HS1SA devices returning modelId SmokeSensor-EM identified as HS3SA

[FlyingDomotic]

What happened?

I have 9 (square) HS1SA devices, externally identical.

Out of these 9 devices, 5 are badly identified as HS3SA.

The 4 clearly identified as HS1SA have "modelId":"SmokeSensor-EF-3.0" from database.db.

The 5 badly identified as HS3SA have "modelId":"SmokeSensor-EM" from the same file.

Going through issues and discussions, it seems that "SmokeSensor-EM" is also returned by HS3SA, as per #9919. My issue is the same as #9408.

Here's database.db content for these devices:

{"id":12,"type":"EndDevice","ieeeAddr":"0x84fd27ffxxxxxxxx","nwkAddr":63811,"manufId":4619,"manufName":"HEIMAN","powerSource":"Battery","modelId":"SmokeSensor-EF-3.0","epList":[1],"endpoints":{"1":{"profId":260,"epId":1,"devId":1026,"inClusterList":[0,1,3,1280,1282,2821],"outClusterList":[25],"clusters":{"genBasic":{"attributes":{"modelId":"SmokeSensor-EF-3.0","manufacturerName":"HEIMAN","powerSource":3,"zclVersion":3,"appVersion":16,"stackVersion":2,"hwVersion":24,"dateCode":"2020.7.10"}},"ssIasZone":{"attributes":{"iasCieAddr":"0x00124b00xxxxxxxx","zoneState":1}},"genPowerCfg":{"attributes":{"batteryPercentageRemaining":200}}},"binds":[{"cluster":1,"type":"endpoint","deviceIeeeAddress":"0x00124b00xxxxxxxx","endpointID":1}],"configuredReportings":[{"cluster":1,"attrId":33,"minRepIntval":3600,"maxRepIntval":62000,"repChange":0}],"meta":{}}},"appVersion":16,"stackVersion":2,"hwVersion":24,"dateCode":"2020.7.10","zclVersion":3,"interviewCompleted":true,"meta":{"configured":1},"lastSeen":1666693921435,"defaultSendRequestWhen":"immediate"}
{"id":30,"type":"EndDevice","ieeeAddr":"0x000d6f00xxxxxxxx","nwkAddr":8425,"manufId":4619,"manufName":"HEIMAN","powerSource":"Battery","modelId":"SmokeSensor-EM","epList":[1],"endpoints":{"1":{"profId":260,"epId":1,"devId":1026,"inClusterList":[0,1,3,1280,1282],"outClusterList":[25],"clusters":{"genBasic":{"attributes":{"modelId":"SmokeSensor-EM","manufacturerName":"HEIMAN","powerSource":3,"zclVersion":1,"appVersion":18,"stackVersion":2,"hwVersion":16,"dateCode":"2018.4.20","swBuildId":"1.1.1"}},"ssIasZone":{"attributes":{"iasCieAddr":"0x00124b00xxxxxxxx","zoneState":1}},"genPowerCfg":{"attributes":{"batteryPercentageRemaining":200}}},"binds":[{"cluster":1,"type":"endpoint","deviceIeeeAddress":"0x00124b00xxxxxxxx","endpointID":1}],"configuredReportings":[{"cluster":1,"attrId":33,"minRepIntval":3600,"maxRepIntval":62000,"repChange":0}],"meta":{}}},"appVersion":18,"stackVersion":2,"hwVersion":16,"dateCode":"2018.4.20","swBuildId":"1.1.1","zclVersion":1,"interviewCompleted":true,"meta":{"configured":1},"lastSeen":1666694713487,"defaultSendRequestWhen":"immediate"}
{"id":46,"type":"EndDevice","ieeeAddr":"0x000d6f00xxxxxxxx","nwkAddr":62484,"manufId":4619,"manufName":"HEIMAN","powerSource":"Battery","modelId":"SmokeSensor-EM","epList":[1],"endpoints":{"1":{"profId":260,"epId":1,"devId":1026,"inClusterList":[0,1,3,1280,1282],"outClusterList":[25],"clusters":{"genBasic":{"attributes":{"modelId":"SmokeSensor-EM","manufacturerName":"HEIMAN","powerSource":3,"zclVersion":1,"appVersion":18,"stackVersion":2,"hwVersion":16,"dateCode":"2018.4.20"}},"ssIasZone":{"attributes":{"iasCieAddr":"0x00124b00xxxxxxxx","zoneState":1}},"genPowerCfg":{"attributes":{"batteryPercentageRemaining":200}}},"binds":[{"cluster":1,"type":"endpoint","deviceIeeeAddress":"0x00124b00xxxxxxxx","endpointID":1}],"configuredReportings":[{"cluster":1,"attrId":33,"minRepIntval":3600,"maxRepIntval":62000,"repChange":0}],"meta":{}}},"appVersion":18,"stackVersion":2,"hwVersion":16,"dateCode":"2018.4.20","zclVersion":1,"interviewCompleted":true,"meta":{"configured":1},"lastSeen":1666696154574,"defaultSendRequestWhen":"immediate"}
