Not possible to modify existing VIP

[Makss39]

Important notices

Before you add a new report, we ask you kindly to acknowledge the following:

• I have read the contributing guide lines at https://github.com/opnsense/core/blob/master/CONTRIBUTING.md
• I am convinced that my issue is new after having checked both open and closed issues at https://github.com/opnsense/core/issues?q=is%3Aissue

Describe the bug

Not possible to modify VIP since update to 24.1.5.

To Reproduce

Steps to reproduce the behavior:

1. Go to 'Interfaces => Virtual IPs => Settings'
2. Click on "Edit" an existing virtual IP

Expected behavior

We should be able to edit an existing virtual IP.
Everything is empty, nothing on the dropdown lists...

Describe alternatives you considered

No alternative

Screenshots

Environment

OPNsense 24.1.5_2 (amd64).

[fichtner]

Since 24.1.5 came out a couple of weeks ago and this is the first report... have you tried a different browser or inspect the browser development console for any errors?

Cheers,
Franco

[Makss39]

Same with Edge, Firefox and Chrome... Also tested on 24.1.5_3, same issue.
No errors on the browser console.

It looks like that one : #6151

[Makss39]

Hello, any hint ? Does somebody was able to reproduce it ?

Thanks !

[Monviech]

I've just spun up a fresh 24.1.6 and I can create new CARP VIPs, edit them, remove them.

Maybe run a health audit in System: Firmware, to see if you have missing files or bad checksums somewhere.

[Makss39]

I can create,edit and remove new VIP.

But it's not possible for VIP created before the update. And I cannot remove them !!!
The update has broke something...

[fichtner]

To be frank it looks like a local issue of some sort. If you want to discuss a specific code change be my guest, but "update" "broke" "something" isn't going to cut through this.

[Makss39]

I just say that I had no issue with modifiying existing VIP in 22.7.
Then I updated to 24.1.5, it does not work anymore...

So my thought is that the update is the reason why it's not working anymore...

[fichtner]

I‘m merely saying if there is a bug it’s not possible to find with the information currently given.

And since nobody chimes in and the report is for the GUI misbehaving a local browser issue is the most likely.

You’d expect the GUI/API not working at all to be a widespread issue.

[Monviech]

Can you test your API? You have to be logged into the OPNsense before you try these links.

Open this link in your browser, replace 172.16.0.254 with your IP:
https://172.16.0.254/api/interfaces/vip_settings/get

From one of the list items, select the UUID and list it, replace 211c9748-651a-40cf-bbd6-918cedd845ec with one of your UUIDs from the prior list.
https://172.16.0.254:4444/api/interfaces/vip_settings/getItem/211c9748-651a-40cf-bbd6-918cedd845ec

[Makss39]

I've found a workaround :

• Create a new CARP IP adress
• Save
  => Then you can now modify/delete previous created CARP IP adresses