Different canonical URLs for same content

[felixhahnweilheim]

The problem

https://community.humhub.com/s/general-discussion/ and https://community.humhub.com/s/general-discussion/home are the exact same page. However, both are set as canonical URL in the HTML source.

Same for https://community.humhub.com/u/luke and https://community.humhub.com/u/luke/home

(Those are just examples, it happens with all spaces and users with default settings.)

What is the expected result?

The same canonical URL is used for both pages.

My suggestion

Set the link with '/home' as canonical.
Some spaces have a custom start page, so the direct link without '/home' redirects to another page. The '.../home' URL always works.

Additional info

Q	A
HumHub version	1.?
PHP version
Operating system

Note: Also provide the full error stacks from Administration --> Information --> Logging and errors from your browser console if possible.
Note: Please use the community site for any questions on customizing HumHub.

[ArchBlood]

I believe this is mostly due to the use of createUrl() being used within both the user profile & space.

An easy workaround would be a Url helper that would handle such issues.

User Example

humhub/protected/humhub/modules/user/widgets/AccountTopMenu.php

Line 65 in 152b0a0

'url' => $user->createUrl('/user/profile/home'),

[luke-]

It would be good to always have a canonical/single URL for such pages.

We have to take into account that /u/luke does not always point to /u/luke/home, because the start page of Profiles & Spaces is changeable.