{"id":50,"type":"EndDevice","ieeeAddr":"0x000d6f00xxxxxxxx","nwkAddr":26283,"manufId":4619,"manufName":"HEIMAN","powerSource":"Battery","modelId":"SmokeSensor-EM","epList":[1],"endpoints":{"1":{"profId":260,"epId":1,"devId":1026,"inClusterList":[0,1,3,1280,1282],"outClusterList":[25],"clusters":{"ssIasZone":{"attributes":{"iasCieAddr":"0x00124b00xxxxxxxx","zoneState":1}},"genPowerCfg":{"attributes":{"batteryPercentageRemaining":200}}},"binds":[{"cluster":1,"type":"endpoint","deviceIeeeAddress":"0x00124b00xxxxxxxx","endpointID":1}],"configuredReportings":[{"cluster":1,"attrId":33,"minRepIntval":3600,"maxRepIntval":62000,"repChange":0}],"meta":{}}},"appVersion":18,"stackVersion":2,"hwVersion":16,"dateCode":"2018.4.20","swBuildId":"1.1.1","zclVersion":1,"interviewCompleted":true,"meta":{"configured":1},"lastSeen":1666694056579,"defaultSendRequestWhen":"immediate"}
{"id":65,"type":"EndDevice","ieeeAddr":"0x000d6f00xxxxxxxx","nwkAddr":42372,"manufId":4619,"manufName":"HEIMAN","powerSource":"Battery","modelId":"SmokeSensor-EM","epList":[1],"endpoints":{"1":{"profId":260,"epId":1,"devId":1026,"inClusterList":[0,1,3,1280,1282],"outClusterList":[25],"clusters":{"genBasic":{"attributes":{"modelId":"SmokeSensor-EM","manufacturerName":"HEIMAN","powerSource":3,"zclVersion":1,"appVersion":18,"stackVersion":2,"hwVersion":16,"dateCode":"2018.4.20","swBuildId":"1.1.1"}},"ssIasZone":{"attributes":{"iasCieAddr":"0x00124b00xxxxxxxx","zoneState":1}},"genPowerCfg":{"attributes":{"batteryPercentageRemaining":200}}},"binds":[{"cluster":1,"type":"endpoint","deviceIeeeAddress":"0x00124b00xxxxxxxx","endpointID":1}],"configuredReportings":[{"cluster":1,"attrId":33,"minRepIntval":3600,"maxRepIntval":62000,"repChange":0}],"meta":{}}},"appVersion":18,"stackVersion":2,"hwVersion":16,"dateCode":"2018.4.20","swBuildId":"1.1.1","zclVersion":1,"interviewCompleted":true,"meta":{"configured":1},"lastSeen":1666696406938,"defaultSendRequestWhen":"immediate"}
{"id":98,"type":"EndDevice","ieeeAddr":"0x000d6f00xxxxxxxx","nwkAddr":28399,"manufId":4619,"manufName":"HEIMAN","powerSource":"Battery","modelId":"SmokeSensor-EM","epList":[1],"endpoints":{"1":{"profId":260,"epId":1,"devId":1026,"inClusterList":[0,1,3,1280,1282],"outClusterList":[25],"clusters":{"ssIasZone":{"attributes":{"iasCieAddr":"0x00124b00xxxxxxxx","zoneState":1}},"genPowerCfg":{"attributes":{"batteryPercentageRemaining":200}}},"binds":[{"cluster":1,"type":"endpoint","deviceIeeeAddress":"0x00124b00xxxxxxxx","endpointID":1}],"configuredReportings":[{"cluster":1,"attrId":33,"minRepIntval":3600,"maxRepIntval":62000,"repChange":0}],"meta":{}}},"appVersion":18,"stackVersion":2,"hwVersion":16,"dateCode":"2018.4.20","swBuildId":"1.1.1","zclVersion":1,"interviewCompleted":true,"meta":{"configured":1},"lastSeen":1666693913471,"defaultSendRequestWhen":"immediate"}
{"id":107,"type":"EndDevice","ieeeAddr":"0x804b50ffxxxxxxxx","nwkAddr":38066,"manufId":4619,"manufName":"HEIMAN","powerSource":"Battery","modelId":"SmokeSensor-EF-3.0","epList":[1],"endpoints":{"1":{"profId":260,"epId":1,"devId":1026,"inClusterList":[0,1,3,1280,1282,2821],"outClusterList":[25],"clusters":{"genBasic":{"attributes":{"modelId":"SmokeSensor-EF-3.0","manufacturerName":"HEIMAN","powerSource":3,"zclVersion":2,"hwVersion":16,"dateCode":"2019.8.29"}},"ssIasZone":{"attributes":{"iasCieAddr":"0x00124b00xxxxxxxx","zoneState":1}},"genPowerCfg":{"attributes":{"batteryPercentageRemaining":200}}},"binds":[{"cluster":1,"type":"endpoint","deviceIeeeAddress":"0x00124b00xxxxxxxx","endpointID":1}],"configuredReportings":[{"cluster":1,"attrId":33,"minRepIntval":3600,"maxRepIntval":62000,"repChange":0}],"meta":{}}},"hwVersion":16,"dateCode":"2019.8.29","zclVersion":2,"interviewCompleted":true,"meta":{"configured":1},"lastSeen":1666695422569,"defaultSendRequestWhen":"immediate"}
{"id":108,"type":"EndDevice","ieeeAddr":"0x84fd27ffxxxxxxxx","nwkAddr":33962,"manufId":4619,"manufName":"HEIMAN","powerSource":"Battery","modelId":"SmokeSensor-EF-3.0","epList":[1],"endpoints":{"1":{"profId":260,"epId":1,"devId":1026,"inClusterList":[0,1,3,1280,1282,2821],"outClusterList":[25],"clusters":{"genBasic":{"attributes":{"modelId":"SmokeSensor-EF-3.0","manufacturerName":"HEIMAN","powerSource":3,"zclVersion":3,"appVersion":16,"stackVersion":2,"hwVersion":24,"dateCode":"2020.7.10"}},"ssIasZone":{"attributes":{"iasCieAddr":"0x00124b00xxxxxxxx","zoneState":1}},"genPowerCfg":{"attributes":{"batteryPercentageRemaining":200}}},"binds":[{"cluster":1,"type":"endpoint","deviceIeeeAddress":"0x00124b00xxxxxxxx","endpointID":1}],"configuredReportings":[{"cluster":1,"attrId":33,"minRepIntval":3600,"maxRepIntval":62000,"repChange":0}],"meta":{}}},"appVersion":16,"stackVersion":2,"hwVersion":24,"dateCode":"2020.7.10","zclVersion":3,"interviewCompleted":true,"meta":{"configured":1},"lastSeen":1666694214011,"defaultSendRequestWhen":"immediate"}
{"id":111,"type":"EndDevice","ieeeAddr":"0x804b50ffxxxxxxxx","nwkAddr":4800,"manufId":4619,"manufName":"HEIMAN","powerSource":"Battery","modelId":"SmokeSensor-EF-3.0","epList":[1],"endpoints":{"1":{"profId":260,"epId":1,"devId":1026,"inClusterList":[0,1,3,1280,1282,2821],"outClusterList":[25],"clusters":{"genBasic":{"attributes":{"modelId":"SmokeSensor-EF-3.0","manufacturerName":"HEIMAN","powerSource":3,"zclVersion":2,"appVersion":17,"stackVersion":2,"hwVersion":16,"dateCode":"2019.8.29"}},"ssIasZone":{"attributes":{"iasCieAddr":"0x00124b00xxxxxxxx","zoneState":1}},"genPowerCfg":{"attributes":{"batteryPercentageRemaining":200}}},"binds":[{"cluster":1,"type":"endpoint","deviceIeeeAddress":"0x00124b00xxxxxxxx","endpointID":1}],"configuredReportings":[{"cluster":1,"attrId":33,"minRepIntval":3600,"maxRepIntval":62000,"repChange":0}],"meta":{}}},"appVersion":17,"stackVersion":2,"hwVersion":16,"dateCode":"2019.8.29","zclVersion":2,"interviewCompleted":true,"meta":{"configured":1},"lastSeen":1666695553127,"defaultSendRequestWhen":"immediate"}

Any idea to fix this ugly problem?

What did you expect to happen?

HS1SA correctly identified

How to reproduce it (minimal and precise)

Paring the devices

Zigbee2MQTT version

1.30.4

Adapter firmware version

20230410

Adapter

Slaesh's CC2652RB

Debug log

No response

[Koenkk]

Since they cary the same zigbee model we cannot distinguish them, I've renamed the device to HS3SA/HS1SA.

Changes will be available in the dev branch in a few hours from now. (https://www.zigbee2mqtt.io/advanced/more/switch-to-dev-branch.html)