Right way to imply a checksum

[shirok1]

Hello, I've been porting a network protocol to Rust using deku recently, replacing handwritten macros. In this protocol, there are two checksum fields, one is a CRC16 for header and one is a CRC32 in the tail. I tried using custom writer with temp tag, result in the field being completely ignored during writing. I also tried using bits = "16" or pad_bits_after = "16" with a () type, but the corresponding bytes are not jumped. Is there a best practice to imply such thing?

[sharksforarms]

Are you able to provide an example of what you have and what you expect? I don't want to make assumptions on your format :)

[shirok1]

Actually the protocol definition is available on GitHub: https://github.com/Livox-SDK/Livox-SDK/wiki/Livox-SDK-Communication-Protocol#21-frame-format

My current code is like this:

#[deku_derive(DekuRead, DekuWrite)]
#[derive(Debug)]
#[deku(magic = b"\xAA")]
pub struct DekuControlFrame {
    // ///    Starting Byte, Fixed to be 0xAA
    // #[deku(temp)]
    // #[deku(assert_eq = "0xAA")]
    // magic: u8,

    /// Protocol Version, 1 for The Current Version
    pub version: u8,

    /// Length of The Frame, Max Value: 1400
    // #[deku(temp)]
    length: u16,

    /// Command Type:
    /// 0x00: CMD
    /// 0x01: ACK
    /// 0x02: MSG
    // #[deku(temp)]
    cmd_type: u8,

    /// Frame Sequence Number
    pub seq_num: u16,

    /// Frame Header Checksum
    // #[deku(temp)]
    #[deku(
    // bits = "16",
    writer = "checksum_write_16(deku::output)"
    )]
    crc_16: u16,

    /// Payload Data
    #[deku(ctx = "*cmd_type")]
    // #[deku(count = "cmd_type")]
    pub data: FrameData,

    /// Whole Frame Checksum
    // #[deku(temp)]
    #[deku(
    // bits = "32",
    writer = "checksum_write_32(deku::output)"
    )]
    crc_32: u32,
}

fn checksum_write_16(
    output: &mut BitVec<u8, Msb0>,
) -> Result<(), DekuError> {
    // writeln!()
    // dbg!(&output);
    CRC16.checksum(
        output.as_raw_slice()
    ).write(output, ())
}

fn checksum_write_32(
    output: &mut BitVec<u8, Msb0>,
) -> Result<(), DekuError> {
    CRC32.checksum(
        output.as_raw_slice()
    ).write(output, ())
}

[sharksforarms]

This looks okay to me...

but the corresponding bytes are not jumped

what do you mean by this?

Here's an example, it may help you. If you can provide a minimal reproduction that I can run I may be able to help debug.

use deku::bitvec::{BitVec, Msb0};
use deku::prelude::*;
use std::convert::TryInto;

#[derive(Debug, PartialEq, DekuRead, DekuWrite)]
struct DekuTest {
    a: u8,
    b: u8,

    #[deku(writer = "checksum1(deku::output)")]
    sum1: u16,

    #[deku(count = "2")]
    data: Vec<u8>,

    #[deku(writer = "checksum2(deku::output)")]
    sum2: u32,
}

fn checksum1(output: &mut BitVec<u8, Msb0>) -> Result<(), DekuError> {
    let sum: u16 = output.as_raw_slice().iter().map(|v| *v as u16).sum();
    sum.write(output, ())
}

fn checksum2(output: &mut BitVec<u8, Msb0>) -> Result<(), DekuError> {
    let sum: u32 = output.as_raw_slice().iter().map(|v| *v as u32).sum();
    sum.write(output, ())
}

fn main() {
    let test_data: &[u8] = [
        1, 2, // a and b as u8
        3, 0, // sum1 as u16 little endian (1+2 == 3)
        1, 2, // data as u8
        9, 0, 0, 0 // sum2 as u32 little endian (1+2+3+1+2 == 9)
    ].as_ref();

    let (_rest, ret_read) = DekuTest::from_bytes((test_data, 0)).unwrap();

    assert_eq!(
        ret_read,
        DekuTest {
            a: 1,
            b: 2,
            sum1: 3,
            data: vec![1, 2],
            sum2: 9
        }
    );

    let ret_write: Vec<u8> = ret_read.try_into().unwrap();
    assert_eq!(test_data.to_vec(), ret_write);
}

[shirok1]

Well, I want to hide the checksum or make it unchangeable (by using () unit type as field type) to point out that checksum should be automatically generated, while making every field in this struct public (mainly for struct initializer)

[sharksforarms]

Ah interesting use case! Thanks for explaining furthur.

