Server implementation follow up

[Tolriq]

To allow client devs to follow each servers implementations and know what features can be implemented in clients, let's use this thread so that servers can have a post where they document what they support.
I'll update the docs from time to time but for the start and with the number of new fields that will come it's easier to have live editable data.

Clients can also post what they added to motivate servers too :)

As a starter for the new fields PR, Symfonium already support all the data except disc title, so if you add them, I'll add support for sure.

[sentriz]

for gonic:

• multi valued album artists (v0.16)
• multi valued genres (v0.16)
• transcode offsets (v0.16)

i haven't looked at the new auth stuff yet

[sentriz]

@Tolriq i just noticed that gonic is returning a concatinated list of genre strings for the "song" entity. i should be returning only 1. (and a list when we have that for song)

updated it now so it doesn't concat

[Tolriq]

Sorry don't understand the question :(

[sentriz]

I just noticed and issue with gonic's song response, and I know you are testing with that. but anyway it's fixed now

[Tolriq]

I only test search3 for now and did not see an issue yet it synced with your test server

[epoupon]

About LMS (https://github.com/epoupon/lms), status for version 3.42.0:

New fields:

• Album response:
  • played
  • musicBrainzId
  • genres
  • artists
  • displayArtist
  • releaseTypes
  • moods
  • originalReleaseDate
  • isCompilation
  • discTitles: discs with no subtitle are omitted
• Child response:
  • played
  • musicBrainzId: note this is actually the recording MBID when this response refers to a song
  • genres
  • artists
  • displayArtist
  • albumArtists
  • displayAlbumArtist
  • contributors
  • moods
  • replayGain
• Artist response:
  • musicBrainzId
  • sortName
  • roles

Extensions:

• Transcode offset

[Tolriq]

Anyway just synced and it works :p

[epoupon]

Nice!
By the way, not sure why we have the display album name at the song level, since it is alredy set at album level? Do we really need to repeat the info for each song?

[Tolriq]

You mean displayalbumartist? Because it's tied to the album artist on the song too. When you display the song info you can display that field without querying the album.

[Tolriq]

@epoupon Sent you a message on Symfonium forums don't know if you have notifications active there.

[epoupon]

Updated first discussion post for version v3.42.0

[dweymouth]

For Supersonic (client), status for 0.6.0 release:

• Multi-valued album artists
• Multi-valued album genres
• Multi-valued track artists

In 0.9.0 (upcoming):

• Show release types for album
• Comment column in tracklist (toggleable)

I've tested with @epoupon's LMS demo server and all looks good. @sentriz if you have your personal library set up for multi-valued tags feel free to give it a spin by building from the feature/multi-artist-genre branch. Planning on releasing this probably tomorrow as 0.6.0. ... and it's released!

[jeffvli]

For Feishin (client), status as of 0.4.1:

OpenSubsonic support is not implemented yet. Feishin still only supports Navidrome's internal API and Jellyfin API.

There are a few barriers preventing me from fully implementing OpenSubsonic in my app:

• getSongList2 endpoint -- allows for a standardized way to fetch songs instead of having to use search2 or search3
• Sort order for list endpoints -- allows for asc/desc on list endpoints
• Total record count for list endpoints -- allows for clients to determine the actual page counts instead of having to infinitely fetch
• (Optional) Additional search query parameter for getAlbumList2 and other list endpoints to search for entities matching the query (same functionality as search3 except only returns from the selected entity)

[Tolriq]

search3 can already only return songs or artists or albums if you pass the proper counts.

[jeffvli]

It does, but it doesn't provide any server-side sorting functionality.

[Tolriq]

IMO we need to think about new endpoints for the 3 types please also post in #57 if you have sort / filter needs related to the new fields too.

[lachlan-00]

I'll be implementing all the new data in Ampache 6.2. I'm just finishing 6.1 now and will move onto subsonic focus for the next major

[metalheim]

navidrome implemented
as of 0.50.0:

• musicBrainzId
• bpm
• comment

as of 0.50.1:

• genres for each album and song

[deluan]

Navidrome list is being maintained here: navidrome/navidrome#2695

This is the current list, not sure if I'll be able to maintain the list in two places in the future :)

Extensions

• getOpenSubsonicExtensions
• stream
• search3
• transcodeOffset
• formPost
• songLyrics (soon: [OS]: Lyrics extension navidrome/navidrome#2656)

New Fields

Child

• played
• bpm
• comment
• sortName
• mediaType
• musicBrainzId
• genres
• replayGain

AlbumID3

• played
• userRating
• musicBrainzId
• genres
• sortName
• isCompilation
• discTitles

ArtistID3

• musicBrainzId
• sortName

[Tolriq]

@deluan links to a maintained page is ok too, as long as we can show to other clients and servers that this is growing and they should join :)