Transition Level 2 to CR

[igrigorik]

• Known / outstanding spec issues
  • https://github.com/w3c/resource-timing/milestone/2
• Web platform tests
  • Initial test for resource timing web-platform-tests/wpt#402
  • One resource entry per resource web-platform-tests/wpt#2919
  • review some initial tests for resource timing web-platform-tests/wpt#4266
• Privacy and security
  • https://w3c.github.io/resource-timing/#privacy-security
• Implementations
  • Chrome: size attributes: M54+; workerStart: M46+; wip: nextHopProtocol.
  • Firefox: M45+
  • Edge: missing support for *size, protocol, secureConnectionStart
  • Safari: no public signals
• Update acknowledgement section

[plehegar]

FPWD got published today. Will touch base in 2/3 weeks to move to CR.

[yoavweiss]

OK, so the current state of affairs:

• Open issues
  [ ] The spec uses the wrong Origin definition, and missing a note regarding TAO redirects #195
• Pending WPTs
  [ ] [Resource Timing] Test XO redirection sandwich with and without TAO web-platform-tests/wpt#13518
  [ ] Add nested-context resource-timing tests web-platform-tests/wpt#13823
• WPT status
  
  
  
  

[igrigorik]

note: WPT badges don't seem to reflect the actual status — something weird with caching?

[yoavweiss]

note: WPT badges don't seem to reflect the actual status — something weird with caching?

weird. They worked fine earlier today...

[yoavweiss]

As discussed in the latest F2F, I looked into which tests are currently failing in Firefox and Safari to get us to 2 passing implementations for each test. The list is:

• Fixed (by @cvazac in 193213) in latest webkit build:
  • buffer-full-add-entries-during-callback-that-drop.html
  • buffer-full-add-then-clear.html
  • buffer-full-then-increased.html
• Not passing in Firefox and Chrome
  • no-entries-for-cross-origin-css-fetched.sub.html
• Not passing in Chrome
  • nested-context-navigations.html
• "secureConnectionStart and fetchStart should be the same" test failing in Safari and Firefox
  • resource_connection_reuse.https.html
  • resource_connection_reuse_mixed_content.html
  • resource_connection_reuse_mixed_content_redirect.html
• Failing in both Safari and Firefox
  • resource_initiator_types.html
  • resource_reparenting.html
  • resource-reload-TAO.sub.html
  • crossorigin-sandwich-no-TAO.sub.html
• "startTime == fetchStart in cross-origin redirect." failing in both Safari and Firefox
  • resource_timing_cross_origin_redirect_chain.html - "startTime == fetchStart in cross-origin redirect."
• Fixed in Safari
  • supported_resource_type.any.html
  • supported_resource_type.any.worker.html

@rniwa and @mstange - can your teams prioritize the work required to fix these issues and pass the tests?

[cvazac]

@yoavweiss I confirm! :)

[yoavweiss]

@yoavweiss I confirm! :)

Looks like it didn't make the latest STP, but I just confirmed that the latest webkit build passes the tests 🎉

[noamr]

@yoavweiss what does this require now?

[yoavweiss]

We dropped level plans in favor of a Living Standard model. We can close this.