[VDG] Make coinjoin settings less hidden

[MaxHillebrand]

The coinjoin profile settings (red coin isolation, anonscore target etc) are too much hidden.

Figure out how to make them more accessible.

[soosr]

Since the beginning, my idea was to have it accessible from MusicBox. It is time to implement it #8849 (comment).

[turbolay]

We discussed about this with @soosr because an user asked instructions to find cj settings.
It's clear that there is a real issue here, and the MusicBox idea #8849 (comment) is an interesting and cheap way to solve this.

However, it feels too crowded because of the LED auto-start indicator
What is the point of the indicator? It's redundant with what's actually written in the MusicBox.
If you have CJ auto-enabled and it will start soon it will be written in the MB anyway.
What about removing it?

It would look like this with the parameters icon:

[soosr]

We discussed about this with @soosr because an user asked instructions to find cj settings. It's clear that there is a real issue here, and the MusicBox idea #8849 (comment) is an interesting and cheap way to solve this.

However, it feels too crowded because of the LED auto-start indicator What is the point of the indicator? It's redundant with what's actually written in the MusicBox. If you have CJ auto-enabled and it will start soon it will be written in the MB anyway. What about removing it?

It would look like this with the parameters icon:

cACK for top right setting icon.
cACK for removing the LED, no one uses it.
+1 I would also remove the CJ setting from the ... menu as it make much more sense in the MusicBox.

[MaxHillebrand]

in the music box where the wasabi logo is, put the icon of the privacy profile, make it clickable and show the other options. This way user can switch profile directly in the music box.

the custom strategy can be the wasabi logo.

[soosr]

in the music box where the wasabi logo is, put the icon of the privacy profile, make it clickable and show the other options. This way user can switch profile directly in the music box.

the custom strategy can be the wasabi logo.

FTR, some sketch up is coming for this, do not start implementing anything yet.

[yahiheb]

This issue should be prioritized because many people find it difficult to access the coinjoin settings.
Another user feedback regarding this:

Not so user friendly. I'm experienced and with version 2, it took me a long time to find the coinjoin privacy settings. They are hidden behind 3 dots in the middle of the right side of the screen of the wallet. Not intuitive.

https://twitter.com/deefouren/status/1614335584335429632

[turbolay]

However, it feels too crowded because of the LED auto-start indicator
What is the point of the indicator? It's redundant with what's actually written in the MusicBox.

First UX feedbacks conclusions from @sannydayX confirmed that this indicator only brings confusion

[sannydayX]

Yes that indicator is also confusing, like many other things in regards to coinjoin. Please don’t star implementing things randomly. There are indeed many uasability issues with the coinjoin, but it needs to be thought out properly as a whole and ideally conduct another user testing session focused just on coinjoin to come up with a good solution. This is a pretty big topic.

[stale]

This has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.

[soosr]

So this issue has been moved back from UX to UI board, but I still think it is more like UX stuff, like how to access the settings. So pinging @editwentyone @nopara73 and asking for opinions.

I would add a 3 dot button in the top right of MusicBox as it usually indicates "Others". That button would open a submenu where we could add the Coinjoin settings.

And in the future it would be also helpful for coinjoin related things like:

• Exclude coins ([Autocoinjoin] Freeze utxo from coinjoin  #7487)
• About fees (info page about CJ fees)

[editwentyone]

Right now its more an UX problem to solve.

I wouldn't add a shortcut to conjoin strategy, what needs to be done is consolidate everything into a "wallet settings" and clearly distinguish between "application settings"

suggestion is incoming

[soosr]

Spec

• Replace the LED indicator with a ... button.

I would add a 3 dot button in the top right of MusicBox as it usually indicates "Others". That button would open a submenu where we could add the Coinjoin settings.

And in the future it would be also helpful for coinjoin related things like:

• Exclude coins ([Autocoinjoin] Freeze utxo from coinjoin  #7487)
• About fees (info page about CJ fees)