mbed-os-example-client size with UBLOX_EVK_ODIN_W2 is massive #3598

JanneKiiskila · 2017-01-17T13:30:06Z

Note: This is just a template, so feel free to use/remove the unnecessary things

Description

Type: Bug
Related issue: #abc
Priority: Major

Bug

Target
UBLOX_EVK_ODIN_W2

Toolchain:
GCC_ARM

Toolchain version:
0.9.10

mbed-cli version:
(mbed --version)

meed-os sha:
(git log -n1 --oneline)
5.3.3

DAPLink version:

Expected behavior

mbed-os-example-client binary size should match approximately what it is for the rest of the boards, somewhere from 250 to 500 kB.

Actual behavior

The binary is huge, it 1.1 megabytes.

Steps to reproduce

git clone mbed-os-example-client
generate security.h from portal (connect.mbed.com)
./build_all.sh
check binary sizes

The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:

JanneKiiskila · 2017-01-17T13:30:22Z

 404456 Jan 17 14:32 f439zi-GCC_ARM-6lowpan.bin*
 278752 Jan 17 14:31 f439zi-GCC_ARM-eth-v4.bin*
 435392 Jan 17 14:33 f439zi-GCC_ARM-Thread.bin*
 395132 Jan 17 14:32 k64f-GCC_ARM-6lowpan.bin*
 271516 Jan 17 14:29 k64f-GCC_ARM-eth-v4.bin*
 274212 Jan 17 14:30 k64f-GCC_ARM-eth-v6.bin*
 426228 Jan 17 14:33 k64f-GCC_ARM-Thread.bin*
 237876 Jan 17 14:31 k64f-GCC_ARM-wifi-v4.bin*
1147488 Jan 17 14:31 ublox-odin-GCC_ARM-wifi-v4.bin*

JanneKiiskila · 2017-01-17T13:31:57Z

What is really strange is that if you look at the mbed-os-example-client-map.csv, total flash is 464853 -> so the size should not be even remotely close to 1 megabyte? What's the linker doing in the end?

JanneKiiskila · 2017-01-17T13:35:45Z

mbed compile -m UBLOX_EVK_ODIN_W2 -t GCC_ARM -c
Link: mbed-os-example-client
Elf2Bin: mbed-os-example-client
+-----------------------------+--------+-------+-------+
| Module                      |  .text | .data |  .bss |
+-----------------------------+--------+-------+-------+
| Fill                        |    662 |    15 |    86 |
| Misc                        | 286923 |  2653 | 18052 |
| drivers                     |   1255 |     0 |     0 |
| events                      |     64 |     0 |     0 |
| events/equeue               |   1226 |     0 |    61 |
| features/FEATURE_COMMON_PAL |  16651 |    93 |  8345 |
| features/FEATURE_LWIP       |  34802 |    87 | 46801 |
| features/mbedtls            |  90261 |    55 |  8755 |
| features/netsocket          |   5046 |    85 |    60 |
| hal                         |    672 |     0 |     8 |
| platform                    |   1390 |     4 |   313 |
| rtos                        |    757 |     4 |     4 |
| rtos/rtx                    |   7851 |    20 |  6871 |
| targets/TARGET_STM          |  14143 |     4 |   784 |
| Subtotals                   | 461703 |  3020 | 90140 |
+-----------------------------+--------+-------+-------+
Allocated Heap: unknown
Allocated Stack: unknown
Total Static RAM memory (data + bss): 93160 bytes
Total RAM memory (data + bss + heap + stack): 93160 bytes
Total Flash memory (text + data + misc): 464723 bytes

JanneKiiskila · 2017-01-17T13:38:51Z

K64F with ESP8266 as reference:

Elf2Bin: mbed-os-example-client
+-----------------------------+--------+-------+-------+
| Module                      |  .text | .data |  .bss |
+-----------------------------+--------+-------+-------+
| Fill                        |    453 |    14 |  2297 |
| Misc                        | 117785 |  2521 |  1427 |
| drivers                     |   1659 |     0 |     0 |
| features/FEATURE_COMMON_PAL |  16651 |    89 |  8345 |
| features/mbedtls            |  73371 |    51 |  8755 |
| features/netsocket          |   4082 |    85 |     0 |
| features/storage            |     42 |     0 |   184 |
| hal                         |    580 |     0 |     8 |
| platform                    |   1424 |    20 |   297 |
| rtos                        |    757 |     4 |     4 |
| rtos/rtx                    |   7221 |    20 |  6871 |
| targets/TARGET_Freescale    |   9787 |    12 |   872 |
| Subtotals                   | 233812 |  2816 | 29060 |
+-----------------------------+--------+-------+-------+
Allocated Heap: 65540 bytes
Allocated Stack: unknown
Total Static RAM memory (data + bss): 31876 bytes
Total RAM memory (data + bss + heap + stack): 97416 bytes
Total Flash memory (text + data + misc): 237668 bytes

237876 Jan 17 15:36 mbed-os-example-client.bin*

The image size very closely matches what elf2bin reports.

