Skip to content
Switch branches/tags
Go to file
Cannot retrieve contributors at this time
51 lines (37 sloc) 2.24 KB

SCP-002: Migration path to Dotty for Scalac users


Proposed by Timothy Perrett and Jonathan Perry, Verizon and Goldman Sachs respectively, 30th June 2016.


The forthcoming release of Dotty leaves a large question mark over how existing users of Scala will migrate to what is essentially, Scala 3.0. This currently has a large unknown factor for users of Scalac; not knowing the time or cost of any potential upgrade. Moreover, without a path to migrate existing code bases, the Scala community could be facing a similar split that was experienced by Python with 2.x vs 3.x, which everyone agrees is undesirable and not in the best interests of the overall Scala community.


In order to mitigate the potential risk to users of Scalac with regards to the migration, we propose a multi-pronged effort:

  1. The invested entities behind Dotty make a concerted effort to have existing Scalac codebases be entirely compatible with Dotty, such that a migrating user has zero (or at least minimal) work required to migrate. This could be achieved either via altering Scalac to be Dotty compliant or altering Dotty / Dotty bridge to accept byte code produced from existing 2.x Scalac.

  2. We request and encourage that EPFL/Scala Center/Lightbend specifically enumerate any deltas vs scalac, such that a migrating user would be able to understand the cost of upgrading to Dotty explicitly, before embarking on any such migration.

  3. Many commercial entities would likely feel more at ease about a migration if a path existed for said entities to pay for certain features - or bugs - to be corrected in a timely manner, in order to migrate their code without source changes. What might this look like and whom would the commercial entity doing the work be? (Ownership of Dotty between EPFL and Lightbend is not clear)


Costs unknown by proposers, as extensive knowledge of the internals of both Scalac and Dotty are required to make fair estimate.


It would be good if this proposal was available shortly after any official release of Dotty, as the probability of fragmenting the community - Python style - increases exponentially month over month, once Dotty is released (i.e. libraries migrate to Dotty, and abandon their Scalac users).