unable to sign in

[bartmaniac]

**Firefly III Server Version:4.7.9

**Firefly III Mobile Version:1.0.2

**Android Version:8.1.0

**Device Information:

• BRAND: Huawei
• MODEL: Nexus 6P

---

Expected Behavior

Able to login succesfully

Current Behavior

I followed the steps.
On firefly-III I Created a new client under OAuth Clients.
Name: I picked a name
Redirected URL: http://empty
I got an id and a secret key

Back on the android smartphone I choose Oauth Auth and filled in the URL Client ID and Secret fields with the same values as the one in firefly-iii. After pressing Sign in I get

Authentication Failed
Therer was an issue retrieving access token from your Firefly III instance. Ensure you are using http://empty as your redirected URL in your Firefly III config

I am doing this on the same internal network. Firefly III is running on mac os High Sierra, under Docker

Steps to Reproduce

[emansih]

The latest version is 1.1.0 though

[bartmaniac]

I got this release from f-droid telling me i'm [up-to-date.
Where do I find and how to install latest version

Thanks a lot

[emansih]

https://github.com/emansih/FireflyMobile/releases

[filoor]

Hi @emansih,

I have tried the new version and i'm still getting "Authentication Failed"

[emansih]

@filoor have you followed the steps found here?

[bartmaniac]

Does one need to be on the same network where firefly-iii is running? . I am trying this on my smartphone at work over 4G while my pc where firefly-iii is running is at my home and there is no portforwarding setup up

[emansih]

Are you able to access firefly from the web browser outside your network?

[bartmaniac]

I can access firefly from my webbrowser when i am at home. I enter localhost:8081/login and get the login page

[bartmaniac]

Something is moving
I tried it once more while on the train using 4g and no more Authentication failed error. The firefox android webbrowser opens and the url is

https://www.google.com/search?q=http%3A%2F%2Fempty+%2Foauth%2Fauthorize%3Fclient_id%3D9%26redirect_uri%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fempty%26scope%3D%26response_type%3Dcode%26state%3D&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&client=firefox-b

[filoor]

Hi @emansih,

Yes i did follow the steps. I traid my internal ip an also external outside the network

[emansih]

Can you guys open a separate issue.......

@bartmaniac I don't think you understand how all these works.

localhost

simply means localhost. It's hosted on your server in an internal Network.

Try this

Open your web browser and access firefly iii on your mobile network.

Are you able to access?

[bartmaniac]

Probably not I guess. I guess i have to enter an internet ip adress not a local 192.168.0.xx

[emansih]

@bartmaniac yes! you are getting onto something

[emansih]

@bartmaniac anymore issues?

[bartmaniac]

well I have no idea how I could make this work. on one hand there is the local firefly database with all the data (running on a local pc with a 192.168.0 .22 ip address and on the other hand the smartphone on a mobile network.

[emansih]

Since I assume you are running purely on a local network( no port forwarding, no ports open to outside world), simply ensure that both your PC and phone are on the same network. Then use 192.168.0.22 as the url

[emansih]

@bartmaniac are you still having issues?