Non CRUD method on model level (was Product uri generation should be on usecase? )

[wejick]

clean-arch/sample-app/pkg/model/product/method.go

Line 16 in c92f4ea

func (p Product) getURL(baseURL string) (result string) {

I think product link uri generation should be on usecase. It needs several logic not related on how we store product, like web, mobile, applink generation.

In general I would say non crud operation should not be here, we should have it on usecase or repository level (I prefer on usecase level tho).

[wejick]

https://www.yiiframework.com/doc/guide/1.1/en/basics.model

https://www.codeigniter.com/userguide3/general/models.html

classic and simple model explanation from php world

[regalius]

For me, simple getter method for a model is fine because eventhough it would be placed in the usecase, it'll be behaving the same anyway, plus, putting the getter & setter method in the model itself would make no code duplication.

Or if we don't want to have it in the model, we 'll need to populate it on the repository level (but of course it'll consume more memory for the struct)

[wejick]

memory usage would be negligible and each storage may have different way to do it.

[regalius]

Then it is better to put it in the repository? and if usecase/delivery wants to change it then they can simply override it