0xc0170 · 2017-01-17T13:57:30Z

cc @andreaslarssonublox

JanneKiiskila · 2017-01-18T07:58:08Z

Issue also exists with mbed-os-example-wifi, so it's not to do with mbed-os-example-client.

For K64F


Elf2Bin: mbed-os-example-wifi
+--------------------------+-------+-------+-------+
| Module                   | .text | .data |  .bss |
+--------------------------+-------+-------+-------+
| Fill                     |   143 |     3 |  2221 |
| Misc                     | 55025 |  2480 |   512 |
| drivers                  |   835 |     0 |     0 |
| features/netsocket       |  3635 |    85 |     0 |
| features/storage         |    42 |     0 |   184 |
| hal                      |   432 |     0 |     8 |
| platform                 |  1230 |     4 |   269 |
| rtos                     |   213 |     4 |     4 |
| rtos/rtx                 |  6649 |    20 |  6870 |
| targets/TARGET_Freescale |  8552 |    12 |   228 |
| Subtotals                | 76756 |  2608 | 10296 |
+--------------------------+-------+-------+-------+
Allocated Heap: 65536 bytes
Allocated Stack: unknown
Total Static RAM memory (data + bss): 12904 bytes
Total RAM memory (data + bss + heap + stack): 78440 bytes
Total Flash memory (text + data + misc): 80404 bytes

80056 Jan 18 09:55 mbed-os-example-wifi.bin*

UBLOX;

Elf2Bin: mbed-os-example-wifi
+-----------------------+--------+-------+-------+
| Module                |  .text | .data |  .bss |
+-----------------------+--------+-------+-------+
| Fill                  |    387 |     8 |    71 |
| Misc                  | 219824 |  2580 | 17165 |
| drivers               |   1068 |     0 |     0 |
| events                |     64 |     0 |     0 |
| events/equeue         |   1226 |     0 |    61 |
| features/FEATURE_LWIP |  34782 |    87 | 46796 |
| features/mbedtls      |  20313 |     0 |  8748 |
| features/netsocket    |   4800 |    85 |    60 |
| hal                   |    490 |     0 |     8 |
| platform              |   1196 |     4 |   269 |
| rtos                  |    213 |     4 |     4 |
| rtos/rtx              |   7279 |    20 |  6870 |
| targets/TARGET_STM    |  13729 |     4 |   844 |
| Subtotals             | 305371 |  2792 | 80896 |
+-----------------------+--------+-------+-------+
Allocated Heap: unknown
Allocated Stack: unknown
Total Static RAM memory (data + bss): 83688 bytes
Total RAM memory (data + bss + heap + stack): 83688 bytes
Total Flash memory (text + data + misc): 308163 bytes

990268 Jan 18 09:56 mbed-os-example-wifi.bin*

So, should be around 308 kb but it is 990 kb. So, we actually have 2 issues:
#1 - why can the K64F version be only 80 kb, but UBLOX would be some 308 kb?
#2 - UBLOX should be 308 kb, but it ends up being >900 kb.

JanneKiiskila · 2017-01-18T08:04:02Z

Kudos to @teetak01 for actually spotting that this is an issue. I just did some more digging on this and filed this bug.

andreaslarssonublox · 2017-01-18T09:57:02Z

The u-blox ODIN-W2 Wi-Fi driver takes approximately 1M of flash since the driver contains patch files for Wi-Fi(682k) and Bluetooth in addition to the stacks.
The patch file can be found in the generated map file:
.firmware 0xa6966(682342) cb_fw_owl35x.o

This is defined as:
static const cb_uint8 attribute((section (".firmware"))) fw[] = { .... }

When building the wifi test (included in mbed test suite) with ARM and IAR toolchains the numbers look OK:
| wifi | UBLOX_EVK_ODIN_W2 | ARM | 84004 | 0 | 0 | 84004 | 1038251 |
| wifi | UBLOX_EVK_ODIN_W2 | IAR | 83645 | 24576 | 49152 | 157373 | 984678 |
while GCC_ARM is wrong:
| wifi | UBLOX_EVK_ODIN_W2 | GCC_ARM | 84020 | 0 | 0 | 84020 | 316971 |

Don't know why the elf2bin is presenting the wrong numbers.

theotherjimmy · 2017-01-18T16:44:33Z

@JanneKiiskila @andreaslarssonublox It sounds like this is a bug with memap.py. @MarceloSalazar Any thoughts on what could be causing this?

0xc0170 · 2017-01-27T11:17:58Z

@JanneKiiskila @andreaslarssonublox It sounds like this is a bug with memap.py. @MarceloSalazar Any thoughts on what could be causing this?

@MarceloSalazar Any update?

MarceloSalazar · 2017-01-27T11:20:52Z

I'm sorry, didn't have chance to look into this yet...

MarceloSalazar · 2017-05-03T02:24:33Z

The patch file is indeed defined in the '.firmware' section, however this is not part of the GNU GCC standard sections, and hence why it's discarded.
https://gcc.gnu.org/onlinedocs/gccint/Sections.html

The problem doesn't happen when using the ARM or IAR compilers, because of the nature of the memory map files (this falls in the RO area).

@andreaslarssonublox would it be possible to rename .firmware to .text?

andreaslarssonublox · 2017-05-03T05:53:10Z

Thanks for finding it @MarceloSalazar. We will fix it in the next release of the driver.

MarceloSalazar · 2017-05-19T14:48:52Z

Built Wifi example with UBLOX_EVK_ODIN_W2 and mbed OS SHA: 5d0ce3c

Total Flash memory (text + data + misc): 998507 bytes

Issue considered fixed.

sg- added component: tools needs: investigation labels Feb 7, 2017

andreaslarssonublox mentioned this issue May 18, 2017

u-blox ODIN driver v1.3 rc2 for mbed OS 5 #4338

Merged

MarceloSalazar closed this as completed May 19, 2017

andreaslarssonublox mentioned this issue May 21, 2017

u-blox ODIN driver v2.0 rc1 for mbed OS 5 #4358

Merged

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

mbed-os-example-client size with UBLOX_EVK_ODIN_W2 is massive #3598

mbed-os-example-client size with UBLOX_EVK_ODIN_W2 is massive #3598

JanneKiiskila commented Jan 17, 2017

JanneKiiskila commented Jan 17, 2017 •

edited

JanneKiiskila commented Jan 17, 2017

JanneKiiskila commented Jan 17, 2017 •

edited

JanneKiiskila commented Jan 17, 2017 •

edited

0xc0170 commented Jan 17, 2017

JanneKiiskila commented Jan 18, 2017 •

edited

JanneKiiskila commented Jan 18, 2017 •

edited

andreaslarssonublox commented Jan 18, 2017 •

edited

theotherjimmy commented Jan 18, 2017

0xc0170 commented Jan 27, 2017

MarceloSalazar commented Jan 27, 2017

MarceloSalazar commented May 3, 2017

andreaslarssonublox commented May 3, 2017

MarceloSalazar commented May 19, 2017

mbed-os-example-client size with UBLOX_EVK_ODIN_W2 is massive #3598

mbed-os-example-client size with UBLOX_EVK_ODIN_W2 is massive #3598

Comments

JanneKiiskila commented Jan 17, 2017

Description

Bug

JanneKiiskila commented Jan 17, 2017 • edited

JanneKiiskila commented Jan 17, 2017

JanneKiiskila commented Jan 17, 2017 • edited

JanneKiiskila commented Jan 17, 2017 • edited

0xc0170 commented Jan 17, 2017

JanneKiiskila commented Jan 18, 2017 • edited

JanneKiiskila commented Jan 18, 2017 • edited

andreaslarssonublox commented Jan 18, 2017 • edited

theotherjimmy commented Jan 18, 2017

0xc0170 commented Jan 27, 2017

MarceloSalazar commented Jan 27, 2017

MarceloSalazar commented May 3, 2017

andreaslarssonublox commented May 3, 2017

MarceloSalazar commented May 19, 2017

JanneKiiskila commented Jan 17, 2017 •

edited

JanneKiiskila commented Jan 17, 2017 •

edited

JanneKiiskila commented Jan 17, 2017 •

edited

JanneKiiskila commented Jan 18, 2017 •

edited

JanneKiiskila commented Jan 18, 2017 •

edited

andreaslarssonublox commented Jan 18, 2017 •

edited