Editing a developer reply from a permalink is visually awkward

[kumar303]

Describe the problem and steps to reproduce it:

• Sign in as a developer
• Go to one of your add-ons that has some reviews
• Go to the review listing
• Reply to a review
• Click the timestamp of the review to view its detail page
• From the detail page, click Edit my review

What happened?

It looks like:

What did you expect to happen?

• There shouldn't be any stars
• You should only see one review form. Multiple forms are open because the reply is also rendered further down in the listing.
  • Editing a reply from the permalink page opens two text boxes #2063 has been opened to address this.
• The link to edit should have been Edit my reply
• The buttons should say Update reply, etc

Anything else we should know?

[AlexandraMoga]

If you venture on selecting a star, an error message will also be displayed:

[bobsilverberg]

@kumar303 maybe a change landed since you reported this, but there is one aspect of your report I cannot reproduce. You say:

The link to edit should have been Edit my reply

I do see "Edit reply" as the link in the featured review card:

Is that bug no longer valid, or am I misunderstanding?

[kumar303]

I do see "Edit reply" as the link in the featured review card

Yep, this is fixed now. I crossed it out in the description. It looks like the other things I mentioned in the description still need fixing.

[ioanarusiczki]

@kumar303 I verified this issue on AMO dev with FF62(Win10) and the "Review" or star ratings are no longer available for the developer response.
The page must be refreshed to see the updated text down below in the list of reviews. Same if the response is edited from the list of reviews, not a big issue but let me know if we should track this with another issue.

Also I filed #2066

[bobsilverberg]

The page must be refreshed to see the updated text down below in the list of reviews. Same if the response is edited from the list of reviews, not a big issue but let me know if we should track this with another issue.

I opened #12447, which I think addresses the issue you describe. Do you agree @ioanarusiczki?

[ioanarusiczki]

@bobsilverberg Yes, I agree. It's in here #12447