Expected behavior

Docker engine and Docker for Mac start and work as usual even without Rosetta.

docker version

N/A because docker fails to start

docker info

N/A because docker fails to start

Diagnostics ID

32A8EAF1-FD11-464B-A824-5EB62FB3ADB8/20240409022034

Additional Info

Downgrading to 4.28.0 fixes the issue.

[shinyzhu]

I have the same issue on my Mac. It's a dead loop.

I've unchecked the "Use Rosetta for x86_64/amd64 emulation on Apple Silicon" option in the General settings.

Rosetta should be optional. I don't have or want to have Intel based containers on my Mac.

[98549844]

I have the same issue on my Mac. It's a dead loop.

I've unchecked the "Use Rosetta for x86_64/amd64 emulation on Apple Silicon" option in the General settings.

Rosetta should be optional. I don't have or want to have Intel based containers on my Mac.

that mean un-select this option "Use Rosetta for x86_64/amd64 emulation on Apple Silicon"
version 4.29 will be resume to normal ?

[amxfonseca]

Same issue here. Docker Desktop is now crashing during startup and selecting "Disable Rosetta" wont't fix it.

[shinyzhu]

I have the same issue on my Mac. It's a dead loop.
I've unchecked the "Use Rosetta for x86_64/amd64 emulation on Apple Silicon" option in the General settings.
Rosetta should be optional. I don't have or want to have Intel based containers on my Mac.

that mean un-select this option "Use Rosetta for x86_64/amd64 emulation on Apple Silicon" version 4.29 will be resume to normal ?

I've tested this on 4.28.

When I checked this option. The Docker Desktop asked install Rosetta. I clicked "Not Now" then this option became unchecked.

[98549844]

I have the same issue on my Mac. It's a dead loop.
I've unchecked the "Use Rosetta for x86_64/amd64 emulation on Apple Silicon" option in the General settings.
Rosetta should be optional. I don't have or want to have Intel based containers on my Mac.

that mean un-select this option "Use Rosetta for x86_64/amd64 emulation on Apple Silicon" version 4.29 will be resume to normal ?

I've tested this on 4.28.

When I checked this option. The Docker Desktop asked install Rosetta. I clicked "Not Now" then this option became unchecked.

docker desktop version4.28 running normally on mac m1 , but v4.29 can't running

[booleanbetrayal]

This issue is blocking our uptake of this release because we have explicitly forbidden Rosetta to eliminate any chance of unintended emulation / architecture drift in our engineering environments.

[MihaelaStoica]

Thank you for reporting and apologies for this bug! We identified the problem and we're working on a fix.

[MihaelaStoica]

Hey everyone, we have a test build with a fix, if you'd like to give it a try. Let us know if it fixes the issue for you.

[mattpavelle]

Hey everyone, we have a test build with a fix, if you'd like to give it a try. Let us know if it fixes the issue for you.

This fixed the problem for me. Thank you, @MihaelaStoica

[shinyzhu]

@MihaelaStoica the test build works fine on my Mac too~ Great work.

[jfernandezr]

Thanks @MihaelaStoica.

After installing this test build, would Docker update to the stable channel back again or should I install the stable version when this issue goes upstream?

Thanks!

[MihaelaStoica]

After installing this test build, would Docker update to the stable channel back again or should I install the stable version when this issue goes upstream?

Yes, you will be able to update to the next official release of Docker Desktop.

[k0ste]

Hey everyone, we have a test build with a fix, if you'd like to give it a try. Let us know if it fixes the issue for you.

Works for me, thanks

[JDanielGutierrez05]

Hey everyone, we have a test build with a fix, if you'd like to give it a try. Let us know if it fixes the issue for you.

I have the same issue after updating, but i just reinstall the 4.28, and now install this test build and works like a charm without using rosetta.

[cperezabo]

ETA for the stable release?

[jac18281828]

Same issue here. Docker should not be enforcing dependencies that are not required. Docker is synonymous dependency management?

[pro-nsk]

Same issue for me.
Test build works, thanks

[maikdiepenbroek]

Test build works :) thanks!

[zhiminL712]

可以给一个windows的测试版本吗？

[stevetoro]

Hey everyone, we have a test build with a fix, if you'd like to give it a try. Let us know if it fixes the issue for you.

Test build resolved the issue for me, same as everybody else, but it also got rid of that pesky "Configuration changed by another application" warning mentioned in #6898. Thank you!

[juanjoseluisgarcia]

This issue is blocking our uptake of this release because we have explicitly forbidden Rosetta to eliminate any chance of unintended emulation / architecture drift in our engineering environments.

Same here!

[junior]

If in the future Docker need to have Rosetta for some reason, a clear message should be passed, and it's a major change. Was unexpected in a minor update.

BTW, both, installing the v4.28 and the test build both works for now. The only annoying issue with this is the Docker Desktop offering you to restart/update all the time and the ⓘ icon on the App bar.

[jamesgreenblue]

Test build worked perfectly 😅

@MihaelaStoica Can you confirm when it will be safe to update to a stable version?

[MihaelaStoica]

@MihaelaStoica Can you confirm when it will be safe to update to a stable version?

The fix will be included in the next release of Docker Desktop, which is currently scheduled for the first week of May