CFP 2109-09: DeFiChain WebWallet (65 772 DFI)

[SantiagoDeFi]

Overview

1. Requester(s): [Santiago Sabater @SantiagoDeFi]
2. Amount requested in DFI: 65 772
   *In order not to lose development time, we decided to put the CFP back on the calculation basis of 2.50€/DFI and bear the price risk. *
3. Receiving address: [dG8trh4x3c242oEdpHDFP63TWSto5t6CYU]
4. Reddit discussion thread: [https://www.reddit.com/r/defiblockchain/comments/pkyssj/cfp_defichain_web_wallet/]
5. Proposal fee (10 DFI) txid: [5d69be22b4d61673d308e4bcaeb232e45180d304573c2d8a9228c55a09469614]

I made three YouTube Videos to make this proposal more readable

1. Explaining the whole proposal (reading is faster): Video01 (25min)
2. Showing the current version of our web wallet: Video02 (12min)
3. Showing designs of upcoming features: Video03 (5min)
   Feel free to choose!

Describe the purpose

DeFiChain is a great blockchain with an incredible community. But we still have a long way to go if we want to become a global player. We all need to do our part and add more diversity and faces to this ecosystem.
A blockchain that has only a few wallets and hardly any collaborations and teams look small and weak. DeFiChain is still young but is currently more in adolescence. What we need now is another 10 strong community projects developing applications on the chain.
I would like to contribute a part to this and to achieve this I have set up a team.

Team

• Santiago Sabater (Project Manager)
• external investors
• P.M. Partners (development team)
• community member, that supports us with their opinion, & ideas

DeFiChain should become bigger, more adult and more colorful. For this purpose, we will program the very first web wallet in the DeFiChain network.
We want to pave the way to the Ethereum network by developing a wallet that will be familiar to Ethereum users and by enabling an alternative to atomic swaps.
In addition, web wallets bring with them the feature that they can be integrated into websites very easily and in a user-friendly manner. We will release a library so that every website can integrate our web wallet and we will actively cooperate with Decentralized Finance Exchange.
In doing so, we will make the web wallet open source and available for free.

Development phases
Note:

• This wallet will be a light wallet, no sync of blockchain and it will be released first as WebWallet on the GoogleChrome Web Store and on our Homepage.
• Wallet will be published open source before starting an open beta for testing.

Alpha (done)
1.1 Design
1.2 Sending
1.3 Receiving
1.4 HD-wallets & BIP39 mnemonic seed
1.5 Support of community generated tokens
1.6 Multiple accounts.
1.7 History
1.8 Full DEX usability

Beta
2.1 Liquidity Mining
2.2 Hardware wallet integration
2.3 Update due to DeFiChain Development
2.4 DFX implementation

Gamma (next CFP round)
Additional features (planned for next funding round, can be adjusted, denied, exchanged to others)

• Interchain Exchange (Atomic Swap)
• Bridges to other networks that do not support Atomic Swap
• Library for website integration

Additional services:

• Create a stunning website as landing page/download page.
• Listing on Google Chrome Web Store
• Steady work on Design & Marketing
• Maintenance

How will the fund be spent?

<style> </style>

The entire development will cost around 100.000-150,000 DFI.

This is only possible because of the preliminary work of Dominik and Patrick. We have constantly received support and resources from them and can hereby confirm that Dominik and Patrick share their resources, those of the community, and thus were able to make our project significantly cheaper. Secondly, we are using the Jellyfish library for our web development which in the beginning was not easy, because the library is still in development.

In total our project is cheap but at the same time, we will apply for the biggest funding so far. This is due to the following reasons:

- We will apply for only two funding’s to realize the whole development

- The current DFI price is low

Due to the fact, that we already paid around 30.000$ up front, we will use the first funding to get our costs back and finance the next development phase. After this is done, we will pay the third development phase with the second funding.

Note: It may be possible, that we are going to ask for more fundings in the future, if the community decides that they want more features to be developed. I want to keep this open if community members come up with great ideas.

Here is the calculation:

FUNDING NR. 1	€	DFI
Sprint 1
Development expenses	22.200
Legal expenses	5.899
Total (2,42€/DFI – fest)	28.099	11.597
Sprint 2
Development dexpenses (2,50€/DFI)	34.596	13.838
Legal expenses	4.200	1.680
Total	38.796	15.518
Additional costs
Buffer	10.000	4000
Project management	37.500	15.000
Compensation investors	30.461	12.184
Total	144.856€	65.772DFI 58.300 DFI price recalculation canceled

 

<style> </style>

Note: If the buffer results in a surplus, it will be offset against the second funding round, so we will apply for less.                          

FUNDING NR. 2 (worst case)	€	DFI
Sprint 1
Development expenses	96.000,00
Legal expenses	4200
Reserves for maintenance	25.000,00
Total	Max. 125.200€	50,080 DFI

 

Note:

-          Total funding is approx. 25% higher than originally planned, due to lower DFI price.

-          If the DFI price changes, we will adapt the calculation.

-          Compensation of the investors will not be sold. Our investors are long time hodler.

-          Total DFI that will not be sold: 27.184

-          The second proposal will not include any profits for the project management and will not allow any investors to be participated.

-          Please consider that we are going to pay taxes

How does this CFP benefit the DeFiChain community?

If you decide to support us, we will be able to release another wallet in the space that can work independently from the previous teams. A wallet with about 10 people actively working on it. A wallet where we can decide what happens next. A wallet that is 100% fully paid by the community and only examines, what the community wants to be examined! You want an iOS App? We will present you a plan and realize it. You want a bridge to a specific network? We will figure out the options. And here is why: I am on your side. I do not have to justify myself when problems arise at the programming level. Either we get our team to fix it, or we get our money back and hire someone else who can do the job. We do not have to wait for there to be enough motivation for someone to tackle a problem. We trust that our team is competent and will continue to be interested in receiving orders.
If the wallet project is finished, the team is still available to the community for new projects. We already have a lot of things in mind, but we do not want to dictate everything. You want us to realize something specific? Then suggest it and we will see if the community agrees! You can also participate and start organizing with me together. The only requirement is that you are 100% motivated, reliable and have a great idea.
We have enough capital through our community fund, which is overflowing and a great developer team, that can program almost everything for us.
The scarce good are not programmers or money, but time. I wish that we will see some more exciting projects until the end of the bullrun.

