Interaction of bundle & "critical" attribute with OSCQuery

[jcelerier]

Hello,
let's say I have the following tree :

/volume (float)
/play (bool, critical)

What happens if the user wants to create an OSC bundle with both ? The most logical thing to me would be to send everything in a single bundle over TCP, would that be fine ? (the alternative being, splitting things over TCP and UDP depending on critical-ness, but then you loose any packing that you may have wanted to keep)

[jln-]

The most logical thing to me would be to send everything in a single bundle over TCP

Agree with that.

Pinging @matcham

[jcelerier]

@matcham

I know that in theory it's possible.. but in practice who actually uses that ?

everyone who uses libossia with oscquery and the "critical" attribute set on parameters :-)

[matcham]

@jcelerier : and what about those who use osc(non-query) with other softwares that support only osc over udp ?

[jcelerier]

this topic is specifically about oscquery, which does use both TCP and UDP. If you use the osc protocol only in libossia (e.g. with [expose osc ...> then everything goes through UDP. And if you use OSCQuery then you likely use it on both sides, you're not using any udpsend / ... anywhere.

[jcelerier]

(updated the title to make that more clear)

[matcham]

ho, ok, so i don't care :-)