New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
IKEA E1812 does not change from ON #6296
Comments
Same issue here. Pairing the Tradfi Shortcut button (E1812) worked fine. but i just dont see ANY events happening when i press the button.
Info: Zigbee2mqtt version: 1.17.1-4 I'm running zigbee2mqtt in home assistant. an entity was created automatically and linkquality and battery are working fine. I have 2 of these buttons and both have exactly the same issue. any ideas? |
@Koenkk I believe that since the button supports group binding, the device's "on" value should be replaced with "toggle", then this button can be used with sockets and lamps, in such a form as now I can not think of how to use it. .. |
@antti365 this device is indeed not bound to the default group (not needed for this device). I've already ordered it and will look into it. |
Its sending one on command on on /off cluster with unicast and / or broadcast (depends of cluster bindings). If like it sending toggle you need doing on custom firmware for it ;-) |
@MattWestb I have created a pair of this button with an outlet using bindings and the button only turns it on, it does not turn it off. I can't think of an application for this functionality, it's nonsense ... I hope Koen will come up with something, otherwise I'll have to hand it back to the store. |
I was still writing its only sending on on command = not seeding toggle so still you need writing on new firmware if you like chaining function from one scene button to one On/Off button.
You need changing the last command But i think its easier and less expensive baying on On/Off button for 6€ then the Silab devkit is costing 100€ for getting access to the Zigbee stack. But you can always making some "magic automatons" that is only working the your system is 100% on line. |
Received my E1812 today:
|
I am a noob at this. Does this mean that the device doesn‘t send any other commands? Why would IKEA do this? I am confused. |
@Koenkk Take one look on de(F)CONZ then its little tricky then like sending multiple commands the being bonded or sending uni and broadcasts. Its more or less the same problems with syfonisk and the new Styrbar dresden-elektronik/deconz-rest-plugin#4572 |
Because it's not meant to control lights, for this use: https://www.zigbee2mqtt.io/devices/E1743.html @MattWestb it looks to be working correctly |
I think IKEA kept it simple for them selves and used the same firmware as the E1743 but just the 'top' side of the button hardware is implemented on the E1812. I'd be honest, I'd expect it to send a scene_recall's with different ID's for short and long press, but I guess the are implementing them purely in software (shortcuts). |
The hardware is only little modified from the E1743 (one button in the middle of the PCB) but the firmware is more one Syponisk / Styrbar and its being paired as one "shortcut button" and not on normal controller in IKEA GW. I think its 100% software but i was not trying configuring scenes in the IKEA GW then i was sniffing it. So one symponisk with our turning sensor ;-) |
@Koenkk would this also affect IKEA E1743? Will you be adding this fix to the next release?
|
@877dev I don't know, but since they seem to share almost the same FW it could be. Fix will be in the next release (on 1 april) |
I updated to the latest version but I'm experiencing the same issue that @Geertvdc mentioned (nothing happens when clicking) |
@ratsoid try force removing the device via the frontend en repair it. |
I wrote a letter with a proposal to update the firmware in support of Ikea, let's see what they answer. Otherwise, you will have to forget about this device ... |
Yup it's working now, thanks! |
What happened:
IKEA E1812 does not change state
What did you expect to happen:
Change from on to off (and vice versa)
How to reproduce it (minimal and precise):
Debug info
Zigbee2MQTT version: 1.17.1
Adapter hardware: CC2531
Additional info
with debug turned on the device only seems to be sending a "commandOn" no matter how often I press the button
Received Zigbee message from 'Schalter Küche', type 'commandOn', cluster 'genOnOff', data '{}' from endpoint 1 with groupID 901
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: