Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Broken DTMF calling (D Decd) #55

Closed
CaptainRi opened this issue Oct 27, 2023 · 14 comments
Closed

Broken DTMF calling (D Decd) #55

CaptainRi opened this issue Oct 27, 2023 · 14 comments
Labels
bug Something isn't working

Comments

@CaptainRi
Copy link

CaptainRi commented Oct 27, 2023

Two k5s, A is the original firmware, B is v0.14.1 firmware.
both same freq eg438.500, both with DTMF (D Decd) turned on. After this setting, B calls A ,A only light and no sound,
but both with DTMF (D Decod) turned off become normal

@egzumer
Copy link
Owner

egzumer commented Oct 27, 2023

DTMF decoding is originally meant to give an option to call each other somewhat like with phones. The call pattern is
callee*caller
Where callee and caller are 3 digit ANI ID of each radio. If radio receives a call it only then starts to listen for a preset amount of time.
This was broken in 1o11's repo when I forked it. I will try to fix that in the future.

@egzumer egzumer added the bug Something isn't working label Oct 27, 2023
@egzumer egzumer changed the title D Decd error Broken DTMF calling (D Decd) Oct 27, 2023
@CaptainRi
Copy link
Author

DTMF decoding is originally meant to give an option to call each other somewhat like with phones. The call pattern is Where callee and caller are 3 digit ANI ID of each radio. If radio receives a call it only then starts to listen for a preset amount of time. This was broken in 1o11's repo when I forked it. I will try to fix that in the future.callee*caller

same issues still exists

@egzumer
Copy link
Owner

egzumer commented Oct 30, 2023

You didn't actually say what is the problem, you only described what is going on. So what is the actual problem?

@CaptainRi
Copy link
Author

You didn't actually say what is the problem, you only described what is going on. So what is the actual problem?

Yes, I only know the phenomenon of the problem. I don't understand programming, and of course I don't know where the problem lies

@egzumer
Copy link
Owner

egzumer commented Oct 30, 2023

No, not where the problem lies, I will investigate where it lies, but you didn't state the problem at all.

@CaptainRi
Copy link
Author

No, not where the problem lies, I will investigate where it lies, but you didn't state the problem at all.

I told you the method of reproduction. What's not clear about it

@egzumer
Copy link
Owner

egzumer commented Oct 30, 2023

You only described what you do, you didn't state what is not right in the result.

@egzumer
Copy link
Owner

egzumer commented Oct 30, 2023

I fixed what I consider wrong, but you say it is still the same so I'm getting confused

@CaptainRi
Copy link
Author

No, not where the problem lies, I will investigate where it lies, but you didn't state the problem at all.

Two k5s, A is the quansheng original firmware, B is your firmware today.
both same freq (eg438.500), both with DTMF (D Decd) turned on. After this setting
Result B calls A , A only light No sound,
A calls B,B only light No sound

@CaptainRi
Copy link
Author

I fixed what I consider wrong, but you say it is still the same so I'm getting confused

Wait a few minutes, I will send the video to the telegram

@egzumer
Copy link
Owner

egzumer commented Oct 30, 2023

Can you see any "bad", "wrong", "not right", "error", "not expected" in your statement? Because I don't. How am I supposed to ask the question in any other way?

You do certain actions, and you get certain outcome. Can you state what is different in what is happening from what you expect to happen?

@CaptainRi
Copy link
Author

CaptainRi commented Oct 30, 2023

Can you see any "bad", "wrong", "not right", "error", "not expected" in your statement? Because I don't. How am I supposed to ask the question in any other way?

You do certain actions, and you get certain outcome. Can you state what is different in what is happening from what you expect to happen?

I opend D decd and press PTT to other,They have no sound,I think D decd has something wrong
Open dtmf The receiver cannot output sound

@egzumer
Copy link
Owner

egzumer commented Oct 30, 2023

Radio with D Decd set to ON should have no sound on receive, unless you call it with its ANI ID. When I call my radio with 102*103 I get the sound.

https://github.com/egzumer/uv-k5-firmware-custom/wiki/Radio-operation#dtmf-calling-decoding

@CaptainRi
Copy link
Author

Radio with D Decd set to ON should have no sound on receive, unless you call it with its ANI ID. When I call my radio with 102*103 I get the sound.

https://github.com/egzumer/uv-k5-firmware-custom/wiki/Radio-operation#dtmf-calling-decoding

I understand. I'm very sorry for wasting a lot of your energy and time.Thank you very much for everything you selflessly did for K5!

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
bug Something isn't working
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants