Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

Results post challenge #52

Open
renault-iaa opened this issue Feb 21, 2024 · 5 comments
Open

Results post challenge #52

renault-iaa opened this issue Feb 21, 2024 · 5 comments

Comments

@renault-iaa
Copy link
Owner

renault-iaa commented Feb 21, 2024 •
edited

Hello,

A few teams (J48, S37, S41, S50) have submitted new results on instances of datasets C and X. Many thanks to them and sorry for the huge delay to publish the results.

These results were calculated without the time limitations of the challenge, except for S41 (the team sends us a new executable and we run the executable with the challenge timelimits). Solutions of 90 instances out of 155 were improved, though slightly.

The issue will remain open and we will update the table of best results whenever a team sends us new solutions.

Renault's organizing team

dataset instance best found team gap vs challenge
dataset_C AS 1730211 J48 -0,40%
dataset_C AS2 1667380 S41 -0,03%
dataset_C AS3 7796940 J48 -0,01%
dataset_C BY 10146024
dataset_C BY2 8302605
dataset_C BY3 37398381
dataset_C CA 883668 J48 -0,21%
dataset_C CA2 913780 J48 -0,21%
dataset_C CA3 3901390
dataset_C CI 4138813
dataset_C CI2 3631050
dataset_C CI3 16036421 S41 -0,07%
dataset_C CL 1757010 S41 -0,08%
dataset_C CL2 1713260
dataset_C CL3 7415781
dataset_C DO 4467910 J48 -0,37%
dataset_C DO2 3140000 S41 -0,49%
dataset_C DO3 13696781 S41 -0,04%
dataset_C FC 1152252 J48 -2,19%
dataset_C FC2 163475 S41 -0,07%
dataset_C FC3 554489 J48 -0,06%
dataset_C FL 1163908
dataset_C FL2 1172995 S41 -0,02%
dataset_C FL3 4806781
dataset_C MA 5472559
dataset_C MA2 4672130
dataset_C MA3 20463630 S41 -0,16%
dataset_C MT 1993297 J48 -0,87%
dataset_C MT2 1664330 J48 -0,62%
dataset_C MT3 6633628 S41 -0,27%
dataset_C PA 7175870
dataset_C PA2 4714660 J48 -1,11%
dataset_C PA3 20616605 J48 -1,13%
dataset_C PO 88175
dataset_C RM 3555823 J48 -2,19%
dataset_C RM2 2205030 J48 -1,44%
dataset_C RM3 10037944 J48 -1,77%
dataset_C SA 6513905 S41 -0,07%
dataset_C SA2 5620805 J48 -0,57%
dataset_C SA3 25245591
dataset_C TA 6434897 J48 -0,61%
dataset_C TA2 5860680 J48 -0,19%
dataset_C TA3 27628984 J48 -0,52%
dataset_C TR 4458282
dataset_C TR2 2697155
dataset_C TR3 11420636
dataset_C VA 7838539
dataset_C VA2 4794905 S41 -0,07%
dataset_C VA3 21338463 S41 -0,01%
dataset_C VO 1250382
dataset_X AS 1912475
dataset_X AS2 2078185 S41 -0,25%
dataset_X AS3 9196363
dataset_X AS4 1938465 S41 -0,09%
dataset_X AS5 2109155 S41 -0,20%
dataset_X AS6 9297347
dataset_X AS7 1907602 S41 -0,36%
dataset_X BY 9267865 S41 -0,10%
dataset_X BY2 9693175 S41 -0,14%
dataset_X BY3 44619432
dataset_X BY4 9705520 S41 -0,11%
