odo service create doesn't honor parameters

[VeerMuchandi]

[kind/bug]

What versions of software are you using?

• Operating System:
• Output of odo version:

$ odo version
odo v1.0.0-beta4 (d11517f1)

How did you run odo exactly?

odo service create mongodb-ephemeral mongodb -p DATABASE_SERVICE_NAME=mongodb -p MONGODB_USER=user -p MONGODB_PASSWORD=password -p MONGODB_DATABASE=todos -p MONGODB_ADMIN_PASSWORD=password

The result of the above command creates a database along with a secret mongodb. If you reveal the secret values they are different (only uses defaults and ignores supplied parameters). I also tried to use params comma separated. No difference.

Compare this with

oc new-app --template=mongodb-ephemeral \
--param=DATABASE_SERVICE_NAME=mongodb \
--param=MONGODB_USER=user \
--param=MONGODB_PASSWORD=password \
--param=MONGODB_DATABASE=todos \
--param=MONGODB_ADMIN_PASSWORD=password

which creates the secret mongodb with the values you want.

Actual behavior

odo not using the values supplied as parameters

Expected behavior

odo should create secret using parameters supplied

Any logs, error output, etc?

[kadel]

This looks like duplicate of #2033

[dharmit]

I think it's not an exact dupe because the parameters will be accessible/visible under the "Environment" tab on OpenShift console and not stored as a secret as mentioned in "Expected behavior". AFAIK, this is true even when setting the parameters using interactive mode of odo service create.

[kadel]

@dharmit the Secret is created automatically by Service Broker. It doesn't matter if you call it using oc or odo. This is auto of clients control.

The problem was that odo didn't pass the parameters to ServiceInstance. This got fixed in #2040

You will be always able to read Secret values in OpenShift console.

[girishramnani]

as per @kadel comment it seems this is a duplicate. Closing