My tasks

Every task that is mastered must be defined. I take care of managing the whole project. This currently includes:

• Technical realization: I take care that the developers get all the information and contacts they need. I hold meetings where I go into technical details and plan and discuss the implementation with the team. Of course, this aspect also included finding a suitable team of developers first. For this alone I needed more than 6 weeks, held countless meetings and conversations.
• Legal aspects: I make sure that each party involved is covered. It is important to make sure that the developers, the investors and also me are legally satisfied. This means that I have drafted contracts with lawyers, explain situations, consider solutions and review contracts before they are signed. Again, I needed specialized lawyers and tax advisors who know crypto.
• Design: Every single feature that is developed needs a vision. I therefore made sketches, gathered information, compared products and finally made whole parts of the UX to reduce costs.
• Investors: Even though $30,000 is not too dramatic a number, it is not easy to find people you want to work with and who are willing to provide enough capital. This involved meetings, conversations, explanations, and weighing the needs of our investors.
• Communication: I am responsible for ensuring that all parties synergize with each other and that the process runs as smoothly as possible.
• Funding: I am responsible for the hole project financing and community work, to achieve a successful funding.

These tasks will come back to me at each stage of development. Some will no longer be necessary; others will be added. I cannot say exactly how many hours per week I spend on this, as it is quite irregular. But in the development of the alpha phase, it was about 25-30 hours per week. In addition, I have also provided money for the wallet and have included a small premium for me, due to the risk I have.

My last thoughts

However, I have been thinking about it a bit in the last few days, and I am afraid that some users might too quickly take the position that we do not need another light wallet.

I want you to remind, that a key puzzle of a decentralized ecosystem is, that there is no central entity. We want to have a variety of developers, building the same applications with different approaches. We know that the foundation developed a fantastic light wallet as well and I have a tremendous respect for U-Zyn. He might be the biggest brain in our community, and I guess that the core development team is the one, we most trust. New users might think different. They do not know the core development team, might feel better with an alternative product. Maybe, we will be able to provide a better-looking wallet, with more details and love, just by the fact that the core development team has trillion other things to do. We do not know yet. But what we know, is that variety and competition lead to better products.

We just want to add another piece of the puzzle. And after that, another one.

DeFiChain-Explained will not be neglected in the process. I currently work full time for YouTube, DeFiChain-Explained and the WebWallet. We are actually ahead of our roadmap for defichain explained and added a big new side project to it: A community-based blog.
We are also using funds from the CFP of DeFiChain-Explained to encourage other community member to invest their time in DeFiChain-Explained.

Regarding to the defichain-analytics, we have 18.945.274 DFI in the fund. Let us try it and invest 0.591% into another wallet & development team. Thanks for taking the time and reading up to here, I really appreciate it.

[wmbst]

This web wallet will be a major benefit for Defichain. Most users coming from the BSC or ETH world are used to metamask and all the other web wallet. So having a web wallet is a very important factor in the success of Defichain.
I totally support this CFP.

[Wuuzzaa2000]

This web wallet will be a major benefit for Defichain. Most users coming from the BSC or ETH world are used to metamask and all the other web wallet. So having a web wallet is a very important factor in the success of Defichain.
I totally support this CFP.

100% agree 😀

[sandstumpen]

Will the WebWallet be open source?
Since the WebWallet is funded by the community, I think it would be good if it became open source.

[sandstumpen]

I found it. It will be open source ;-)

In doing so, we will make the web wallet open source and available for free.

[SantiagoDeFi]

Will the WebWallet be open source?
Since the WebWallet is funded by the community, I think it would be good if it became open source.

Yes! The wallet will be 100% open source and we are also planning to integrate a bug bounty program later on.

[defichain-mn-8P24-krmb]

signmessage 8P24qRzccs9FJXkqrrzPZGa2aNXxqBkrmb cfp-2109-09-yes
H9rgnfEwS+XBv9+SNpp72X8JVSo3KJQaSB/kn3Tb3EyvA+8eFdhb1slaHqAy49AXsL530FyHWZ0XhGgeDv1gX74=

[halfmoonbln]

signmessage 8RmKLDHLmWKhHbR8ScJ6xvcsAAeXuetfxc cfp-2109-09-yes
H1riCZvsZ4LyRDir6RLz2pV/SHErBaulFEXexGpepVNsFne3CwBrf6V3Q1E1VJrmN0k/C/Py4W5o3Z+SYlrBA4o=

[riddikilus]

signmessage 8Ly4EGDFmcMr9kaEUyVRz3727w2rdzkMyW cfp-2109-09-yes
H7kHmsbiThWUOQToz3N+ZVU6rXGWqDY9Sh6EWkYo/14DSAVlGa8Df/laqfrQOiupo6Ht0ul/TnrfvnMVd62zJr8=

[riddikilus]

signmessage 8HJGgMQR8rS9ZaLiWsRwJSmgvComw6AmDK cfp-2109-09-yes
H/XwRvHnhAwudONEVS1JH2FcNLy2RLcLzrBEB2HCOUcFWfsRHs4GN879D/Igz5at/XK07qwAG23vdFgPgsEEYSM=

[dfip-voting]

$ defi-cli signmessage 8VKs5jqADhwRTHVXsf8hhMmJm5r8FpWF7h cfp-2109-09-yes
IJfojIEqDEfRxkRJdY0rcvaUnxauKT21VIZK3I4BIUM2UtkCJ7SLI7AvQxLzuvu/FBiYS5Nu+rcQEynOz9jGAB0=

$ defi-cli signmessage 8XP5w7ybYGFoUYy3Sm9nWdbexAvSPJXZxD cfp-2109-09-yes
H6UrJsCI66cKev414djigGz+aaM7h493rnjhHxOW60q9EsQkeWFVrYq/MZGMpzs3UB/oh/EQoac681A2AaITNMM=

$ defi-cli signmessage 8VWKo5wCpaHqKvDLUTAaEWnFVhZWGoYPL2 cfp-2109-09-yes
IAqPjvQ6SXlUN4ozZZV71w7gz12h25xwDn9ZNEtdW4lbHgsNUMITvPUTbWBWI59sR5j7Z80IM0SnMrM2CYUYB2o=

[KermitIsBack]

$ defi-cli signmessage 8ZXoChtTZoGWwdt9E9cLzvx8FEuYVL6Trg cfp-2109-09-yes
IAFkPKZJ8bow5Xd8z4O2BIqaIHTyUGTf6uoaZWLj63AuIfvjucOYNYil8MKDJfvUDPmJUyDubxfJLmijG9R1g+o=

[MasternodeOwner]

signmessage 8VqHKJmGVPxDj2gZyD4cMnE5AvjrKPBgT6 "cfp-2109-09-yes"
HzuBqpQ9+GEXuO+6Nog4EVF9VEC2acLwHb4WGc8qO1gVUw+BsAj3pM5eoIkK3igvk1BWWNQR53oIkKSuC7WTja0=

[naiirad]

$ defi-cli signmessage 8Rt2wuBuWM3q8UVZJDb1EvRvbEswFthhYY "cfp-2109-09-yes"
H/LK+IWfi9KjEM485SNoAR9dx4jUcwI83jV/+6QlbgnqZ7HBrbb66FdO7uAED5jC9Qo3frCTckXzASLRw5vhlu8=

[AberSowasVon]

$ defi-cli signmessage 8GuL9RvCPD9crWfBnbbvSDdAw98dxLj8VL "cfp-2109-09-yes"
IBkZ3rTZUYpYG9rVYJ9wAp/Hk5SgHAGE5Wcu99u1a5J0HaUPpV2Q9uNzkzPFIsLRI+eZ2v5kMhgEIz8NvIapzp4=

[DrDrCat]

$ defi-cli signmessage 8dzgrtVJ1KMigZs8WS5n4R6biE2jdsbLu6 "cfp-2109-09-yes"
H/81khRT51uIslFhUnICxi1Y3C2DwPUsAggXuw7SSiLtMOIqeU5X2FAhLOrJLInxkRZniLbLKcNK4gjp35wBgxs=

[Smurfxy]

cfp-2109-09]
$ defi-cli signmessage 8VBLzNi1TdHwQHWg7HbZcR9ZSkequXs6Up "cfp-2109-09-yes"
IFcl2FSvWrXMXUrs44u+jKY09zLPAu6qx3k+dm9koQnyfwGFvDmBjRJlTEw8Rod37BgNBgDX+mcP7JHmzWQK9YQ=

[Lafarik]

$ defi-cli signmessage 8U94KePNHgnQj9Tdh3nCrgVD3jrYqSiZeM "cfp-2109-09-yes"
ILCiDeFdAhU5xXHovBboBcH0lbkuxXKWRl9C2KtftmP8Nivd7yk2IKX/I1+2ybGA6ksu141ATJ6Rzplby/Bv49Y=

[AmarHadjj]

$ defi-cli signmessage 8FATbHjLHLJgpbN3uwYKUeWjTp54keYpgU "cfp-2109-09-yes"
IId7BJA9Qk1jLxcs3ZUpy/qrziAyaxva2IuUfNjsy5buJRETTCSjjK3p9hGnVHODlDspJj4xqaDehE0A3W1ynMg=

[Danielvk77]

$ defi-cli signmessage 8TqoNqksKuUY641vMMhf42tSSSdTKx8R4q "cfp-2109-09-yes"
H/sBd4MuGTCOjDCsW9K0XY6AL9Dn2riMCJ+hiw9RBqSCDjy0GPiLIX+biQV+XGmvw5IUZhsLrlpVYOfP/5wQbKw=

[Buschfunker]

$ defi-cli signmessage 8ZfZsC1HiSf55GivvEdvR2JXJU1G4N7fpe "cfp-2109-09-yes"
HyUoAYlaBredr5j6C1nxHyfQx+HukTanhi5sl4OC7U/vAM38jRsbs7Yw8UjIBfXGwi8AiThumpm772H/mB9IzpA=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Uzfy7TMByLMtexDsGdVjesDKqCWzo7tLn "cfp-2109-09-yes"
IGzrLdNFv2cJ5Dwy54dsdskp423Dfd0y0eXeUSe0IEjEYlKJAghlaQ9DD9a7s6iiInmAYRJIt6+acZovFeo1TvY=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8MX8bUDFdLiU9KBt46DFLWF5pd67pcAv7m "cfp-2109-09-yes"
IPLItp1To9o/eOBVNk4V8G79BPfabBJEknQ644h5QBvQOotqMhTnWR/qrlDr7TE5WA0Lc1ER4aDz5NKtvU5mdQo=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Q1ZDLjw4Vd8F6US74S1M394BwnCcVPj3Q "cfp-2109-09-yes"
IINM/UUfRc7R6KRvu50okcQBuJVTPXtlsY+iTlVKC/r3e0tX5ylOuV0XuJX7o9+JW4lWGPw83TQGSmjwjan19gc=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8R2qzMjdNr1qVRFv7PJoNh2YBQqHj5UnEY "cfp-2109-09-yes"
IFYAbvZ3JJCPHXyaZ6QWIAYL03SD0lGTQyMYKwpAG+6bPWuaGYGkPhBvUH6Oxioo5fptS/ptFBtcTI+hW/nbWdU=

[DefiLobster]

$ defi-cli signmessage 8aqXetSP2XNF8M5G3uY6ab22yEBaWLBVA2 "cfp-2109-09-yes"
H/8Rm/uGviH/YPTp1LoMfyI8+1UNWmC17Qn567RD3zl7LBJpIvNw1xA2et+ZYNntKN+6mXTvq6e8u71Pdy2oMqs=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Q4nwQHE4G7Gvdu69AStvrspeDeLjHypsP "cfp-2109-09-yes"
IEDrPO9asyhA58/A4BbGR/YIpLnPCudOhbB2D4SShuBTaIdYKjlP9q6fJ4RTlmhTwlAwyfttu0fKY6+52PAwqjg=

[Kryptobat]

$ defi-cli signmessage 8YcEwJqHTKWLYSVGHp3w2knkhyCzNXSqmS "cfp-2109-09-yes"
H8suXWG13nFqa2fRjW8ygYJp/8kBnnKBSCN3OQKkJBZDFc8EH6OD4kUjT4D3JxkhAR796osfxh0x3qxxphNu4rQ=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8UoBUAVDxrhxuzvgnt5Rtm6cEpmNamjcZE "cfp-2109-09-yes"
Hy6LagtOXBVZ/uPvUsEiAvrcf7o18YsjK9Pfgu7knYKsaaatcgg/e8U1/xlXkqfeAV88znVGsKU6mrPNS7O35hk=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8J9cKafkM4wtjEVFUZs84jEhnEQE3sYier "cfp-2109-09-yes"
HxEo0KokcnwOqElHRQ4wRsgBqtKco/CMDYOc1an5Y3D4PEh2cL0K7ZLanQT+WSxy+LNAEOUqJoE1xflmaNdeX8M=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8KKK92SVGqesUxr3txVdgprgEv8cCZ3EEt "cfp-2109-09-yes"
ILQiXw1Kp03I8FfFTWuPauJ6MmVvE+OT0W7sFs2JxX1VaSnEDKeNIxqbMjRHemBeEYv4BTwifAGRztbKUBCUK9o=

[FxX9920]

$ defi-cli  signmessage 8FN6cGRAPMTwiBLRzHAh39BkZokFCkcJRe "cfp-2109-09-yes"
IJS9Ur+znwGsNEVmZ4tmMBVyG0ZBDJbqo68eUAseVUAMKt54ujdtTfw9slyt7jUscHSgXVwerRsAAw+7WJpY190=

[SantiagoDeFi]

Every vote counts and will ultimately make the difference in whether or not we can continue to develop over the next few weeks!

I would be happy to get in conversation with anyone who voted against our WebWallet CFP ! Every vote counts and I'm happy to talk openly about criticism or funding amount if that's what's on your mind. You can contact me anonymously on Telegram

https://t.me/Santiago_Sabater
@markusm39 @DeFiChainLover @ilfalconft @allmann1 @AndiyNW @mn-1632339193

Please consider to get into conversation, maybe we can find a solution together!

[net47]

$ defi-cli signmessage 8QV6uLzeDQdWik5BDipRhbEHAM7fTvqXhm "cfp-2109-09-yes"
H51S2U0u5ANkDWBZ74bqB0APPJI+CgVHRl27lZu1AVpZUq0Et6wDmvsRoH2Qhnt9U3SP03UZz6IjIul4yiYnXGk=

[C783027]

$ defi-cli signmessage 8M767wCwdvtFwYDm8hpeVAQxBk6rTNUcdD "cfp-2109-09-yes"
IMCe4AbeaDrrzOfp59QzulVAvZ5t4QzbfmX4C6hZuc11O1upCIqpWOhbs7+w14wHo5kSjrjaXnW+U4aogN5VD0E=

[SantiagoDeFi]

**I understand the costs and all and think it's a good project, that's why I vote yes. But I don't like the adaption of asked funds because of a price drop. At the end, thats a risk every single one has to deal with. Should we send out more DFI to the CFP who are finished already? They have to deal with the decrease too.

WOULD YOU HAVE MADE AN EDIT AND ASKED FOR LESS WHEN PRICE WOULD HAVE INCREASED? I don't think so. Bad taste I have to admit.**

$ defi-cli signmessage 8ZzZPPLjoPSh6uQD8FKpk8jB5riwpryE3n "cfp-2109-09-yes"
ILGEDQdB25lpqyk1gey5sy4TzQJD1VNjeatgi4ew3UGiS3PbD5xDqgW9Ksxki8fS9uxetS9BJVYDT5uVmvKT3+U=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8aaQDgwZTKxxYiSH4jVz1KEeDuYwqjU2g5 "cfp-2109-09-yes"
Hy3H8DdP89LH3blnHpdOl2hK+1ekLN9uDSosL9CMqXJ4Ww+mfcu/e/RPqJZRZOPt2IFrQTqG24jBwQrlkwmn8bk=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8ZcArjPhpid7pudPpXLYSABGcoyr3LCUBj "cfp-2109-09-yes"
IB0nghMyc01Vsto7pRKj9h0bWcBC+HkFtwj/032SxN+VSVRth3958FjsrLGtiMSypz3h04dcWFvd4QyqXvsqc0U=

Thank you so much for your votes!!!

I have lowered the funding amount back down to the original amount with 2.50€/DFI. We are not looking to squeeze the last DFI out of the fund and if the price had broken out to the upside, we would have adjusted the CFP as well.

[gorg1919]

$ defi-cli signmessage 8LLNJSfspvTQ4ygY9vMYyhuuph5ifzchJy "cfp-2109-09-yes"
H1AnamH+1cbd0vO8Ir0MgsiHXmtrDJ1wsAwR7oXM1Ti0auhdTib6tkj0ojRZT5tnr72KRG5fVYetfit9PXVa+kg=

[uzyn]

Thank you so much for your votes!!!

I have lowered the funding amount back down to the original amount with 2.50€/DFI. We are not looking to squeeze the last DFI out of the fund and if the price had broken out to the upside, we would have adjusted the CFP as well.

@SantiagoDeFi going to revise it back to the original amount, or this invalidates all the votes.

@gorg1919 please take note as you voted after the change.