dataset_X BY5 10129640
dataset_X BY6 47153751 S41 -0,12%
dataset_X BY7 9257853 S41 -0,50%
dataset_X CC 639891 J48 -0,18%
dataset_X CC2 693985 J48 -0,54%
dataset_X CC3 2982656
dataset_X CC4 672708 J48 -0,67%
dataset_X CC5 743755 J48 -0,30%
dataset_X CC6 3115470
dataset_X CC7 661123 J48 -1,36%
dataset_X CI 5142787
dataset_X CI2 5447635
dataset_X CI3 24827870
dataset_X CI4 4457095
dataset_X CI5 4732565
dataset_X CI6 21552916
dataset_X CI7 4396161 S41 -0,50%
dataset_X DO 1617307 S41 -0,16%
dataset_X DO2 1717480 S41 -0,14%
dataset_X DO3 7749916
dataset_X DO4 1266226 S41 -0,14%
dataset_X DO5 1353105 S41 -0,20%
dataset_X DO6 6038350
dataset_X DO7 1241394 S41 -0,55%
dataset_X FC 1053830 J48 -2,29%
dataset_X FC2 1110100 J48 -2,64%
dataset_X FC3 5032659 J48 -2,92%
dataset_X FC4 907285 J48 -3,66%
dataset_X FC5 964370 J48 -3,10%
dataset_X FC6 4381218 J48 -2,21%
dataset_X FC7 899177 J48 -1,17%
dataset_X FS 719453 J48 -0,08%
dataset_X FS2 779685 J48 -0,55%
dataset_X FS3 3303243
dataset_X FS4 759233 S41 -0,15%
dataset_X FS5 834320 J48 -0,44%
dataset_X FS6 3447487
dataset_X FS7 735662 S41 -0,23%
dataset_X MA 4239687
dataset_X MA2 4561805 S41 -0,21%
dataset_X MA3 20110235 J48 -0,34%
dataset_X MA4 4289540 S41 -0,07%
dataset_X MA5 4611170 S41 -0,10%
dataset_X MA6 20412412 J48 -0,26%
dataset_X MA7 4225156 S41 -0,76%
dataset_X MT 1502474 J48 -0,76%
dataset_X MT2 1654470 J48 -0,67%
dataset_X MT3 6703811
dataset_X MT4 1311999 J48 -0,92%
dataset_X MT5 1451685 J48 -0,10%
dataset_X MT6 5902719
dataset_X MT7 1294540 J48 -1,24%
dataset_X PA 24995
dataset_X PA2 27560
dataset_X PA3 93749
dataset_X PA4 26315
dataset_X PA5 29100
dataset_X PA6 101480
dataset_X PA7 26315 S41 -0,01%
dataset_X RM 3020110 J48 -2,62%
dataset_X RM2 3134185 J48 -3,16%
dataset_X RM3 15114409
dataset_X RM4 2531322 J48 -2,53%
dataset_X RM5 2655945 J48 -2,36%
dataset_X RM6 12386081 J48 -2,26%
dataset_X RM7 2522711
dataset_X SA 5451463 S41 -0,04%
dataset_X SA2 5799000 J48 -0,22%
dataset_X SA3 25929188 S41 -0,02%
dataset_X SA4 5524696 S41 -0,05%
dataset_X SA5 5879000 S41 -0,12%
dataset_X SA6 26215218
dataset_X SA7 5436070 S41 -0,95%
dataset_X TA 893617
dataset_X TA2 920825 S41 -0,43%
dataset_X TA3 4427097
dataset_X TA4 947158 S41 -0,05%
dataset_X TA5 976455 S41 -0,18%
dataset_X TA6 4699366
dataset_X TA7 862386 S41 -1,40%
dataset_X TR 5024090
dataset_X TR2 5311800
dataset_X TR3 24220074
dataset_X TR4 5471247
dataset_X TR5 5829965 S41 -0,29%
dataset_X TR6 26173887
dataset_X TR7 5278261
dataset_X VA 31344
dataset_X VA2 38745
dataset_X VA3 120024
dataset_X VA4 29701
dataset_X VA5 36755
dataset_X VA6 119006
dataset_X VA7 29101
@renault-iaa
Copy link
Owner Author

Update with new best solutions from J48 👍 :

dataset instance best found team gap vs challenge
dataset_C AS 1730211 J48 -0,40%
dataset_C AS2 1667380 S41 -0,03%
dataset_C AS3 7787276 J48 -0,14%
dataset_C BY 9918111 J48 -2,25%
dataset_C BY2 8138065 J48 -1,98%
dataset_C BY3 36845021 J48 -1,48%
dataset_C CA 883668 J48 -0,21%
dataset_C CA2 913780 J48 -0,21%
dataset_C CA3 3901390
dataset_C CI 4138813
dataset_C CI2 3631050
dataset_C CI3 16036421 S41 -0,07%
dataset_C CL 1753878 J48 -0,26%
dataset_C CL2 1713260
dataset_C CL3 7415781
dataset_C DO 4467910 J48 -0,37%
dataset_C DO2 3140000 S41 -0,49%
dataset_C DO3 13686576 J48 -0,12%
dataset_C FC 1133276 J48 -3,80%
dataset_C FC2 163475 S41 -0,07%
dataset_C FC3 554489 J48 -0,06%
dataset_C FL 1163908
dataset_C FL2 1172425 J48 -0,07%
dataset_C FL3 4806781
dataset_C MA 5423369 J48 -0,90%
dataset_C MA2 4672130
dataset_C MA3 20449411 J48 -0,23%
dataset_C MT 1993297 J48 -0,87%
dataset_C MT2 1664330 J48 -0,62%
dataset_C MT3 6633628 S41 -0,27%
dataset_C PA 6980499 J48 -2,72%
dataset_C PA2 4705825 J48 -1,29%
dataset_C PA3 20496178 J48 -1,71%
dataset_C PO 88175
dataset_C RM 3540348 J48 -2,62%
dataset_C RM2 2205030 J48 -1,44%
dataset_C RM3 10037944 J48 -1,77%
dataset_C SA 6481692 J48 -0,57%
dataset_C SA2 5611870 J48 -0,73%
dataset_C SA3 25130340 J48 -0,46%
dataset_C TA 6409441 J48 -1,01%
dataset_C TA2 5840810 J48 -0,53%
dataset_C TA3 27628984 J48 -0,52%
dataset_C TR 4410625 J48 -1,07%
dataset_C TR2 2697155
dataset_C TR3 11328863 J48 -0,80%
dataset_C VA 7629924 J48 -2,66%
dataset_C VA2 4794905 S41 -0,07%
dataset_C VA3 21197731 J48 -0,67%
dataset_C VO 1235861 J48 -1,16%
dataset_X AS 1912475
dataset_X AS2 2078185 S41 -0,25%
dataset_X AS3 9196363
dataset_X AS4 1938465 S41 -0,09%
dataset_X AS5 2109155 S41 -0,20%
dataset_X AS6 9297347
dataset_X AS7 1907602 S41 -0,36%
dataset_X BY 9022315 J48 -2,74%
dataset_X BY2 9556155 J48 -1,55%
dataset_X BY3 43368997 J48 -2,80%
dataset_X BY4 9472113 J48 -2,51%
dataset_X BY5 9998530 J48 -1,29%
dataset_X BY6 45672944 J48 -3,26%
dataset_X BY7 9247943 J48 -0,61%
dataset_X CC 637182 J48 -0,61%
dataset_X CC2 693985 J48 -0,54%
dataset_X CC3 2978029 J48 -0,16%
dataset_X CC4 670592 J48 -0,98%
dataset_X CC5 743755 J48 -0,30%
dataset_X CC6 3115470
dataset_X CC7 659151 J48 -1,66%
dataset_X CI 5103347 J48 -0,77%
dataset_X CI2 5422670 J48 -0,46%
dataset_X CI3 24613915 J48 -0,86%
dataset_X CI4 4440005 J48 -0,38%
dataset_X CI5 4732565
dataset_X CI6 21453582 J48 -0,46%
dataset_X CI7 4363837 J48 -1,23%
dataset_X DO 1617307 S41 -0,16%
dataset_X DO2 1717480 S41 -0,14%
dataset_X DO3 7749916 S41 0,00%
dataset_X DO4 1266226 S41 -0,14%
dataset_X DO5 1353105 S41 -0,20%
dataset_X DO6 6038350 S41 0,00%
dataset_X DO7 1241394 S41 -0,55%
dataset_X FC 1043145 J48 -3,28%
dataset_X FC2 1105720 J48 -3,02%
dataset_X FC3 5032659 J48 -2,92%
dataset_X FC4 907285 J48 -3,66%
dataset_X FC5 964370 J48 -3,10%
dataset_X FC6 4381218 J48 -2,21%
dataset_X FC7 897389 J48 -1,37%
dataset_X FS 719453 J48 -0,08%
dataset_X FS2 779685 J48 -0,55%
dataset_X FS3 3303243
dataset_X FS4 759233 S41 -0,15%
dataset_X FS5 834320 J48 -0,44%
dataset_X FS6 3447487
dataset_X FS7 735662 S41 -0,23%
dataset_X MA 4226469 J48 -0,31%
dataset_X MA2 4561805 S41 -0,21%
dataset_X MA3 20032023 J48 -0,73%
dataset_X MA4 4285417 J48 -0,17%
dataset_X MA5 4597565 J48 -0,39%
dataset_X MA6 20225094 J48 -1,18%
dataset_X MA7 4216143 J48 -0,97%
dataset_X MT 1502474 J48 -0,76%
dataset_X MT2 1654470 J48 -0,67%
dataset_X MT3 6703811
dataset_X MT4 1311999 J48 -0,92%
dataset_X MT5 1451685 J48 -0,10%
dataset_X MT6 5902719
dataset_X MT7 1294540 J48 -1,24%
dataset_X PA 24995
dataset_X PA2 27560
dataset_X PA3 93749
dataset_X PA4 26315
dataset_X PA5 29100
dataset_X PA6 101480
dataset_X PA7 26315 S41 -0,01%
dataset_X RM 3005575 J48 -3,09%
dataset_X RM2 3110305 J48 -3,90%
dataset_X RM3 14633310 J48 -3,18%
dataset_X RM4 2516136 J48 -3,11%
dataset_X RM5 2613845 J48 -3,91%
dataset_X RM6 12314093 J48 -2,82%
dataset_X RM7 2472914 J48 -1,97%
dataset_X SA 5447504 J48 -0,11%
dataset_X SA2 5773970 J48 -0,65%
dataset_X SA3 25867322 J48 -0,26%
dataset_X SA4 5504704 J48 -0,41%
dataset_X SA5 5859960 J48 -0,44%
dataset_X SA6 26150053 J48 -0,25%
dataset_X SA7 5432068 J48 -0,84%
dataset_X TA 887752 J48 -0,66%
dataset_X TA2 905690 J48 -2,06%
dataset_X TA3 4398685 J48 -0,64%
dataset_X TA4 939593 J48 -0,85%
dataset_X TA5 962910 J48 -1,57%
dataset_X TA6 4651210 J48 -1,02%
dataset_X TA7 862386 S41 -1,40%
dataset_X TR 4920669 J48 -2,06%
dataset_X TR2 5170445 J48 -2,66%
dataset_X TR3 23826976 J48 -1,62%
dataset_X TR4 5342769 J48 -2,35%
dataset_X TR5 5665580 J48 -3,10%
dataset_X TR6 25758966 J48 -1,59%
dataset_X TR7 5278261
dataset_X VA 31344
dataset_X VA2 38745
dataset_X VA3 120024
dataset_X VA4 29701
dataset_X VA5 36755
dataset_X VA6 119006
dataset_X VA7 29101

