Update-firmware not working for Roborock S5

[esnovo]

Describe the bug

I've build a new firmware image and when I try to update roborock using mirobo nothing happens:

Without debug

$ mirobo --ip 172.162.2.15 --token xxxxxxxxxx update-firmware 'http://xx.xx.xx.xx/vacuum_2034_valetudo_2021_03_0.pkg' '174e4db6ae270581a2b9a6cb4d8acc5c'
Going to update from http://xx.xx.xx.xx/vacuum_2034_valetudo_2021_03_0.pkg
Using http://xx.xx.xx.xx/vacuum_2034_valetudo_2021_03_0.pkg (md5: 174e4db6ae270581a2b9a6cb4d8acc5c)
Update started!
0%|
$

Debug enabled:

$ mirobo -d --ip 172.162.2.15 --token xxxxxxxxxx update-firmware 'http://xx.xx.xx.xx/vacuum_2034_valetudo_2021_03_0.pkg' '174e4db6ae270581a2b9a6cb4d8acc5c'
INFO:miio.vacuum_cli:Debug mode active
DEBUG:miio.vacuum_cli:Read stored sequence ids: {'seq': 120, 'manual_seq': 0}
DEBUG:miio.vacuum_cli:Connecting to 172.162.2.15 with token xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Going to update from http://xx.xx.xx.xx/vacuum_2034_valetudo_2021_03_0.pkg
Using http://xx.xx.xx.xx/vacuum_2034_valetudo_2021_03_0.pkg (md5: 174e4db6ae270581a2b9a6cb4d8acc5c)
DEBUG:miio.protocol:Unable to decrypt, returning raw bytes: b''
DEBUG:miio.miioprotocol:Got a response: Container:
data = Container:
data = b'' (total 0)
value = b'' (total 0)
offset1 = 32
offset2 = 32
length = 0
header = Container:
data = b'!1\x00 \x00\x00\x00\x00\x04p\x9a\xe5a\xf1' (total 16)
value = Container:
length = 32
unknown = 0
device_id = unhexlify('04709ae5')
ts = 2021-03-29 15:25:20
offset1 = 0
offset2 = 16
length = 16
checksum = b'\xff\xff\xff\xff\xff\xff\xff\xff\xff\xff\xff\xff\xff\xff\xff\xff' (total 16)
DEBUG:miio.miioprotocol:Discovered 04709ae5 with ts: 2021-03-29 15:25:20, token: b'ffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff'
DEBUG:miio.miioprotocol:172.162.2.15:54321 >>: {'id': 121, 'method': 'miIO.ota', 'params': {'mode': 'normal', 'install': '1', 'app_url': 'http://xx.xx.xx.xx/vacuum_2034_valetudo_2021_03_0.pkg', 'file_md5': '174e4db6ae270581a2b9a6cb4d8acc5c', 'proc': 'dnld install'}}
DEBUG:miio.miioprotocol:172.162.2.15:54321 (ts: 2021-03-29 15:25:20, id: 121) << {'result': ['ok'], 'id': 121}
Update started!
0%| | 0/100 [00:00<?, ?it/s]DEBUG:miio.miioprotocol:172.16s.2.15:54321 >>: {'id': 122, 'method': 'miIO.get_ota_state', 'params': []}
DEBUG:miio.miioprotocol:172.162.2.15:54321 (ts: 2021-03-29 15:25:20, id: 122) << {'result': ['idle'], 'id': 122}
0%| | 0/100 [00:00<?, ?it/s]
DEBUG:miio.vacuum_cli:Writing {'seq': 122, 'manual_seq': 0} to /home/john/.cache/python-miio/python-mirobo.seq

$

When I try to troubleshoot the error and ssh into the roborock looking for logs I don't find anything relevant.
When issuing the command "miio_recv_line" I see the command is being issued correctly:

{"method":"miIO.ota","params":{"mode":"normal","install":"1","app_url":"http://xx.xx.xx.xx/vacuum_2034_valetudo_2021_03_0.pkg","file_md5":"174e4db6ae270581a2b9a6cb4d8acc5c","proc":"dnld install"},"id":414798309}

But nothing happens and no request is made to the HTTP server to retrieve the image. The update simply fails without any error.

Unfortunately due to firewall restrictions I can only install the firmware remotely and not locally. So there aren't any other possibilities.

Version information (please complete the following information):

• OS: Fedora Linux
• python-miio: miiocli, version 0.5.5.2

Device information:
If the issue is specific to a device [Use miiocli device --ip <ip address> --token <token> info]:

• Model: roborock.vacuum.s5
• Hardware version: Linux
• Firmware version: 3.5.8_002020

To Reproduce
Steps to reproduce the behavior:

1. Invoke mirobo --ip xx.xx.xx.xx --token xxxxxxxxxx update-firmware 'http://xx.xx.xx.xx/vacuum_2034_valetudo_2021_03_0.pkg' 'md5sum' in order to trigger an update.

Expected behavior
The update should start and one should be able to observe a request being made on the HTTP server to retrieve the firmware image.

All other commands though mirobo works without any issues.

[rytilahti]

Are the devices in the same network? Also, iirc, some (newer) firmwares disabled firmware updates from local network as a hardening measure, which may be the case here.

[winebob]

I'm having the same issue (2034 firmware). Any idea what the latest firmware that still supports updating on a local network?

[esnovo]

Was able to solve this by doing a reset and by unprovisioning the robot. After this I was finally able to update it on through my local network.

[rytilahti]

Okay, let's close this then! 👍 @winebob, did you do a reset and try to do the update on non-provisioned device? If not, you should try that out. Alas, I haven't seen anyone keeping track of information about changes between versions, so the question when this blocked is not easy to answer.

[winebob]

I tried the build setting --enable-local-ota which solved my issue, missed that option before.