[fleshless666]

$ defi-cli signmessage 8UQJQ5KZPojS1DdhLuFwU2uyDUxeggAuzJ "cfp-2109-09-no"
IBIP2s7xcqyieTRrW+nffsz8gKt8nHrKc7yufCXGwnZlfM9xscqgcgPWuzoEApiRh5sEHQkEVvrimY5/1FuqT6c=

[Kretsche49]

signmessage 8YYS9tsWFv3Ffv3xH6nYMsM5dyVdQRpM5Z "cfp-2109-09-no"
IJzkU4xklC6ewwrTHPLqnaVNFWhCVefwsAMpX7M8XzSuA3EeTxT64LHxoJswEFvD7lf7WITx+NEqq9z7UnEqAAg=

signmessage 8HX66kSuw7EFLxiwd9VCUJwB5mnCHGraLo "cfp-2109-09-no"
H79rTRij3bwfukyQQ194VWl0K7h1tvBQkeE2dgVD849abmvoWZriEHvRbPhfxTN4QZwrH7M8DKD5NLv+wayZxE0=

[angelocastiglione]

signmessage 8dJLcKddBnwXzzXBLeZLYqzHehfeB8UWa2 "cfp-2019-09-no"
IGjdGOsFDAgwDzfvz2hCaMs2MSFPuIuiSgc4o3HapapzIVSzEbWyIC88cHnDYTQpfcD11gZAIjSiaBrTdBCA79Y=
signmessage 8JgPSdyFpLTG1wAnxFHpuHjEoSmPBhHccg "cfp-2019-9-no"
IEFTHQ1Myy8GWtWjQgSw7MrGSf0OZd8bIJgcb6/eJg09VwYwBqUBjfO78tnsmeQcoc5h23XI9oD4xvIF49tjWck=

[Reklov1408]

$ defi-cli signmessage 8RdM4gtnvA2MPe8Ks7aAsPNnQCagdRQwjb "cfp-2109-09-yes"
H0fegHHaqd4shEMdybnd0u93YSLLl4xeuOwe4tdd7uG0eu7JCHajNTqO/Xaqo8B42L0IajC8s77Ifv5h0rJ7Vng=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8ZRPJ7cYYroBCkBpwcvmGvNZjifPpZPc4n "cfp-2109-09-yes"
IDSqixQgiqKdAlk1o5YJoaH4fFbOJpJRTxzouqGLDMH4Dn9PsDzgRhBWP4PQzTB+/U/jYEL0UViYNTG9MbboGEA=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8bpiDiotrXDekqPWznLebtFHaJs7P4vh5m "cfp-2109-09-yes"
IFvs/Ab5oCHV9fOa8i3KrxDSIHHqueoTI6wKCNcNRxfNZbsNkhKa+8bdzvZoGUfgp5gciAK95XA484oOGK01eEI=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8RBs5Catv2wUBEHZjdbkVpHb9NcKswUDEQ "cfp-2109-09-yes"
H2lg+uEwSQH894GsV4ET0oFdtqs/gfvQIuVbwDFQpkV+G9wlb2DnXUHoMYdOLKkAxRjV+qyMwFWgaG8Pz0iGHQQ=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8FdZ1uSP8tb6NR9SuzsvfDTM1LVpM3dynk "cfp-2109-09-yes"
IBn2+xv0CV4EqzrrOA11rKbVzX7JOVZBFvRmmiCSSUVVSI/BpcofA4YrnF450/tQI7x4E77p4AgNgZUUtegKQvU=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8PytoGKRs7DFKBCG6ZMXPF1wLTe3Y16Dow "cfp-2109-09-yes"
Hwz/rQwitRyzlunK3A1Yk8AZSzVk0nZJmGb33+Zs80UdbFsqo2sJVQG+eua05WhufdTW9zmOTZ7TqdO3H4tb9x4=

[NativeDefi]

signmessage 8cbErY9UJiPTReT1gvdtxeGTDNqasUnZqF "cfp-2109-09-no"
H6V0eOfWlj91P+DWSzrZq8lteqgFFgNTbSSQhdYJ4GtMQgIREuRE5lgxp9u/tbAVv33oaQjjag5btc82K84ni7Y=
signmessage 8aixj7G6PEE5yLojJNZYYigR95xfBMd954 "cfp-2109-09-no"
ID7XTReErtKioMVNJGucYjNx3b2T/l7QlllBcxtP1qj2ZeGj6t/sO3b5U+FkK+UUEOI/d+8aowAVbSB0cLRAJx4=
signmessage 8QKEAc5wzx3gcMkVFkXAn8wfiM5QbcNH62 "cfp-2109-09-no"
H35acWWqSg/ZMx2xIew9kt6i8eVlMAi83VG8QNagh512OVzT84urFcKrcySCbQdkHg6Ta++guhNntuHCCNqbIck=
signmessage 8PTEQ8DBmNi3hDtA6T1ANTP6EUdqQPZqHX "cfp-2109-09-no”
IMGrz/aaALTdOD/7boTRFblLNMr7oLum47rMyd6FoE+bZv1MZhUg/bglAzVJpdW4Oi/PuoovQwcjkWvaj8n6TZQ=

[Niecoo]

$ defi-cli signmessage 8FCti735amK34nybQkQKVGMA4K398oBENx "cfp-2109-09-no"
IFNcOggpbJ9a67iDC4kK4ky4qw1RTOv1K4sUT7y/olLFMjEhyuf9pY+YCMgFRFctO0rMiA1RmTHopclWtZ133Is=

[C783027]

signmessage 8b6DJkdhFA2dey9p8dJy5PU91SpeBR3dpk "cfp-2109-09-yes"
IAMHMnP58Z1r6e6iRln34DTLJSIKzKmdS6jaJh0R0UCtefXGCxEU++Zee7Ki47ZCsb6azyF2Zw1ScYT7bbLHCMY=
signmessage 8dR1AtyVids5FBeEMddEoFupacbjbPPpcS "cfp-2109-09-yes"
IARz0MOUPKrnTXM7Q3oGo9uqlrC6V9DPKAdaCkNpKnZIanvRTFch6lqHcIiYOOG4S5T2SS9Ip8sGt1G2V9uR/zo=
signmessage 8PEE1hoQ8kChfDernfQH7oEmzZ6GeTpg3N "cfp-2109-09-yes"
IMDizGApIZeiHih52Q1hvy/scpMBZ4Wkonse+Yyh2zW9CjWaGTYbBjurj3i5bzh6gECm9q1HVZI0HM3P773iqJU=
signmessage 8HSG7WMwsTFixmX4t9HBYKmhqHYxQkZVjc "cfp-2109-09-yes"
H/0DrFstINs+QTNCrgwLfk/cYYHv+yVt338cndBgxYc2XmPwy8jmgD09rtTl+d1OqKHyRS7tC5Ny9enf8541Q5w=
signmessage 8YDAS398tg32PVHP66WYjRQGtVq6GS9HbB "cfp-2109-09-yes"
H6gBRWq6yLuQxoMYk9q+e3YW9DBgu6LbwKRmc22geYWJYbZKFIV921/R9Znb0cl4nTMK8muD+TiJlItMeYek6ac=
signmessage 8T1QZAQNWCvndghqreKDmWFNNNsfqgCChQ "cfp-2109-09-yes"
H9M6pCXsTh4cJSVuwV7wA57wgr1+R+/Vyo5iXCQgOqYVekhJXpYIpvQtgm2f1TeTfklFUa0f6Rvo998EoFT05ko=
signmessage 8cwLYPddnzZWeC7bQW2atCKyqb5uxxeqZF "cfp-2109-09-yes"
H8w680RwtGKdLHdXWpkFtd6G/Pm6mnlFagjeqijHZ4q5QAXaY5kqGbbcbzw2BRWd/CBTOyHbWjiQ4vFJbyqlcEs=
signmessage 8S6BjLf9wqRq8R3zmjzym87tzVPTQbyvuQ "cfp-2109-09-yes"
HxT/KqWLCL4GRIEZ+N7xZ2pSD1Tme2B62DZ01ADVw+83TZGK45Lfud8RC8a/T8O2nd2CocBQVmJ4FW7wWJy5oEU=

[Kampflama]

signmessage 8P5C5Una5WhQvRve9toNkCse3nELAx3YH2 "cfp-2109-09-yes"
H75Td/N9+QgGjjAlhZECluFQtlVpRu88PcfgKCLpD0t2QpZ2THLwZ33v4vTKQj/tOzyhtAiDnaMXgAYATErdCA4=

signmessage 8ZmdL2gFvPQ8WZphuh8772RSPtZLd8pKpY "cfp-2109-09-yes"
IC9UImCbUSLWOLbIecmE2nPOXiT7Zc3jAZ4tMplqRc1bWEn3tZFpxDvBRwtyx4ZxdBhQZbT7Zjt+9XyLQWyae7U=

[ms-01]

signmessage 8X9mSBVoeFfsk7XyAJmYCGu4SgrQzMj7Ud "cfp-2109-09-yes"
H+n5Y3WcIulpj1JUf6PLL245Al05oB8luRgYs9WrCcN0ISKKT4SsidKOUykPvvkYTYbEWS28EHEbBB7D6TUg5fI=

signmessage 8cfqCfRmN697jMavNmgbJH61tRXNhBXCiM "cfp-2109-09-yes"
H6vyzJhDNMQFUoPghQ5J5DGWi3LcfuGHpWwrxrrDp1B6NMSf1BLWQRr22+no73O7D1dWTcf0GupkbacgHvdE+cI=

signmessage 8K5EUbUbdpRWH1Tx1tTSpJgXs1x8Bck5vN "cfp-2109-09-yes"
IOnJgUafltTl8yPtEYu80ZZNULuB/VfoiS/fZA23DuCXSlm37a8qo4ckLUaZTrd0kjqGnYzD/mt28RqBlqb+0hw=

signmessage 8c3Rdmz1hCSvvSRittYUYQtQQLurX8dzzQ "cfp-2109-09-yes"
IHV/WLrDJhY0UgCys1duISmPfEAXZPcKeeO1e8n3a2+6UGLkYjckLCGbjskcndrjWgd+uwVCWDmsDGQ2T2biUoY=

signmessage 8LiEQLQCLkv2eTcQ5vmMWszMCXEYBk9GK3 "cfp-2109-09-yes"
INretARK+loCgqy6Cg9gwZ9ff88Dt3Il/VZKoOpe0d2mdQ6Q3yw9Ti05h52GbNFLZfqelY5QasAX6BHq/qDIfTY=

signmessage 8SQaHvzkrHik3o9vwF1MdKf2LkdgcicNTD "cfp-2109-09-yes"
H2rLPYkkz22nM1WSFNPCRWJYSs2Cf44jr1g/IFmjFJvRevSoUnrljtmhfLhN7klMjhShJSo8X5GRVcg4+nOqfBQ=

signmessage 8WnUuKZ7U55HNxmnwZMwzJHggRSy1ZKUKs "cfp-2109-09-yes"
IMcFPQemwkwNn1FgxyRCqqwEopghmsAB5t3/N490LpijVyBDDSAbTf7vDKWUJJW5761Nx03+SFUXeD8GT/0CSt0=

signmessage 8XFTnhwwbyM3MA7jLosmiupJfzKvuC8XM8 "cfp-2109-09-yes"
H8qMHPDMax4hEKSRCLAQLZUUM4CLdCRzmAaTdO0mcao7Sgetm2CtDvicTx6ANoFKpshdvAIZd3MNEWK9sBwe2Mo=

[Geldmax]

idea very good an ok, but to much DFI for the project.

