Missed forum notifications

[PeopleInside]

Current Behavior
A clear and concise description of the behavior.

As user i want can choose if receive notification for all replies in a topic or just when i am mentioned.
Actually i see in Flarum the option i want: to be notified of all replies on the topic where i am but this seems is not working as expected. If the reply has not the mention i never receive notification.

Steps to Reproduce

1. Partecipate in a topic.
2. Click on the Following button
3. Following option is selected ( Be notified of all replies )
4. See error: no email and notification arrive if you are not mentioned.

Please see this: https://discuss.flarum.org/d/17605-be-notified-when-an-update-is-avaiable/4
Also here: https://discuss.flarum.org/d/17608-issues-with-composer-on-centos/11

My experience is that i miss replies because are not notified.

Expected Behavior

1. I should decide if by default following for all replies or just when mentioned. This maybe in the profile preference
2. If i see i am following all replies i should be notified on all replies not only when mentioned as happen now

Screenshots
If applicable, add screenshots to help explain your problem.
https://discuss.flarum.org/d/17605-be-notified-when-an-update-is-avaiable/4

Environment

• Flarum version: Flarum Community it's your version and your forum. The bug is in the Flarum support community

• Website URL: https://discuss.flarum.org/

Output of "php flarum info", run this in terminal in your Flarum directory.

I cannot do as server is yours :D

Possible Solution

Additional Context
In a support community you should never miss replies. In my experience with the Flarum forum i found many replies to my topics that i miss to read because of no notifications.

[PeopleInside]

I understood now all replies means when someone click on reply on your message.
Should be another option to decide to be notified of all message posted in a topic. This will be not inserted in the core? There is an extension who will do that?

[tobyzerner]

Actually, here "all replies" refers to all new posts in the discussion, even if they're not in direct reply to yours. Note that you will only receive one notification for the first new post that you haven't seen, and you won't receive any further notifications until you are once again up-to-date and have read all the posts in the discussion.

If you're not receiving this initial notification, though, that's a bug. I've followed a few discussions on discuss.flarum.org to see if I can reproduce the issue.

[tobyzerner]

Confirmed and fixed. Thanks for the report @PeopleInside.

[PeopleInside]

@tobscure i made some errors maybe but i am happy to see i can help little bit. Happy to be right this time, thank you!

[PeopleInside]

Hi @tobscure , this is not fully fixed.

• I visited this topic on Flarum community
• Without posting i subscribe to the topic (Following)
• I see someone has posted a reply (post) and i never been notified by email and by notification

Never received a notification also for the reply up

Update: I subscribed here and when a new message has been posted i was notified. * Confused :D * maybe i experience no notification because two previous post was a direct reply to user post? This should be notified anyway...