Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Logo #105

Closed
skypjack opened this issue Jun 25, 2018 · 35 comments
Closed

Logo #105

skypjack opened this issue Jun 25, 2018 · 35 comments
Assignees
Labels
discussion it sounds interesting, let's discuss it documentation docs related issues/requests help wanted I don't have the knowledge/resources to do that

Comments

@skypjack
Copy link
Owner

Hi all,

I just realized that we need a logo for EnTT. :-)
Because the library is made out of the ideas of its users, it would be great if the same happens also for the logo!!
Someone wants to suggest something or make a contribution directly with an image?
It would be really appreciated!!

Thank you very much for your help!!

@skypjack skypjack self-assigned this Jun 25, 2018
@skypjack skypjack added discussion it sounds interesting, let's discuss it documentation docs related issues/requests help wanted I don't have the knowledge/resources to do that labels Jun 25, 2018
@indianakernick
Copy link
Contributor

Since this is a library that is primarily used for the creation of games, I think some pixel art is in order.

@ArnCarveris
Copy link

@Kerndog73 Agree.

Example of minimalist logo of: raylib

@indianakernick
Copy link
Contributor

indianakernick commented Jun 26, 2018

This is why I call myself a programmer and not an artist!

entt_512

The idea was that there are three circles. A circle for entities, a circle for components and a circle for systems. Where the three circles overlap, we have EnTT, which joins the three concepts together. A good logo needs a little bit of symbolism but the bright colors are a bit over-the-top and it kind of looks like EnTT is a graphics library or something. I think minimal pixel art is the way to go.

Maybe this will inspire a real artist to have a crack!

@skypjack
Copy link
Owner Author

@Kerndog73 Really, really appreciated!! Come on guys, make your proposal!! :-)

@ArnCarveris
Copy link

@skypjack It's okay?
image

@skypjack
Copy link
Owner Author

@ArnCarveris It could be ok, of course. Actually, both your images could work.. Let's see if others want to participate before to decide!! ;-)

@mario-deluna
Copy link

mario-deluna commented Jun 26, 2018

Maybe something simple:

entt0

A Penrose triangle:

entt3

Ant as a foundation for your game:

entt

Multiple components working with each other:

entt1

Its a circle there is no meaning here:

entt2

@ArnCarveris
Copy link

@mario-deluna Vote for A Penrose triangle

@skypjack
Copy link
Owner Author

@mario-deluna I really, really love the one with the circle, even if it has no meaning. Thank you very much for these amazing images!!

@m-waka
Copy link
Contributor

m-waka commented Jun 27, 2018

I'm also no artist. But tried to mix my favourite ideas from @mario-deluna, @ArnCarveris and @Kerndog73 up a little bit with inkscape:
entt_proposal
entt_proposal_bw
The circles as the entity in the center and the Components surrounding it loosely:
entt_proposal2
entt_proposal2_bw
But I think this should probably better be done by an artist. 😄

@eliacoan
Copy link

eliacoan commented Jun 27, 2018

Mixed something already in here :-)

entt

@eliacoan
Copy link

eliacoan commented Jun 27, 2018

Another take, seeing you like the circle idea!
entt_2

@eliacoan
Copy link

Last one, sorry for the flooding, hope you'll find your logo! 😄
entt_3

@iderik
Copy link

iderik commented Jun 27, 2018

I like the one with three triangles next to each other, because it looks like building blocks (components).

@skypjack
Copy link
Owner Author

@eliacoan Flooding?? Absolutely!! You're welcome and thank you, really thank you for participating!!
Feel free to flood if you have something else to propose, I'll keep the issue open for another couple of days probably. 👍

@m-waka
Copy link
Contributor

m-waka commented Jun 27, 2018

Just a small variation:
entt_proposal3
entt_proposal3_bw

@skypjack
Copy link
Owner Author

@m-waka I know I'm asking much to you, but I think it would be great also something along your line with the E on the left, three circles on the right in a column with the letters N, T, T within them, everything within the external frame. What about?

@m-waka
Copy link
Contributor

m-waka commented Jun 28, 2018

Ok, this is how I interpret your description:
entt_proposal5
entt_proposal5_bw
But I like this a bit more:
entt_proposal4
entt_proposal4_bw

@richardbmx
Copy link

richardbmx commented Jun 30, 2018

Hello my name is Richard I am a graphic designer and I like to make open source contributions, I see that you are looking for a logo for your app, I would like to present my proposal and if you like I send all the files you need to use it.

Inspired by the current logo of the three circles I have given a more modern and current form which incorporates the letters ENTT and the three circles without closing in its entirety using the three colors of the original logo.

logo87

If you want any change or other variation of the logo do not hesitate to ask

Regards..

@dbacchet
Copy link

@richardbmx they look great! I particularly like the first and the forth (same logo with color and solid black).

@richardbmx
Copy link

@dbacchet Good thing you really like it is the same logo but in different variations that guarantees that the logo is functional

@skypjack
Copy link
Owner Author

@richardbmx Thank you for participating!! Your proposal looks great.
I'm from mobile now, so I'll look at them better when I'm back home. BTW I like them.

I think the next step will be to pick up the best proposals, make some small changes and ask to users to vote.

@skypjack
Copy link
Owner Author

skypjack commented Jul 3, 2018

Time to recap. These are my favorites:

  1. I like this one by @mario-deluna for no particular reason, I just like it.

  2. I like the three circles of @m-waka, in particular this one and this one (I like much the one with circles having different sizes, but we can adjust it later). Three circles like the three parts of the whole: entity, component and system. It makes sense after all.

  3. I like the first and the fourth from @richardbmx (as mentioned also by others). The former as the three parts concept mentioned above, the latter is good and it's enough for me.

I want to ask to the authors if they can release their images under a license that allow me as owner of the project to use the logo for any purpose in future.
Otherwise, let me know and I'll remove your proposal from the list above.

Then, well... let's vote!! I wrote EnTT, but it wouldn't have reached this point without you, so it's right to involve users in giving it a shape!! 😊

I'd say to vote with the reaction icons:

Once voted, let's see if I wake up tomorrow still democratic or not!! 😂

Repository owner deleted a comment from loudedtwist Jul 3, 2018
Repository owner deleted a comment from loudedtwist Jul 3, 2018
@richardbmx
Copy link

Hello happy day all my designs are under license, you can use it wherever and however you want

License of Creative Commons
This work is under Creative Commons license Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International.

@skypjack
Copy link
Owner Author

skypjack commented Jul 4, 2018

@richardbmx It looks like we are going to collaborate. Could you contact me by mail for a short chat?
You can find it in my profile. Thank you very much for your contribution.

@richardbmx
Copy link

@skypjack Ready send you an email greetings ...

@richardbmx
Copy link

@skypjack
Copy link
Owner Author

skypjack commented Jul 9, 2018

@richardbmx I'm working on this. Soon the logo will be online. Thank you very much.

@richardbmx
Copy link

@skypjack Excellent I am glad to know that you will use my proposal

@skypjack
Copy link
Owner Author

skypjack commented Jul 9, 2018

Well, this is democracy. Right? :-)

@richardbmx
Copy link

looool... so is

@skypjack
Copy link
Owner Author

skypjack commented Jul 10, 2018

Here it is. Mention: Logo Copyright (c) 2018 Richard Caseres. Is it fine for you? @richardbmx

@richardbmx
Copy link

@skypjack for me this perfect thank you very much for using my work

@skypjack
Copy link
Owner Author

You're welcome. It looks fine. I think I'll merge it on master tomorrow. Thank you very much.

@skypjack
Copy link
Owner Author

skypjack commented Jul 12, 2018

On master. Thank you again @richardbmx for your proposal. It's time to close this issue.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
discussion it sounds interesting, let's discuss it documentation docs related issues/requests help wanted I don't have the knowledge/resources to do that
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

9 participants