I created a branch with some changes to be able to use temp attribute with a custom writer

You can try it out by changing the dependency:

deku = { git = "https://github.com/sharksforarms/deku.git", branch = "sharksforarms/temp-write" }

Here is the new example I came up with. Let me know if this matches your use-case.

use deku::bitvec::{BitVec, Msb0};
use deku::prelude::*;
use std::convert::TryInto;

#[deku_derive(DekuRead, DekuWrite)]
#[derive(Debug, PartialEq)]
struct DekuTest {
    a: u8,
    b: u8,

    #[deku(writer = "checksum1(deku::output)")]
    #[deku(temp)]
    sum1: (),

    #[deku(count = "2")]
    data: Vec<u8>,

    #[deku(writer = "checksum2(deku::output)")]
    #[deku(temp)]
    sum2: (),
}

fn checksum1(output: &mut BitVec<u8, Msb0>) -> Result<(), DekuError> {
    let sum: u16 = output.as_raw_slice().iter().map(|v| *v as u16).sum();
    sum.write(output, ())
}

fn checksum2(output: &mut BitVec<u8, Msb0>) -> Result<(), DekuError> {
    let sum: u32 = output.as_raw_slice().iter().map(|v| *v as u32).sum();
    sum.write(output, ())
}

fn main() {
    let test_data_read: &[u8] = [
        1, 2, // a and b as u8
        1, 2, // data as u8
    ]
    .as_ref();

    let test_data_write: &[u8] = [
        1, 2, // a and b as u8
        3, 0, // sum1 as u16 little endian (1+2 == 3)
        1, 2, // data as u8
        9, 0, 0, 0, // sum2 as u32 little endian (1+2+3+1+2 == 9)
    ]
    .as_ref();

    let (_rest, ret_read) = DekuTest::from_bytes((test_data_read, 0)).unwrap();

    assert_eq!(
        ret_read,
        DekuTest {
            a: 1,
            b: 2,
            data: vec![1, 2],
        }
    );

    let ret_write: Vec<u8> = ret_read.try_into().unwrap();
    assert_eq!(test_data_write.to_vec(), ret_write);
}

[shirok1]

Wow, thanks for the amazing job! It works just like how I imagined.

By the way, is it possible to make context parameter tempable too? If so, I can make my cmd_type field #[deku(temp)] too, which is used as an ID in FrameData enum of [CMD, ACK, MSG].

PPS. What about the length field, which presents the whole length of the encoded bytes, can it be implied using deku too? I currently directly write it into the buffer after the encode process.

[sharksforarms]

Wow, thanks for the amazing job! It works just like how I imagined.

By the way, is it possible to make context parameter tempable too? If so, I can make my cmd_type field #[deku(temp)] too, which is used as an ID in FrameData enum of [CMD, ACK, MSG].

PPS. What about the length field, which presents the whole length of the encoded bytes, can it be implied using deku too? I currently directly write it into the buffer after the encode process.

The thing with temp is that we remove the field entirely from the AST at compilation. That means we cannot store the result, such as cmd_type and length. Maybe the update attribute better suites your usecase for these?

[shirok1]

Hello, I wonder if sharksforarms/temp-write is going to be merged to main?

[wcampbell0x2a]

Hello, I wonder if sharksforarms/temp-write is going to be merged to main?

Did this MR fix your issues? #322

[shirok1]

Sorry, I haven't been around this project until now 😢

And I found a bug when using it with context(#[deku(ctx}]). In the generated DekuContainerWrite::to_bits, the rest properties are references and passed to DekuWrite::write as references, temp properties are values, and use & inline in DekuWrite::write's arg list. However, ctx won't distinguish them, causing either a "type XXX cannot be dereferenced" (if writing * in ctx) or "mismatched types, expected XXX, found &XXX" (if not).

My code:

#[deku(temp, temp_value = "self.data.deku_id()?")]
pub cmd_id: u16,

#[deku(ctx = "*cmd_id, *cmd_type")]
pub data: command::Data,

Expands to:

While I could simply change type in ctx to reference, I don't think a reference to such a small number is something elegant... 😴

[sharksforarms]

Would this be a minimal reproduction?

use deku::prelude::*;
use std::convert::TryInto;

#[deku_derive(DekuRead, DekuWrite)]
#[derive(Debug, PartialEq)]
#[deku(ctx = "field1: u8, field2: u8")]
struct Child {
}

#[deku_derive(DekuRead, DekuWrite)]
#[derive(Debug, PartialEq)]
struct Parent {
    pub field1: u8,

    #[deku(temp, temp_value = "self.field1")]
    pub field2: u8,

    #[deku(ctx = "*field1, *field2")]
    pub field3: Child
}

fn main() {
    let value = Parent {
        field1: 0x01,
        field3: Child {}
    };
    let value: Vec<u8> = value.try_into().unwrap();
    assert_eq!(vec![0x01], value);
}

I don't have time to work on this at the moment, cc: @SneakyBerry maybe they have ideas

[SneakyBerry]

@sharksforarms thanks for mentioning and minimal reproduction. I'll do some research and provide MR.

[shirok1]

@SneakyBerry Hello, have you get any progress there?

[SneakyBerry]

@shirok1 Hi! Check this. Will it work for you?