You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Describe the bug
On Amethyst, direct replies to root have the "reply" marker instead of NIP-10 mandated "root" marker.
This disrupts the thread chain & sometimes the replies to this reply, show up as replies to the root note in the Notifications tab.
(This is a minor issue found only in Notifications view - when displayed in Conversations view, the ordering is perfect)
To Reproduce
Steps to reproduce the behavior:
Select any Note A & reply to it on Amethyst (B). B will mention "A" with a "reply" marker & not "root" marker.
Reply to B from another client (C) (I used Nostter.vercel.app) -- still no root marker in any note
Reply to C from Amethyst (D). Now for some reason, this D note mentions B as "root"
Reply to D from Amethyst/any other client (E). E will show up in notifications tab as a reply to B & not to D.
Expected behavior
Direct replies to root, to have "root" marker instead of "reply" marker in kind1
Amethyst allows replies on Public chat, streams, communities, etc & maybe there are other dependencies for this reply structure.
This is a very minor issue -- just wanted to bring to your notice (I've also informed Nostter dev)
Device (please complete the following information):
Phone Brand/Model : NA
Android Version [e.g. 33]: NA
App Version : v0.76.0-Play
Bounty (in Bitcoin sats) offered for a solution
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
AutumnSunshine
changed the title
Direct replies have "reply" marker instead of "root" marker
[BUG] Direct replies have "reply" marker instead of "root" marker
Oct 1, 2023
Describe the bug
On Amethyst, direct replies to root have the "reply" marker instead of NIP-10 mandated "root" marker.
This disrupts the thread chain & sometimes the replies to this reply, show up as replies to the root note in the Notifications tab.
(This is a minor issue found only in Notifications view - when displayed in Conversations view, the ordering is perfect)
To Reproduce
Steps to reproduce the behavior:
Expected behavior
Direct replies to root, to have "root" marker instead of "reply" marker in kind1
Amethyst allows replies on Public chat, streams, communities, etc & maybe there are other dependencies for this reply structure.
This is a very minor issue -- just wanted to bring to your notice (I've also informed Nostter dev)
Video and Screenshots
Sample Note IDs:
--Direct reply having "reply" marker:
https://nostr.band/note1d2kcxmw3t7695hfmx3avl0dpdna933clm7u5tgap8w9ul066gpjsv493kx
--Direct reply having "reply" marker, causing "root" to be marked incorrectly, as described earlier
B= https://nostr.band/note1nrxek00xxpkr8799t7pvnuka3c0z8sdc9cl6hy63s39tzn8u7xpqc52g78
D= https://nostr.band/note1773v5m6usr5jmsww8yhr4mkkhx9krdma5nur2lncjp856pzhgh6qu6897w
Device (please complete the following information):
Bounty (in Bitcoin sats) offered for a solution
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: