the result is diffrent from others和别的程序算出来不一样

[sparkang]

您好，我用的你的程序计算我的测试集，同时，我还用了这个：https://github.com/rafaelpadilla/Object-Detection-Metrics。你的这个算出来比他的那个要低6个百分点！

[sparkang]

sorry my english is not very good,first your code's results is lower than this:https://github.com/rafaelpadilla/Object-Detection-Metrics.
and second, your curve is 11-point curve,i want to know how i can get every-point curve.
and thanks for your contribute, this code helps me a lot!

[Cartucho]

@sparkang Hello! Sorry for the late response.

Why is my curve a 11-point curve? I don't have that restriction I believe.

I am currently working on adding tests to my code to make sure that everything is giving the same results as the official PASCAL VOC matlab code.

[sparkang]

thank you for your reply, i have a question, i use your code to generate the result just like this:[cid:2881269a-78ce-4b85-8c6d-c9a44d86f1df] i want to know why this curve is not closure，because i want to your image like this: [cid:9fa5bf10-34c3-4316-ac71-c5d0b0dfd3af] besides, your code's result is diffrent from this one:https://github.com/rafaelpadilla/Object-Detection-Metrics#optional-arguments

…

________________________________ 发件人: Cartucho <notifications@github.com> 发送时间: 2019年3月19日 17:35 收件人: Cartucho/mAP 抄送: sparkang; Mention 主题: Re: [Cartucho/mAP] the result is diffrent from others和别的程序算出来不一样 (#58) @sparkang<https://github.com/sparkang> Hello! Sorry for the late response. Why is my curve a 11-point curve? I don't have that restriction I believe. I am currently working on adding tests to my code to make sure that everything is giving the same results as the official PASCAL VOC matlab code. ― You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub<#58 (comment)>, or mute the thread<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AlbxsTjMGJ-i0fPc6kPtXXYZdIe-x6n6ks5vYK9tgaJpZM4bZHx2>.

[lilyhuang1015]

@sparkang 您好，我也碰到一樣的問題，所以挑了一張圖片將兩個作者的code做測試，發現該位作者是對的，然而另一位您貼連結的作者，將其中一個bbx IOU=0.3認為是TP，然而我嘗試其他樣本，發現在IOU<=0.2049的才會被認為是FP，希望對您有幫助

[sparkang]

者

哦哦 原来是这样的，非常感谢你的回复，不过我想再请教一个问题，就是如何让图像和作者readme的一样呢，就是让曲线是闭合的

[lilyhuang1015]

@sparkang readme那張圖 recall最後連接到1，應該是額外進行繪製的，但實際不是閉合曲線，因曲線下有塗色的才是實際數據，應該是作者為了讓最後連接到1而畫上的，後半段的顏色並沒有畫上，也代表沒有算到最後那個三角形，然而一般大量數據最終難以達到recall=1，除非您的檢測結果total TP=total ground truth，

[sparkang]

@sparkang readme那張圖 recall最後連接到1，應該是額外進行繪製的，但實際不是閉合曲線，因曲線下有塗色的才是實際數據，應該是作者為了讓最後連接到1而畫上的，後半段的顏色並沒有畫上，也代表沒有算到最後那個三角形，然而一般大量數據最終難以達到recall=1，除非您的檢測結果total TP=total ground truth，

哦哦 这样的 感谢 ： ）

[anjanaouseph]

@sparkang Hello! Sorry for the late response.

Why is my curve a 11-point curve? I don't have that restriction I believe.

I am currently working on adding tests to my code to make sure that everything is giving the same results as the official PASCAL VOC matlab code.

Hi @Cartucho So you are not using the 11 point AP formula here?

[JJY0710]

@sparkang readme那張圖 recall最後連接到1，應該是額外進行繪製的，但實際不是閉合曲線，因曲線下有塗色的才是實際數據，應該是作者為了讓最後連接到1而畫上的，後半段的顏色並沒有畫上，也代表沒有算到最後那個三角形，然而一般大量數據最終難以達到recall=1，除非您的檢測結果total TP=total ground truth，

请问您测试过官方yolo的指标程序吗，我测试的时候yolov5测出来的指标是高于该作者的，按理说yolo的程序更有权威性