You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
The p87482 (American Opportunity qualified expense) variable is in the puf.csv file but is not "aged". It is used in the tax calculations in the AmOppCr function, but when puf == True this calculation has no effect on tax liability because the American Opportunity credit is set to the "aged" value of the p87521 variable, which is also in the puf.csv file.
Given this situation, is there any reason to keep the p87482 variable in the puf.csv file?
Even If the p87482 variable is removed from the puf.csv file, it will remain in the VALID_READ_VARS set (along with the other three student expense variables, p87487, p87492, p87497, which will be moved from the CALCULATED_VARS set). This will allow other datasets to specify the expenses for up to four students and calculate the credit from the expenses when puf == False.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
martinholmer
changed the title
Drop p87482 (AmOpp expenses) variable from puf.csv file?
Drop p87482 (AmOpp expense) variable from puf.csv file?
May 12, 2016
The
p87482
(American Opportunity qualified expense) variable is in thepuf.csv
file but is not "aged". It is used in the tax calculations in theAmOppCr
function, but whenpuf == True
this calculation has no effect on tax liability because the American Opportunity credit is set to the "aged" value of thep87521
variable, which is also in thepuf.csv
file.Given this situation, is there any reason to keep the
p87482
variable in thepuf.csv
file?Even If the
p87482
variable is removed from thepuf.csv
file, it will remain in the VALID_READ_VARS set (along with the other three student expense variables,p87487
,p87492
,p87497
, which will be moved from the CALCULATED_VARS set). This will allow other datasets to specify the expenses for up to four students and calculate the credit from the expenses whenpuf == False
.Is there a better way to handle these matters?
@MattHJensen @feenberg @Amy-Xu @GoFroggyRun
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: