How to resolve by stream?

[garak]

I'm using LiipImagineBundle with Gaufrette.
Gaufrette is configured to use aws S3, so I configured a StreamLoader. So far so good.
Now the problem is that I'm not able to resolve thumbnails via Gaufrette, since the only way I found here is AwsS3Resolver, that is not what I want: AwsS3Resolver bypasses Gaufrette and so I cannot use Gaufrette options (most notably the "directory" options), but the worst point is that this completely defeats the Gaufrette abstraction layer (e.g. I cannot easily switch between filesystem abstractions).
So, is a stream resolver really missing here, or am I doing something wrong?
Thanks in advance.

[makasim]

We can introduce a gaufrette resolver. Sounds reasonable to me.

[romaricdrigon]

+1 for a Gaufrette resolver.
Using stream feels like a step back from the Symfony2 style.

[makasim]

any takers on this?

[garak]

I tried to write something myself, and I ended up with some code. But my main issue is how to get the asbtraction work with every implementation. So, I implemented my GaufreffeResolver, but in the resolve method I have to call $this->filesystem->getAdapter()->getUrl(), but unfortunately getUrl() is not present in every adapter. I'm stuck at this point.

[makasim]

I see, it is hard to use gaufrette as a resolver. but can at least use it as a data loader, would it be useful?

[romaricdrigon]

Why closing it, something was done?

[makasim]

The interface of a resolver is richer than stream can provide us with. So nothing to do here. The stream data loader is already here.

[romaricdrigon]

I think the issue is about working with Gaufrette by stream, and not by using objects provided by Gaufrette.
At least it is what I understood from the first post. And I can hardly see a stream having a better interface than a Gaufrette filesystem object.

[makasim]

The PR is very welcome, I dont see much sense keeping it open, since it is just an addition which is not block us in any way.

[makasim]

The PR is very welcome (:

[romaricdrigon]

Well, if someone wants to have some time on it, the issue keeps track of it. For instance for some Symfony hack day.

[michellesanver]

This needs an issue with a more clear description of the feature and the requested implementation. Create a new issue with clarifications, link this one, and close when done :)