New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Add increased/decreased DevelopmentOfAnatomicalEntity #708
Comments
We are trying to avoid "decreased and increased", in favour of: decreased occurrence decreased all by itself means nothing logically - better to distinguish. Which one is it? |
we have increased / decreased for pretty much every phenotype. And it's not always rate. Sure occurrence might be used but I won't change these phenotypes. |
@pfey03 I think it would be increased occurrence of development in location (where location would be a cellular component in this case). I think you could use this pattern: Is there a GO term that would work for you? |
@nicolevasilevsky |
also, a general question: I have not yet added the synonym, but in general, is this acceptable as it's in the ontology but not primary term? Thanks @nicolevasilevsky, @matentzn |
Thanks both; Just to be clear. We do not impose any restrictions on the terminological aspect of a term at all. You can name a phenotype "increased X" - this has no bearing on anything. But for the pattern (logical definition), we want to be able to distinguish things in a more semantically meaningful way - a process can either occur more often, or at a higher rate, or with a larger output - its usually one of these. Thats why for the EQ, we try to capture precisely the meaning of term! So to your second question: Absolutely! The only thing you need to do to be uPheno conformant is to adhere to the logical definition - the rest is up to your personal gusto! |
Hey @pfey03 can i close this issue? If not, what are the action item? |
Hmm, so nothing being added right? It's a lot of different things and I will see if I can manage with InLocation I would have to use for both, anatomy term or GO CC |
Ok check that out, and if sometning is missing, just say here: please add pattern x and y. |
There is:
abnormalDevelopmentOfAnatomicalEntity
Please add the increased / decreased terms
Thanks!
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: