Only prefix commands show up in help menu

[vicky5124]

If a context menu command is registered, it will not show up in help, even if it's also allowed to run as a slash or prefix command, though, that should probably not matter and show up anyway.

/// Test
#[poise::command(context_menu_command = "Test", slash_command, prefix_command)]
pub async fn test(
    ctx: Context<'_>,
    #[description = "test"] _user: User,
) -> CommandResult {
    Ok(())
}

Commands:
  /help        Show this menu
  
Test bottom text

Running /help test doesn't work either, saying "No such command test"

[kangalio]

Hmm, I cannot reproduce. The /test command shows up in the help menu and /help test works too.

Did you add the command to the framework with .command(test(), |f| f)?

[vicky5124]

On further investigation, i appears to show up only if prefix_command is added to the macro, if it's just context menu by itself or cm+slash command, it won't show up.

[kangalio]

That checks out. The help command currently iterates through the prefix commands only. My logic was that the user can already see all slash commands and context menu commands within the Discord UI.

Though it's probably better to show all commands, that's less surprising. I'll add it to the todo list

[vicky5124]

This issue is not over, context menu commands don't show up.
And as an additional issue, dynamic prefixes don't show in help either.

And I have a feeling that over 1 in length prefixes will not align the description text.

[kangalio]

Technically, these are three separate issues 😄 I'll see if I can fix them quickly

[kangalio]

What do you think of this output for context menu commands?

Commands:
  /help        Show this help menu
  /vote        Vote for something
  /getvotes    Retrieve number of votes
  /add         Add two numbers
  /choice      Dummy command to test slash command choice parameters
  /boop        Boop the bot!
  /delete      Deletes the given message
  /user_info   Query information about a Discord profile
  /echo        Echo content of a message
  /greet       Greet a user. Showcasing autocomplete!

Context menu commands:
  User information (on user)
  Echo (on message)

This is an example bot made to showcase features of my custom Discord bot framework

[vicky5124]

Great! But, how will it fair with command descriptions? How does /help command name get affected by this? Will it be case-insensitive, or will the user have to write the command name entirely as is?

[kangalio]

Good point, thanks for noticing that. I made it case-insensitive, and you can refer to commands by either their prefix, slash, or context menu name

[kangalio]

Implemented in f533fdd d016c78 90a1ef0 c90727c