Easy place to add answers?

[PestoPresto]

Not an issue, but is there a place to easily add answers? While playing through P5R's 1st dungeon, it looks like the answers are mostly the same as with regular P5, so this guide will still work.

As an extra:
The question "You carry a gun because you think it'll make you more popular with girls?"
The answer "That's right" is Good for Upbeat shadows. Worked on the Mandrake.

"I'll go out with you just for today if there are no strings attached"
"If it pleases you" is also Good for Upbeat shadows. Worked on Mandrake

[montgocloud]

Same, would love to contribute anything that I gather from my playthrough of Royal. Here's the first one that I've noticed:

Q: "Hey, sonny if somethin's been botherin' you. I'm willin’ ta give you a listen."
A: "I have no worries." GOOD - Gloomy

[SugarFrost]

I would also like to contribute my findings. Some answers are a bit different from the base version. Here is a list with the ones I have found so far:

Q: “Aren't people as old as you s'posed to go "dating," all the time? Can't you get some dates?”
A: “Dating’s not important.” (Good - Upbeat)

Q: “It is not possible for this series of events involving you and me to be attributed to that?”
A: “Fair Enough.” (Good - Gloomy)

Q: “I insist you surrender yourself to the authorities.”
A: “I apologize.” (Good - Gloomy)

Q: “If I were to die here, my existence up to this point would be rendered meaningless. But this way of life in this world is all i’ve ever known.”
A: “There are other ways to live.” (Good - Gloomy)

Q: “Me am really in soup, now. Do what you want. Me am ready if you want grill me, so..”
A: “I’ll mince you.” (Good - Upbeat)
A: “I don’t want to eat you.” (Good - Timid)

Q: “Why you wear mask to fight, anyway?”
A: “I care about my looks.” (Good - Timid)

Q: “There is something you want say to me, right?”
A: “Let me touch your paw.” (Good - Upbeat)

Q: “Why’re you so desperate?”
A: “There’s something I must do.” (Good - Timid)

Q: “I know when I’m gettin’ all sweaty. I’m glistenin’, aren’t I?
A: “Not at all.” (Good - Timid)

Q: “When you were little, what did you wanna be when you grow up?”
A: “A winner in society.” (Good - Upbeat)
A: “A pro athlete.” (Good - Irritable)

Q: “You’re s’posed to go easy on kids! Are you stupid? Do you go to school and get stupid grades?”
A: “I’m smart.” (Good - Irritable)
A: “I’m good at PE.” (Good - Upbeat)

Q: “What was that, anyway?”
A: “A threat letter.” (Good - Irritable)

Q: “Didn’t you feel like that when you were a kid, too?”
A: “It’s not so bad-olescent.” (OK - Irritable)

Q: “Guess what I want you to read to me before you tuck me into bed!”
A: “A story about Yakuza.” (Bad - Irritable)

Q: “You carry a gun because you think it’ll make you more popular with the girls?”
A: “It’s for self-improvement.” (Good - Irritable)

Q: I’ll go out with you just for today if there are no strings attached.”
A: I’ve got enough on my plate.. (Good - Irritable)

Q: “I gotta ask. How do you work out?”
A: “I just have a knack for it.” (Good - Timid)

Q: “What in the hell are ya tryin’ ta tell me, anyway?”
A: “You’re going to die.” (OK - Timid)

Q: “Hey, if you got any medicine, lend me some. They're supposed ta work miracles, right…?”
A: “That won’t change anything” (Good - Gloomy)

Q: “Humans always want either an autograph or a self-hee, ho. Which is it, ho?”
A: “Give me your credit card.” (Good - Gloomy)

[PestoPresto]

Q: "Is it not possible for this series of events involving you and me to be attributed to that?"
A: "That is incorrect." good - upbeat

new answer, not a direct quote
Q: "Why you keep trampling here? What you humans thinking?"
A: I'll take off my shoes good - upbeat

Q: "There something you want say to me, right?"
A: "I want you." good - upbeat

Q: "If yer gonna kill me, do me a solid and make it quick."
A: "I'll make it quick." good - irritable

Q: "Hey, if you got any medicine, lend me some. They're supposed ta work miracles, right...?"
A: "That won't change anything?" good - irritable

Q: "Ooh, what if this leaves a scar and it's permanent?"
A: "Sorry..." good - gloomy

Q: "You carry a gun because you think it'll make you more popular with the girls?"
A: "That's right." good - irritable
A: "It's for self-improvement." good - upbeat

new question
Q: "When it came down to it, you couldn't do anything to me!"
-"How could you tell?" Good - upbeat
-"I could"
-"What do you want me to do?"

new answers, may be out of order
Q: "Me not understand in what way you superior to me..."
-"Luckiness" ok - timid
-"Youthfulness"
-"Cuteness"

Q: "If so, then won't you overlook this? Let's make a deal..."
A: "All right." good - upbeat

new answer, possibly replaces "find myself"?
Q: "Why you come all the way here?"
A: "I just felt like it" good - gloomy

new answers
Q: "If you capture me, what you going to do to me?"
-"Take pride in capturing you" ok - gloomy
-"Use you to decorate the hall"
-"Nothing."

[kjensen9]

Another answer
Q: "Hey, let's play a game! Guess what I wanna eat!"
A: "Hamburgers" - GOOD - UPBEAT

Q: "What was that, anyway?"
A: "A love letter" - OK - UPBEAT

Q: "Why do they like "making out"? "
A: "Ask your parents" - GOOD - TIMID

Q: "Do you think they really mean it all the time?"
A: "YES" - OK - TIMID
A: "No, but they say it anyway." - GOOD - TIMID

Q: "When you were little, what did you wanna be when you grow up?"
A: "A Pro Athlete" - GOOD - TIMID

[joyce-chen]

Hey! Thank you for the new answers. I'll add these in momentarily. I threw together a google form for people who don't have github accounts.

I'm keeping this issue open for people to submit their discoveries. If future submissions can format their comments as such, will really help me out. Thank you.

Game version: Persona 5 / Persona 5 Royal

Type: New Question
Q: "What is the question?"
1- "This is the first answer." Good - Mandrake - Upbeat
2- "Second answer."
3- "Third answer."

Type: New Reaction
Q: "What is the question?"
1-"This is the only new reaction." Good - Mandrake - Upbeat

Type: Different Wording
Q: "What is old question?" > "What the new Royal question?"
2-"The old answer" > "The new Royal answer"

Type: Conflicting Reaction with guide
Q: "What is the question?"
3-"This is the answer." Good - Mandrake - Upbeat

[PestoPresto]

I forgot to put down the shadow names before recording these.

Correction
Hell, I got all sorta girls lined up if you're into that.
1 Really? ok - life-draining spirit - gloomy

Correction
...Um, this has been buggin' me for a while, but... Is it me, or does something stink?
1 It's just you. good - life-draining spirit - gloomy

Correction
You're a big bully! don't you think that's "immature"?
1 Now that you mention it... good - ? - upbeat

New answer/Correction
Hey, let's play a game! Guess what I wanna eat!
2 Humans.
3 Shut up. good - ? - irritable

New answer/Correction
Didn't you feel like that when you were a kid, too?
1 It's not so bad-olescent. ok - ? - irritable
2 Being a kid is tough. good - ? - irritable

Correction
You're a big bully! don't you think that's "immature"?
2 No, I don't think so. good - ? irritable

Correction
Do you seek friendly competition with a beloved neighbor? Or have you come to destroy a hated foe?
1 You're a beloved neighbor. ok - ? - irritable

New question
For you to force me to prostrate myself, as one who only seeks your well-being... Is there anything more irrational?
1 My apologies.
2 I don't want salvation. good - ? - irritable
3 Shut up.

Correction
I insist you surrender yourself to the authorities.
1 This is a misunderstanding. ok - ? - upbeat

Correction
You, however are talking to me right here. Are you the exception to this rule?
3 I have ulterior motives. good - ? - upbeat

Correction
Me am really in soup, now. Do what you want. Me am ready if you want grill me, so...
3 All right I'll mince you! good - ? - gloomy

Correction
There something you want say to me, right?
3 Let me touch your paws. ok - ? - gloomy

Correction
If your girlfriend asked if you were free to have dinner with her "friends", what would you say?
1 Sure. good - ? - upbeat

Correction
Why have you decided to be more communicative with me?
1 Your looks. good - ? - upbeat/timid

Correction
Me no curse you, but me curse your commander! Me curse the one who order you...!
2 Fighting me is bad luck. bad - ? - gloomy

Correction
You given much thought, what if you go to place where you could die at any moment?
1 I've thought about it. ok - ? - gloomy

Correction
I know when I'm gettin' all sweaty. I'm glistenin', ain't I?
2 Not at all. good - ? - timid

Different wording/Correction
I've been sending you serious "don't speak to me" vibes. > I've been sending you a serious "don't speak to me" aura.
2 I didn't see any "vibes." > I didn't notice any "aura." ok - ? - timid

New question
You do understand that we are here because of people like you, right?
1 I never thought of that.
2 I understand. bad - ? - timid
3 What do you mean?

Correction
Ah, so I suppose you commit such extreme acts because you know you won't be punished harshly...
2 Age doesn't matter. ok - ? - timid

Different wording
In the very end, what the hell are you tryin' ta tell me? > What in the hell are ya tryin' ta tell me, anyway?
1 I'm telling you to die. > You're going to die.

Correction
What's gonna happen to me?
3 I'll be your dominatrix. good - ? - upbeat

Correction
How 'bout we have an interview? You're the winner, after all. I'll listen to whatever you gotta say.
2 I want to aim higher. good - ? - irritable

Correction
A bad rep spreads like wildfire. If I were you, I'd quit all this nonsense. What's the point?
1 You're right. good - ? - irritable

Correction
Y'know, if I'm gonna be killed, I'd rather be offed by some beautiful, classy woman.
3 It's all the same. good - ? - irritable

Correction
Hey. So whaddya think when you think about the future?
1 An average level of happiness. good - ? - timid

[joyce-chen]

Corrections and additions have be all added up to this point. Thank you! Sorry for the delay.

[zjturner]

Some of the questions have undergone relatively significant wording changes in P5R, and in many cases the answers just don't work anymore. I saw there's a csv file, but that was last updated 3 years ago so I don't think that's the right place to make fixes. Should I just edit the .md file directly? Happy to submit a pull request rather than make you do it yourself as long as I'm editing the right file.

[joyce-chen]

@zjturner
Yes, the CSV file is outdated and should not be used.

To clarify things, I've opened two issues with formatting details for GitHub users to submit changes:

• Persona 5 Royal - Submit Changes #16 for Persona 5 Royal
• Persona 5 - Submit Changes #17 for the original Persona 5

For non-Github users, I've created a form.

Pull requests are not a recommended at this time. Sorry for the confusion. Thanks!

[mattman9929]

hey @joyce-chen ill be playing this to the end so ill be adding some missing info you be needing :)

[joyce-chen]

@mattman9929 Glad to hear! I just updated the guide to include a bunch of submissions from the last few months.

[mattman9929]

This is that "domestic violins" thing, right?
upbeat section on (What? No, you're wrong...) is bad