Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Feature request to be able to exclude websites #93

Open
o-be-one opened this issue Jan 17, 2021 · 50 comments · May be fixed by #372
Open

Feature request to be able to exclude websites #93

o-be-one opened this issue Jan 17, 2021 · 50 comments · May be fixed by #372

Comments

@o-be-one
Copy link

Hello,

i wanted to upload a file on Tresorit website's and i was not able because ClearURL was cleaning some part of it. I had few 412 HTTP status. I haven't digged deep but i've seen that disabling this extension (latest stable Firefox in my case) resolved my issue.
So, i've searched to add Tresorit in an exclusion list as i can do with few other addons but haven't seen that.

Is it possible to add a feature to disable ClearURLs options for selected websites? Or at least can someone fix the file upload blocking we experience on Tresorit website?

Thanks a lot for your help.

@deadbeef2000
Copy link

Hello,

same problem occurs when I'm trying to visit the following page:

https://app.getresponse.com/click.html?x=a62b&lc=SX7CKv&mc=In&s=NBb4KD&u=zs9vf&z=ES3yhIs&

The filtered version doesn't include mc=ln and the trailing &, if this part is removed, I get redirected to a 404 page, but if I disable the addon, I get redirected properly.

This happens to all app.getresponse.com/click.html links, but unsubscribe.html or change.html works perfectly fine.

@U-Go-7
Copy link

U-Go-7 commented Feb 28, 2021

I agree, please add a whitelisting feature or a button to enable/disable the add-on on each website. Not to sound ungrateful, but, seriously, it's like the most basic feature in something which has the potential of breaking things.

@dt-flo
Copy link

dt-flo commented Mar 25, 2021

I also need a whitelist feature. I leave the addon uninstalled until this feature has been added.

@Ryonez
Copy link

Ryonez commented Mar 25, 2021

Have also had instances that I need to disable it or pages won't load for a service.

When this occurs I typically disable the extension and never turn it back on for ages because I'll forget about it.

@kanish671
Copy link

kanish671 commented Apr 4, 2021

The mc query param in this link https://www.mailing.dzone.com/click.html?x=a62e&lc=toz&mc=h&s=TSmS&u=f&z=oTUWUqe& is getting removed and causing to redirect to 404 page.

I would like to have an option to whitelist certain websites or certain params in URLs of certain websites.

@oleg-d
Copy link

oleg-d commented Apr 7, 2021

Also throwing my hat in the ring for this feature request

@securingmom
Copy link

This seems like it would be better if it had a list subscription option so all y'all could help build a peer reviewed whitelist for optional implementation.

@LM1LC3N7
Copy link

As the extension manipulate URLs, this can led to some false positives.
So adding an exclusion option, like uBlock (you can disable the extension for the current visited domain) would be a great idea 😄

@Shamp0o
Copy link

Shamp0o commented Apr 14, 2021

+1
This add-on makes my University's websites unusable.

@VictorioBerra
Copy link

Please add this.

@ipleten
Copy link

ipleten commented May 6, 2021

Selfhosted GitLab server is also affected - I can't switch branches on WEB UI drop-down list due to parameter is being cleaned each time.

@brendandburns
Copy link

fwiw, creating new GitHub CodeSpaces is also broken by this.

@Ansem93
Copy link

Ansem93 commented Jun 16, 2021

This should be top priority. I have important websites not working because of clearurls.

@DaBomby
Copy link

DaBomby commented Jul 28, 2021

This is a huge deal breaker in terms of using this addon. A simple all rules are on or all rules are off functionality is not helpful. It turns into a situation wherein you will have to turn it off to make sites work, and then you forget to turn it back on. Ultimately eroding the value proposition from this extension.

This should be made a priority for a new feature release.

@Ryonez
Copy link

Ryonez commented Jul 28, 2021

@KevinRoebert, lucky you for the mention. No-one working on this has responded here and you have the most recent commits.

To give you an idea how bad this is, this breaks websites. Legitimate ones some of us need to use.
Where the aim is to improve browsing experience and maintain users privacy, the inability to use legitimate services that we need to does the opposite, resulting in the extension being disabled or removed.

This should be considered a key required feature for the extension.

@DaBomby
Copy link

DaBomby commented Jul 28, 2021

@KevinRoebert, lucky you for the mention. No-one working on this has responded here and you have the most recent commits.
This should be considered a key required feature for the extension.

Agree, there does not seem to be any response and the updates to the code are rather infrequent. I wonder if this project has become abandoned?

@KevinRoebert or @yipinghuang1991 are you able to weigh in on this?

@sreid99
Copy link

sreid99 commented Oct 14, 2021

Seems to break playing videos on google drive too.

@Ryonez
Copy link

Ryonez commented Oct 14, 2021

If you've made it this far I'm going to recommend just disabling/removing this extension for now. Despite this being a long standing issue that will completely break sites, and it's the second most thumbed up issue that's open (The first being a request for Safari support that has had a response), no one working on the extension has made any kinda of reply here. And that's despite people mentioning them in this issue for some kind of feedback.

It breaks sites, the devs don't seem to care, just remove the extension and move on at this point.

@ahuj9
Copy link

ahuj9 commented Nov 1, 2021

Can we just add a "disable on this site" button to the extension?

@Caligatio
Copy link

This add-on now breaks the new login flow for the US's third largest credit union. It would be wonderful if we could get some ability to whitelist sites, even if it isn't he prettiest implementation.

@GuardianLiarus
Copy link

Yes please, we need this feature, some sites break due to clearurls for me

@learn2reid
Copy link

Is there any update on this?

@thakyZ
Copy link

thakyZ commented Mar 10, 2022

I would like this mainly because I believe filtering links on Steam's link filter wouldn't be a good idea and might be a security risk. So I would like to piece of mind to not have that be bypassed.

@qmzmdqs
Copy link

qmzmdqs commented Mar 17, 2022

I also need this feature.
I hope it can be temporarily disabled at the specified host and URL. Because some rules have errors, which affect the normal function of the webpage

@diogoleitao
Copy link

Chiming in on this as well, HERE WeGo breaks a lot with this extension as well.

@abudhu
Copy link

abudhu commented Apr 22, 2022

Also adding my desire for this feature. Please!

@pjboro
Copy link

pjboro commented Apr 23, 2022

This addon is breaking some popular websites. The probable result is that people disable it and forget to turn it on later. It would be awesome to be able to turn the extension off for specific websites.
Would devs accept a PR, provided someone created one?

@keldian
Copy link

keldian commented May 20, 2022

For everyone's info, there's been some discussion about whether or not CleanURLs is even necessary with the appropriate uBlock lists. It sounds like you can replace the functionality of CleanURLs with AdGuard URL Tracking Protection and Actually Legitimate URL Shortener Tool.

uBO has no support for bypassing redirect tracker URLs, never mind how many lists you add to it. That specific mechanism is the entire reason I started using ClearURLs.

@conradsrc
Copy link

The author said he'd be working on it more after Feb '22 and wanted to put in the whitelist feature, though it seems @KevinRoebert hasn't posted on this issue about it.

I'm using Tautulli and "Login with Plex" no longer works. ClearURLs mangles the URL so that it just points at the frontpage of the Plex website. I tried fiddling with ClearURL's options but it seems none of them are specifically causing it. I was only able to fix it by disabling ClearURLs altogether.

It would be infinitely easier to have a whitelist feature where I could fix this in seconds, as opposed to having to disable the extension and write up an issue here for every single possible website that this could happen to.

@m4jki
Copy link

m4jki commented Jul 21, 2022

broken captcha login on gate.io with filter enabled

@xenstar
Copy link

xenstar commented Aug 23, 2022

wow, so many people have requested this. Now if I disable it for a specific site, I have to disable it for all the sites. And sometimes I even forget to enable it. This is a good plugin, I hope the developer will add a whitelist function soon.

image

@EsEnZeT
Copy link

EsEnZeT commented Jan 11, 2023

Is there better alternative? It started to brake gdrive file stream login. I guess I just remove it, not worth the trouble.

@gbakeman
Copy link

As mentioned earlier, you can supplement most of CleanURL's functionality with uBlock lists.

#93 (comment)

@Brog33
Copy link

Brog33 commented Dec 27, 2023

love this plugin but it breaks certain sites, so i will disable it until a whitelist is in place.

@learn2reid
Copy link

+1!

@Drugoy
Copy link

Drugoy commented Jan 8, 2024

@EsEnZeT NeatURL - a better alternative that has the blacklist functionality (which this ticket is all about) and whose UI I like more (instead of showing me bullshit like statistics - get me direct access to the GET param cleanup rules!).

@OutlawCecil
Copy link

Agreed this is needed! AliExpress is broken by this extension currently.

@o-data
Copy link

o-data commented Jun 19, 2024

I remember there was a Whitelist feature, could I have remember it wrong? Anyway here is the error for one of website I used it break the Search function. Disable ClearURL will work again.

Required request parameter 'ref' for method parameter type String is not present

@nxmndr
Copy link

nxmndr commented Jun 20, 2024

I have tried editing the data.minify.json & rules.minify.hash URLs with new ones giving custom JSON but they are not saved clicking Save & restart.

@Banaanae
Copy link

I have tried editing the data.minify.json & rules.minify.hash URLs with new ones giving custom JSON but they are not saved clicking Save & restart.

Make sure hash is lower case

@Banaanae
Copy link

I've started working on adding a whitelist, I'll make a draft PR once basic functionality is added

@nxmndr
Copy link

nxmndr commented Jun 24, 2024

Thanks :) Ideally it should be per parameter and per website, as some legit website also have some parameter mishmash.

Everything is lowercase.

@Banaanae
Copy link

Banaanae commented Jun 24, 2024

I'll see what I can do, but that might be a bit advanced for me :)

Also most whitelist that come to mind (uBo sponsor block) don't even have this functionality

However when I submit my PR anyone could implement that

@Banaanae Banaanae linked a pull request Jun 25, 2024 that will close this issue
8 tasks
@Banaanae
Copy link

This has been completed in #372

@o-data
Copy link

o-data commented Jun 29, 2024

Now to hope that a new release is build

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging a pull request may close this issue.