I try to convert Predictive Ranges [LuxAlgo] to the py, whats the problem?

[kaanguven]

closed

[xmatthias]

Well without actually knowing where you suspect that the problem is (or what problem you're encountering) - it's pretty difficult to say.

One thing that i can see from afar is that the way you implement it will be very slow, as it's looping through the whole dataframe - but at first glance - for no good reason (it could be probably vectorized by using appropriate pandas calls).

[kaanguven]

Well without actually knowing where you suspect that the problem is (or what problem you're encountering) - it's pretty difficult to say.

One thing that i can see from afar is that the way you implement it will be very slow, as it's looping through the whole dataframe - but at first glance - for no good reason (it could be probably vectorized by using appropriate pandas calls).

I guess the problem is in for loop, I'm undecided whether to use a for loop for the avg value

[xmatthias]

Well if i'm honest, i dont' see a question in any of your comments.

it's just a "this is code, this is my converted code" ... but if there's no actual question - then there's no actual response.
Please understand that i'll not be debugging random code without even knowing why or what to look for.

[kaanguven]

Well if i'm honest, i dont' see a question in any of your comments.

it's just a "this is code, this is my converted code" ... but if there's no actual question - then there's no actual response. Please understand that i'll not be debugging random code without even knowing why or what to look for.

the question is : "According to pinescript, the output in my python code is wrong, what am I missing?"

[xmatthias]

Well - most likely, precise understanding of how the indicator should actually work?

Pinescript seems simple at first glance, but really isn't, and i find it never really clear if something is a series or a value/scalar - as that can somehow change throughout time iirc.

Can you define (in words, not code) how the indicator should actually work?
Without that understanding, the attempt to convert it to a different language will certainly fail.

[stash86]

Just to add one thing for you to consider, have you ever consider that maybe the pinescript's result is the one wrong?

[kaanguven]

Just to add one thing for you to consider, have you ever consider that maybe the pinescript's result is the one wrong?

No 100% sure it works fine.