You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
The topic of HAR support often comes up when we discuss about network event support (#196). I am filing this issue to summarize mozilla's opinion and intent on that topic.
At the moment, we (mozilla) are prototyping HAR generation based on the network events proposed in #196 to make sure that clients can generate HAR files using BiDi. But we don't plan to directly add HAR support in BiDi, we just want to ensure network events are compatible with it.
But if there is a strong interest for generating HAR with BiDi however, it might make sense add a command in the future. Some thoughts about pros of having a command:
HAR format is specified, so if we don't have a command any client (which wants to provide the HAR feature) will roughly have to reimplement the same logic (which will therefore be duplicated across clients)
related to the previous point, if we want to promote HAR usage, forcing clients to reimplement that logic can be an issue for adoption
it will be hard to test against regression for HAR support if we don't own such a client
generating a HAR in the browser might be more efficient because you don't have to communicate all the network events to the client
Now some cons:
if we have a HAR command, then all vendors will need to implement the HAR generation logic
HAR files can be huge when recording complex scenarios (several 100MBs)
As a summary there is no intention from the mozilla side to have a BiDi HAR command "for now". We only want to ensure network events from BiDi can be used for HAR generation. We can reconsider after discussing this as a group, based on the interest.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
The topic of HAR support often comes up when we discuss about network event support (#196). I am filing this issue to summarize mozilla's opinion and intent on that topic.
At the moment, we (mozilla) are prototyping HAR generation based on the network events proposed in #196 to make sure that clients can generate HAR files using BiDi. But we don't plan to directly add HAR support in BiDi, we just want to ensure network events are compatible with it.
But if there is a strong interest for generating HAR with BiDi however, it might make sense add a command in the future. Some thoughts about pros of having a command:
Now some cons:
As a summary there is no intention from the mozilla side to have a BiDi HAR command "for now". We only want to ensure network events from BiDi can be used for HAR generation. We can reconsider after discussing this as a group, based on the interest.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: