No sync in Edge Windows Creator Update: SCRIPT65535: Invalid calling object

[wassx]

Hi!
I tried to connect to my server with an edge browser but there occurs an error in the console.
SCRIPT65535: Invalid calling object networked-aframe.min.js (2,3147)

Chrome and safari work as expected.
Any ideas please?

[wassx]

Ok, I found on the page of WebRtc: no edge supported. 😕

[wmurphyrd]

Looks like Edge WebRTC is available in preview builds as of a couple weeks ago: https://blogs.windows.com/msedgedev/2017/01/31/introducing-webrtc-microsoft-edge/#Hlcah5SRWeiITzeV.97

Have you tried it?

[wassx]

Ah thank you, I'll give it a try!

[robertlong]

There's still no support for DataChannels in Edge 🙁
https://developer.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-edge/platform/status/?filter=f3f0000bf&q=rtc

[wmurphyrd]

Just confirmed successful networking in WindowsMR on Edge using wsEasyRTC adapter

[wmurphyrd]

Note that the invalid calling object error traces back to https://github.com/networked-aframe/networked-aframe/blob/master/src/NafLogger.js#L24

Getting it to load in Edge requires that networked-scene.debug is false and that you avoid any other conditions that would invoke the NafLogger

[wmurphyrd]

So this may be a bug in Edge which has a fix in preview right now: https://developer.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-edge/platform/issues/14495220/

[wmurphyrd]

The original issue, SCRIPT65535: Invalid calling object, is now fixed in the latest version of Edge (windows 10 v1803, build 17134.81), so this issue can probably be closed. Although we may still want an open issue to track full Edge compatibility.

With that latest version, I get some partial support in Edge with the EasyRTC adapter now. Audio can stream between two Edge tabs on the same machine (but not to other browsers or even Edge on another machine), and other avatars sometimes sync into the Edge instance but not from Edge outwards.

[3DataWill]

With a new beta from EasyRTC last week, voice and video conference with Edge worked for me in their demo, streaming between desktop Edge and Android Firefox.

Edge still doesn't have DataChannels, but perhaps the wseasyrtc adapter could be extended with audio support.

[vincentfretin]

Edge is now using Chromium. Closing.