$ defi-cli signmessage 8XQQ2HUPR2uy6S7VbGBBtCmQNture7XPvQ cfp-2109-09-no
$ defi-cli signmessage 8eLydM42kR12cSBmUq1V6RkVARYp2ZaubS cfp-2109-09-no
$ defi-cli signmessage 8bd3uKBxboBDQqpfGc8en9GuTVyt2GcF4C cfp-2109-09-no

[DTOHR]

$ defi-cli signmessage 8VxohuNsyCDRCxTA7so5ar2jUFGXVdmU7Q "cfp-2109-09-yes"
ILCrf3AxAOA0azSlpnHhco70h2Uda3XEVzj1fBphHbtUUWl9uqi/VT6rSjuq+ZwP7nvBOjGGW8wdtwladWT5MRA=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8HbdJdcMG9ZgdA3e5KDU7eQQb52je3gt15 "cfp-2109-09-yes"
H+Q1Yu1rmjLZDTEVA/4MfSTIi5x1lDVbP5LeVIeFD9+ybex8t7qnAfCMzNGIaTkixXZ3TVDDXJREj/LKfgjs2D0=

[123bumblebee]

$ defi-cli signmessage 8Hs4sLv66LN49bQ3NbvVLQYPcK2PsKLoKo cfp-2109-09-yes
IJoZDSIe+2WTP5roQDocSbgehCmCMRy/WLy2HXzYY9NXC/Bd9LXuMmpt0Qp5j7UjvZVaDG0ahX5BYnwZ2ko5VgE=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8U8DBmY7qXLoq2f2JycLGzDX3qv2VQNtJL cfp-2109-09-yes
HytvBNpLaZgIUKstRoFD2r8xRaGsaK0JoQ3uHDnmQtocCBqoH0yirNV4eij8jGLbfhmpBw9Y7m0ljlG28e3s1pY=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8c5MhVHu9sRT27547UrhAEx8JRqoxVHPLD cfp-2109-09-yes
H2ega2sDbGmbQugjfVsvP7xxbc/JOb1dntjubidWP6U7Mo6HbNrdh4rbRgUIfXVJBMKGfA/35qUTIpZcmGq9N90=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8RKdgXgKZXe4GFsXtBwuHaJz5WFSddzvdP cfp-2109-09-yes
HxH6n53LYr1j2tdztZ7qv0PRKLQfajMYDCpcqfF5NhgLFGOdUH1+Z8DoW+LoKG/N8VvmKh4bdvR0S8KqAADwG2s=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8MaE5KgCAm8UnxSDwyYnWZ4C7HQNSSTREB cfp-2109-09-yes
H8Mbx98pZKsBKHFG/QD1rgX5S6wDH49gyULhvOBSyrwhfyEctdaPo36wdEKG8Jd/Kn07YfN98OccK718HHDId9Q=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Z5yj2tBhUZDj8U63h2VUerrpGnxFHMCsQ cfp-2109-09-yes
IL2HM4G24X+CUrKfiDU8dyVZ+7+7Rb1JEunaMbX/56GAQ+L7daZBHSmZztG22lXqeuuzTM7+Ykmgy971ugWPImI=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8KrQFFQpRBGT1P1BLg9b6d3HkMBvE92p9h cfp-2109-09-yes
IBBh3zOjGmzsrt70i4uehmqLIDX8HUGgGP/ZttGCN/52dxk35/f9aBKBQzRmEG9pHPpmxbSGYfop8keCgu+WaKI=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8W4FvnuQpUeAbHEKEi3Pt5rNxzegrpaons cfp-2109-09-yes
HzeACscfwHmjazONFYJXMqlICQdgv3yT98+m+sBHZ6y6Uuh5mpbKmWfaPjTOe7nzwvXw9c5V0CaHY81giPATqfw=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8bYKEDnwbVCAj7RCBT8Ah6G1fDPGsy55x9 cfp-2109-09-yes
IKXIzMIahBGFONc+HsNJc0BaNvdyi6L1+U1mEvUBWkSNUhqVYNgvlsiwEEGV3gi/LsUR0A5k+At7m9fuEIMMq0k=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Y727d85iV6tumeSeWZ1PsEghP4ZovjQdG cfp-2109-09-yes
ILc8lv2dYNslLPxEzbC4Gt3Vlg1fB7vS+0z8/x3camKPcn7SKqBANduFqGUSmwUh9gDcKel7D/12bWpUEPtdOyM=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8XmR43vrB8kaUVRona6F7wd6FTZzfZi6DL cfp-2109-09-yes
IKyHVUhGqA+Kmie0COyVjFRS3Adj2CdwQ6ACmuB6zOWNfN1eqTjGrF7cD9RP1J13wQqorK8GwNIG1KZlJVL9BcM=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8VZt4CZzH59FHYBb6dt7XUkRiasuHvh3q9 cfp-2109-09-yes
H0TLM5t419gGbWsZ4pJl7/J5p+vnCLkQJaWXfAQyr/G4aXtCzE5BB2zRx03dAzgA3x5P++vtqpynUGdgjCdsR20=

[4oi5n]

signmessage 8U6NBMrQjtCbiUf5YQ8UoiB6CRFyyHa9Qj cfp-2109-09-yes
HyQgeWQgWsDvOc7Ei3jL0HgxNvSHtAjf2zduqmCCmptxPfrvtxHPrNYPsdX+NAbOZ+MjYwJ8w7fjd/teikGRgzo=

[derstrecker]

defi-cli signmessage 8JcvCqCPJ5ZsaWNhedB4NvxU6nVzCtdHiB cfp-2109-09-yes
IEsEdxZ6/HK0ELEzHrOLQd9rKrr4X8TARzQ51lF1MIHjRCp4q3JIfLTGuKk3K9gG/Z9+uWy3PGKULQe6f8domxM=

