Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Can't ban forever #181

Open
Tantrix opened this issue Apr 29, 2022 · 5 comments
Open

Can't ban forever #181

Tantrix opened this issue Apr 29, 2022 · 5 comments
Assignees

Comments

@Tantrix
Copy link
Contributor

Tantrix commented Apr 29, 2022

For some reason, I can't ban a user forever, just for a time.

 <Luadch> [command] !ban cid V5FEPL3C7QZVEZGMXTXPYSFWGGRVVSHESXZBG3A 1 trojan
 <Luadch> [ BAN ]--> User:  V5FEPL3C7QZVEZGMXTXPYSFWGGRVVSHESXZBG3A  was banned by:  Delion  |  bantime: 0 days, 0 hours, 1 minutes, 0 seconds  |  reason: trojan

but

 <Luadch> [command] !ban cid V5FEPL3C7QZVEZGMXTXPYSFWGGRVVSHESXZBG3A -1 trojan
 <Luadch> Usage: [+!#]ban nick|cid|ip <NICK>|<CID>|<IP> [<TIME> <REASON>] / [+!#]ban show|showhis [<NICK>]|clear|clearhis
 <Luadch> [command] +ban sid Q7CV -1 test
 <Luadch> Usage: [+!#]ban nick|cid|ip <NICK>|<CID>|<IP> [<TIME> <REASON>] / [+!#]ban show|showhis [<NICK>]|clear|clearhis

2.24 RC1

@Sopor
Copy link
Contributor

Sopor commented Apr 29, 2022

Ban forever is removed 86d3a2c even if it still works. I have some issues with it as you already know :(

If you want to ban forever you can simple user delreg instead and give them a reason and the nick will be blocked and can't be used.

@pulsar-de
Copy link
Member

In reg hubs there would be the alternative of delreg with a blacklist entry, but i admit that a forever ban makes sense in public hubs...

@pulsar-de pulsar-de self-assigned this Apr 30, 2022
@Sopor
Copy link
Contributor

Sopor commented Apr 30, 2022

Even if you ban a user forever the user can easy change the CID and login again. IP address can sometimes be a little bit harder but still possible to change quite easy.

@Tantrix
Copy link
Contributor Author

Tantrix commented Apr 30, 2022

the user can easy change the CID and login again

You never guess.

@ryehamstrawberry
Copy link

ryehamstrawberry commented Sep 22, 2022

In reg hubs there would be the alternative of delreg with a blacklist entry, but i admit that a forever ban makes sense in public hubs...

Please reimplement "forever" bans.

Yes, you can always just +delreg user accounts but there are situations where it's useful to save permanent bans with reasons, too.

The reason accounts are not auto-banned when they are removed is because both +delreg and +ban serve two different functions, otherwise you would combine them, which you don't.

Just because the dev team might not see a need for a feature does not mean everyone else agrees, at least in this instance.

Think of it this way: every other chat platform has the ability to implement permanent bans, not just silly timed bans for 1.9025875190259e+31 years ....

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

4 participants