@renault-iaa
Copy link
Owner Author

The solution files associated with the best results on datasets C and X. Each dataset was compressed into several archives due to size limitations for upload.

dataset_C_1.zip
dataset_C_2.zip
dataset_C_3.zip
dataset_X_1.zip
dataset_X_2.zip
dataset_X_3.zip
dataset_X_4.zip
dataset_X_5.zip

@fontanf
Copy link

fontanf commented Apr 28, 2024

In solution C/BY3, stack P081065711_7 doesn't seem to be supported.

P081065711 Id stack Stack code X origin Y origin Z origin X extremity Y extremity Z extremity
P081065711 P081065711_4 D 1600 1200 0 3200 2400 1200
P081065711 P081065711_5 E 3200 0 0 4800 1200 1200
P081065711 P081065711_6 F 4800 0 0 6400 1200 1200
P081065711 P081065711_7 G 4800 1200 0 6400 2400 1200

@renault-iaa
Copy link
Owner Author

Hello @fontanf, you are right, the stack G should be considered not supported. But according to the challenge specifications, the checker considers that stack G is adjacent to stack E ... because they share one common point. The constraint P3 is satisfied with s1=stack G and s2=stack E. There is somewhat a loophole in the specifications.
image

image

@fontanf
Copy link

fontanf commented Apr 30, 2024

Indeed, you're right. I should have read the constraint more carefully. Intuitively, that didn't look "supported".

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
Development

No branches or pull requests
2 participants
@fontanf @renault-iaa