[UserMaxL]

signmessage 8UmV4yLvZjj81QzE5EMdYH3mC3rvxLmEkb "cfp-2109-09-no"
IPcJtrJ6zumiSod9/hO2+N/aSseCjRJFHDWPfx9FQSIrWBh9aJaYMit09+yFHJFwdTR+op3kCQE9WxbkwBBR8vQ=

signmessage 8RHZQZFJ4q4Jay62WQjS4rYSJuYswLuZ1b "cfp-2109-09-no"
H4+dCPvK3Mem/F8HNqj+0LK+UAV9VpHVtr0IP7jYSbV/Rfly4yias4+gBgswNV6SRu1dCDnph8rOy0kbPgPzQWY=

signmessage 8UoqeYej9Tg7iGvkxjBaBqAP8xipvRhxuQ "cfp-2109-09-no"
IPokvrBE2REs9iPpo0dR54nCpc12CBFGy/VQxmE1/dt9KohhJKWYir0flVPI9gyC4upmMYpp9+aAXl6MCsA+F5c=

signmessage 8NXbaKpEy3sNmrjc6bbiNE2RaVyMk4kh54 "cfp-2109-09-no"
IL3FlyRdYYhb+mIJPy2423m1LrvTyyfOOKshuHXZaXuSCunpafX6eGMm2fpkDrVsA/Bn0LYqll11MufvMnB2wMQ=

signmessage 8JC3tbEgpL4qsviPeK6EMTUWntpwXGKesC "cfp-2109-09-no"
IMDQYomJu1j/kZWAd7OdUMOaRh+pO5z5SGA6N56oLbNmKFpvSZav5dqxB9kB5jM0G1IdpWiCCUwXKw4i0nT4LnE

[surangap]

RESULTS for cfp-2109-09
===========================
cfp-2109-09 is approved by 25 votes majority
YES: 249
NO: 224
Neutral: 1
Total valid votes: 474
Total rejected votes: 11
===========================

Invalid format or vote message for vote: signmessage 8dJLcKddBnwXzzXBLeZLYqzHehfeB8UWa2 "cfp-2019-09-no"
Invalid format or vote message for vote: signmessage 8JgPSdyFpLTG1wAnxFHpuHjEoSmPBhHccg "cfp-2019-9-no"
Verify message failed for "defi-cli  verifymessage 8PTEQ8DBmNi3hDtA6T1ANTP6EUdqQPZqHX IMGrz/aaALTdOD/7boTRFblLNMr7oLum47rMyd6FoE+bZv1MZhUg/bglAzVJpdW4Oi/PuoovQwcjkWvaj8n6TZQ= "cfp-2109-09-no""
Invalid number of mintedBlocks: 0, masternode: 8X9mSBVoeFfsk7XyAJmYCGu4SgrQzMj7Ud for "defi-cli  verifymessage 8X9mSBVoeFfsk7XyAJmYCGu4SgrQzMj7Ud H+n5Y3WcIulpj1JUf6PLL245Al05oB8luRgYs9WrCcN0ISKKT4SsidKOUykPvvkYTYbEWS28EHEbBB7D6TUg5fI= "cfp-2109-09-yes""
Verify message failed for "defi-cli  verifymessage 8JC3tbEgpL4qsviPeK6EMTUWntpwXGKesC IMDQYomJu1j/kZWAd7OdUMOaRh+pO5z5SGA6N56oLbNmKFpvSZav5dqxB9kB5jM0G1IdpWiCCUwXKw4i0nT4LnE "cfp-2109-09-no""
Invalid format or vote message for vote: signmessage 8NvE9Uzkq31iPQnTBFAAKmN5YkCaxbByZc "cfp-2109-9-yes"
Invalid format or vote message for vote: signmessage 8GQuQhRTKTcGgw8nSMnQmqLJWmZ2zoaorq "CFP-2109-09-yes"
Invalid number of mintedBlocks: 0, masternode: 8HJGgMQR8rS9ZaLiWsRwJSmgvComw6AmDK for "defi-cli  verifymessage 8HJGgMQR8rS9ZaLiWsRwJSmgvComw6AmDK H/XwRvHnhAwudONEVS1JH2FcNLy2RLcLzrBEB2HCOUcFWfsRHs4GN879D/Igz5at/XK07qwAG23vdFgPgsEEYSM= "cfp-2109-09-yes""
Duplicate vote. masternode: 8QV6uLzeDQdWik5BDipRhbEHAM7fTvqXhm for "defi-cli  verifymessage 8QV6uLzeDQdWik5BDipRhbEHAM7fTvqXhm H51S2U0u5ANkDWBZ74bqB0APPJI+CgVHRl27lZu1AVpZUq0Et6wDmvsRoH2Qhnt9U3SP03UZz6IjIul4yiYnXGk= "cfp-2109-09-yes""
Invalid format or vote message for vote: $ defi-cli signmessage 8XQQ2HUPR2uy6S7VbGBBtCmQNture7XPvQ cfp-2109-01-yes
Invalid format or vote message for vote: $ defi-cli signmessage 8eLydM42kR12cSBmUq1V6RkVARYp2ZaubS cfp-2109-01-yes
Invalid format or vote message for vote: $ defi-cli signmessage 8bd3uKBxboBDQqpfGc8en9GuTVyt2GcF4C cfp-2109-01-yes

mnstate_validate.log
validate_cfp-2109-09_failed.log
validate_dfip.log

[uzyn]

Payouts made:

• 34406846c5e9680bca359279b8b6b71c0c34f80d1d8ef24e048f69dde130804a
• 948e66ca7f8be6bf8e15d84494ad6395e319fe3fa2deba9fd8976b78f80b58ab
• ac7451597d4e8c30006daad7884663db56faa253648523123cc45fdd6496c6cb
• 012acdf8c4553f243921bb34ea8359853e121556de18f7c20721a948869a34b4
• a0057171c0b687c4cf4e4e7b88c7e66f6a70732b91b101dd8f551131f4b02fc5
• 9ebff624fa61d799178bb5a41abd6c575ba15114e9cdebb0f523901aae38704a
• b69100ecea94bc4e1666228a518b14b3eff52ef36ab26cd16145dd8df74281e8
• 69e4f51b76974140f41c45706cd7111aaf98a47e25d3bd31fcf4eede8b6d5a8d
• 27f45a06bf0e591a85f569e252e63b2b4431d7779cd2ff1399019552e8873388
• 2753e82dceef3c6f96a6c9190496af8482800db627945d5560d5d0d1ab30be9d
• c6ba54f3786a021d5eed7a66c4d894dd732eaccc4623501148f49205507963c9