Should Dice coefficient for empty result and empty reference be 1?

[baumgach]

Hi there,

This issue is in reference to the following line:

medpy/medpy/metric/binary.py

Line 79 in 39131b9

dc = 0.0

Shouldn't an empty reference and an empty result set output a Dice coefficient of 1 rather than 0? I.e. if no pixels of a class are present in the image and no mask is predicted, then the prediction is correct. Or am I missing something here?

(For the Jaccard coefficient the division by 0 detection seems to be missing altogether.)

Thanks and best wishes,
Christian

[loli]

Thanks for noticing!