Radix Dialog - Events for open and close separately

[varun-raj]

Can we have separate events to trigger for onOpen and onClose in a modal?

Currently we've the onOpenChange for radix dialog that triggers whenever the dialog opens or closes. Can we bring a way to have individual events for open and close?

I've a logic for it already, if its required, I can raise a PR

[benoitgrelard]

Hi @varun-raj,

What would be the advantage of this? The current API achieves everything without bloating the API surface.

[andy-hook]

Closing this issue due to lack of activity, feel free to follow up with more information about the request though.

[TimHuynh0905]

@andy-hook it seems like the onOpenChange prop is inactive for open event. i am using this version "@radix-ui/react-dialog": "^1.0.2", any thoughts?

[benoitgrelard]

@TimHuynh0905 what do you mean? Do you have an example sandbox?

[charlesBochet]

@benoitgrelard I'm facing the same issue, onOpenChange does not seem to be triggered when open property is switching from false to true.

Here is our usage of the dialog:
https://github.com/twentyhq/twenty/blob/b982788100a95a9494e0ec961062e6faa7cf3aa2/front/src/modules/command-menu/components/CommandMenu.tsx#L18

[joaom00]

@charlesBochet onOpenChange is only triggered when the state is updated internally by Radix

[charlesBochet]

mmmh ok, thanks for the answer!