-
-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 1.3k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Recieve and Apply Mastodon Note Edits #8364
Comments
implementing the whole "note history" would be more difficult. But it would make for a better experience (if a post is edited to offensive content -> etc...) |
There should at least be a hint that the note was changed. Otherwise popular notes could be changed after getting popular etc. |
I think it would fit better with the other icons in the top right of the note; but otherwise yes |
Another concern is what is allowed to be updated. In the Pleroma merge request that was linked in the other issue there is a list of updateable properties in Note also that it seems to be forbidden to change the options of a poll or change poll options between On another note I thought that Mastodon said they implemented updating posts as well, but their website still says:
|
I think this is more important now that Mastodon 4.0 is releasing with editing posts in the UI |
個人的な意見
|
In addition, users should also be notified by any edits (as Mastodon currently does) so that anyone reacted can cancel/modify theirs. 編集が行われた場合、リアクションを変更できるように通知も必要になります。 |
There have been countless times where I've posted something, had someone reply to it, and then realize I've made a typo or missed an important detail. Only having the option to "Delete and Edit" makes it impossible for me to fix it without losing people's replies. In this case, the actual content of the note hasn't meaningfully changed. That being said, I understand that not everyone limits themselves to fixing simple typos, which is why I think users need to be notified if a note they reacted/replied to has been edited (as @saschanaz has mentioned) so they can decide if they want to change their reaction/reply. Because note editing is likely going to be something people either agree or disagree on, I think be a good idea to allow admins the ability to enable/disable direct editing of notes.
Having the history of note edits is invaluable for moderating an instance. If someone posts something that's problematic and edits it after the fact, as a moderator, I still need to know what was originally said so I can decide if I need to take further action. |
another very good reason to keep full editing history: I can only see the note on the remote server if it's a public note; any "followers only" or direct note won't be visible |
Summary
Receive AP Update for Note objects.
My ideas:
note_history
with unique indexid
, and indexnote_id
Update
, create a new entry under note_history with old content and old dateedited_date
as a nullable column tonote
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: