Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Rocket.Chat: allow voice compression of audio equivalent to mainstream chats to encourage adoption by new groups #24

Open
fititnt opened this issue Feb 3, 2018 · 2 comments

Comments

@fititnt
Copy link
Owner

fititnt commented Feb 3, 2018

The people in our testing groups ("ChatOps for non-DevOps people") do not work in a typical T.I. environment, often use chat platforms that are different from corporate chats (i.e. Slack, HipChat, Glip, Gitter...), but maybe "more simple", but mainstram messengers: WhatsApp, Facebook Messager, then others, by this order or usage.

If slack/HipChat/Etc promote themselves as a replacement for e-mail, we could think that what we are trying here is to replace mainstream chat with some more intelligent version of itself. This could be done or 1) improving (example: adding chatbots used for chatops to mainstream messagers) or 2) replacing with new chat platforms. Both ways are in testing in this working grouo.

This specific issue discuss the second alternative, with usage of rocket.chat (a very very good hackeable platform) to be more friendly for Facebook/WhatsApp related to voice audio.


  • Perceived problem when uploading voice using rocket.chat: "it does not work" "it works for small length audio"
  • Server problem: audio files where blocked because of default server upload size (2mb); increasing upload to 10mb make it work
  • File size problem: files are encoded in .wav, with very low compression rate; even if server compress a file before share to others, would waste too much bandwish if encoding does not occour on client side, before upload

I'll still get more information about the problem in the next few days. I asked them to send files on different platforms to allow comparison.

@cdiegosr
Copy link
Collaborator

cdiegosr commented Feb 5, 2018

It's interesting :D

My tests with rocketchat on chat.aguas.win :

5 seconds of video message - 448k of .webm
5 seconds of audio message - 1025kb .wav

and same thing (without rules) with my smarthphone:

5 seconds of video message with WhatsApp - 294kb .mp4
5 second audio message with WhatsApp - 1024kb .wav

seems better to send and receive video than audio, I am thinking to disable audio message with this...

@fititnt
Copy link
Owner Author

fititnt commented Mar 15, 2018

Nice. The issue RocketChat/Rocket.Chat#4552 was closed and the RocketChat/Rocket.Chat#9726 was merged

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants