www/caddy - Issue tracker for DNS Providers

[Monviech]

Important notices

Before you add a new report, we ask you kindly to acknowledge the following:

• I have read the contributing guide lines at https://github.com/opnsense/plugins/blob/master/CONTRIBUTING.md
• I have searched the existing issues, open and closed, and I'm convinced that mine is new.
• When the request is meant for an existing plugin, I've added its name to the title.

Explain the problem

This issue is for tracking the current state of DNS Providers in the os-caddy plugin.

If you have issues, need to have a DNS Provider added, or have questions, please post that in this issue, don't create a seperate issue. Please note that I don't have accounts to test any of these providers. Following the link to their current maintainer will be a good starting point.

Since the DNS Providers in caddy are a community maintained effort, it is likely that plugins become unmaintained, forgotten, or dysfunct over time. To mitigate the risk of the build of caddy-custom failing, and to make sure there aren't any exploits in the code, a retention policy is enforced.

Policy:

The less DNS providers, the better for the build to make it less bloated. Though there is no other choice, so yeah...~ Adding maintained providers is ok.

🟥 A DNS provider plugin will be removed and not be added if:

• they're unmaintained for too long (like 2-3 years of no updates)
• they make the build of caddy-custom fail
• users report errors with the functionality, and they won't be fixed
• the maintainers ignore issues or pull requests on their provider module

🟩 A DNS Provider plugin will be added if:

• it's explicitely requested
• it doesn't make the current caddy-custom build fail
• it is in the caddy-dns repository and doesn't look unmaintained

Compare this list to: https://github.com/caddy-dns

Colors explained:
🟩 - Will stay in build
🟨 - Will stay in build unless errors, though marked for deprecation if no updates are provided
🟥 - Will be removed from build in next plugin version.

Current compile status:

• 🟩 cloudflare - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟩 duckdns - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟩 gandi - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟩 ionos - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟩 desec - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟩 porkbun - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟩 route53 - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟩 acmedns - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟩 netlify - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟩 powerdns - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟩 tencentcloud - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟩 hexonet - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟩 linode - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟩 mailinabox - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟩 namecheap - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟩 azure - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟩 rfc2136 - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟩 netcup - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟩 dnsmadeeasy - os-caddy-v1.5.7+
• 🟩 bunny - os-caddy-v1.5.7+
• 🟩 civo - os-caddy-v1.5.7+
• 🟩 scaleway - os-caddy-v1.5.7+
• 🟩 acmeproxy - os-caddy-v1.5.7+
• 🟩 inwx - os-caddy-v1.5.7+
• 🟩 namedotcom - os-caddy-v1.5.7+
• 🟩 easydns - os-caddy-v1.5.7+
• 🟩 infomaniak - os-caddy-v1.5.7+
• 🟩 directadmin - os-caddy-v1.5.7+
• 🟩 hosttech - os-caddy-v1.5.7+
• 🟩 vultr - os-caddy-v1.5.7+
• 🟨 njalla - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟨 googleclouddns - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟨 digitalocean - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟨 dinahosting - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟨 ddnss - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟨 ovh - os-caddy-v1.5.6+
• 🟥 godaddy - os-caddy-v1.5.6 - removed in os-caddy-v1.5.7 (due to api changes on godaddys side that makes using it impossible)

How does the workflow look like to ensure a new DNS Provider plays nice with the rest?

• The DNS Provider should be 🟩
• OPNsense Tools have to be used and a full build of the current state of the ports has to be made. https://github.com/opnsense/tools
• Afterwards, the make.conf has to be populated with the new DNS Provider and their commit hash, compare: https://github.com/opnsense/tools/blob/dbb78c3da78eede81fc26f557f8daefbd42289e5/config/24.1/make.conf#L97
• A new build has to be triggered, building just caddy-custom with make ports-caddy-custom
• If the build is successful, then the DNS Provider can be added to the plugin.
• I already added all DNS Providers in this branch, so its just copy pasting to support them in the plugin: https://github.com/Monviech/opnsense-plugins/tree/more-dnsproviders-stached

[dMopp]

I would love to have netcup compiled. :)

[Monviech]

@dMopp Wanne try and add it? I documented what needs to be done. If you get stuck I can help.

[Monviech]

I have compiled Netcup in since it was a bit more complicated, I had to issue an upstream PR too. But now, only the Plugin GUI is left, which is just some copy pasting.

[dMopp]

I would really like to help, but to be honest i dont know where to start right now :O

[Monviech]

It's okay, I will add it next week. It'll be in the next plugin version.

• www/caddy-custom: Update dependencies of extra modules tools#410
• www/caddy: DNS Provider add netcup and RFC2136 #3998

[un73l]

Hello,
Thanks for the work. Could it be possible to have Infomaniak added ?

[Monviech]

@un73l I'll evaluate it and if the build checks out I will add it.

[Monviech]

@un73l Infomaniak and a few more will probably be in next version, build checks out.

#4032