MDEV-28749: restore_prev_nj_state() doesn't update cur_sj_inner_table…

…s correctly

(Try 2)

The code that updates semi-join optimization state for a join order prefix
had several bugs. The visible effect was bad optimization for FirstMatch or
LooseScan strategies: they either weren't considered when they should have
been, or considered when they shouldn't have been.

In order to hit the bug, the optimizer needs to consider several different
join prefixes in a certain order. Queries with "obvious" query plans which
prune all join orders except one are not affected.

Internally, the bugs in updates of semi-join state were:
1. restore_prev_sj_state() assumed that
  "we assume remaining_tables doesnt contain @tab"
  which wasn't true.
2. Another bug in this function: it did remove bits from
   join->cur_sj_inner_tables but never added them.
3. greedy_search() adds tables into the join prefix but neglects to update
   the semi-join optimization state. (It does update nested outer join
   state, see this call:
     check_interleaving_with_nj(best_table)
   but there's no matching call to update the semi-join state.
   (This wasn't visible because most of the state is in the POSITION
    structure which is updated. But there is also state in JOIN, too)

The patch:
- Fixes all of the above
- Adds JOIN::dbug_verify_sj_inner_tables() which is used to verify the
  state is correct at every step.
- Renames advance_sj_state() to optimize_semi_joins().
  = Introduces update_sj_state() which ideally should have been called
    "advance_sj_state" but I didn't reuse the name to not create confusion.

mysql-test/main/subselect_sj.result

@@ -2178,10 +2178,10 @@ INSERT INTO t5 VALUES (7,0),(9,0);
 explain
 SELECT * FROM t3 WHERE t3.a IN (SELECT t5.a FROM t2, t4, t5 WHERE t2.c = t5.a AND t2.b = t5.b);
 id	select_type	table	type	possible_keys	key	key_len	ref	rows	Extra
-1	PRIMARY	t5	index	a	a	10	NULL	2	Using index; Start temporary
+1	PRIMARY	t5	index	a	a	10	NULL	2	Using where; Using index; LooseScan
 1	PRIMARY	t4	ALL	NULL	NULL	NULL	NULL	3	
-1	PRIMARY	t2	ALL	b	NULL	NULL	NULL	10	Using where
-1	PRIMARY	t3	ALL	NULL	NULL	NULL	NULL	15	Using where; End temporary; Using join buffer (flat, BNL join)
+1	PRIMARY	t2	ref	b	b	5	test.t5.b	2	Using where; FirstMatch(t5)
+1	PRIMARY	t3	ALL	NULL	NULL	NULL	NULL	15	Using where; Using join buffer (flat, BNL join)
 SELECT * FROM t3 WHERE t3.a IN (SELECT t5.a FROM t2, t4, t5 WHERE t2.c = t5.a AND t2.b = t5.b);
 a
 0

mysql-test/main/subselect_sj_jcl6.result

@@ -2189,10 +2189,10 @@ INSERT INTO t5 VALUES (7,0),(9,0);
 explain
 SELECT * FROM t3 WHERE t3.a IN (SELECT t5.a FROM t2, t4, t5 WHERE t2.c = t5.a AND t2.b = t5.b);
 id	select_type	table	type	possible_keys	key	key_len	ref	rows	Extra
-1	PRIMARY	t5	index	a	a	10	NULL	2	Using index; Start temporary
-1	PRIMARY	t4	ALL	NULL	NULL	NULL	NULL	3	Using join buffer (flat, BNL join)
-1	PRIMARY	t2	ALL	b	NULL	NULL	NULL	10	Using where; Using join buffer (incremental, BNL join)
-1	PRIMARY	t3	ALL	NULL	NULL	NULL	NULL	15	Using where; End temporary; Using join buffer (incremental, BNL join)
+1	PRIMARY	t5	index	a	a	10	NULL	2	Using where; Using index; LooseScan
+1	PRIMARY	t4	ALL	NULL	NULL	NULL	NULL	3	
+1	PRIMARY	t2	ref	b	b	5	test.t5.b	2	Using where; FirstMatch(t5)
+1	PRIMARY	t3	ALL	NULL	NULL	NULL	NULL	15	Using where; Using join buffer (flat, BNL join)
 SELECT * FROM t3 WHERE t3.a IN (SELECT t5.a FROM t2, t4, t5 WHERE t2.c = t5.a AND t2.b = t5.b);
 a
 0

sql/opt_subselect.cc

@@ -180,7 +180,7 @@
   ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
    - optimize_semijoin_nests() does pre-optimization 
    - during join optimization, the join has one JOIN_TAB (or is it POSITION?) 
-     array, and suffix-based detection is used, see advance_sj_state()
+     array, and suffix-based detection is used, see optimize_semi_joins()
    - after join optimization is done, get_best_combination() switches 
      the data-structure to prefix-based, multiple JOIN_TAB ranges format.
 
@@ -2761,7 +2761,7 @@ bool find_eq_ref_candidate(TABLE *table, table_map sj_inner_tables)
   Do semi-join optimization step after we've added a new tab to join prefix
 
   SYNOPSIS
-    advance_sj_state()
+    optimize_semi_joins()
       join                        The join we're optimizing
       remaining_tables            Tables not in the join prefix
       new_join_tab                Join tab we've just added to the join prefix
@@ -2821,9 +2821,9 @@ bool is_multiple_semi_joins(JOIN *join, POSITION *prefix, uint idx, table_map in
 }
 
 
-void advance_sj_state(JOIN *join, table_map remaining_tables, uint idx, 
-                      double *current_record_count, double *current_read_time,
-                      POSITION *loose_scan_pos)
+void optimize_semi_joins(JOIN *join, table_map remaining_tables, uint idx,
+                         double *current_record_count,
+                         double *current_read_time, POSITION *loose_scan_pos)
 {
   POSITION *pos= join->positions + idx;
   const JOIN_TAB *new_join_tab= pos->table; 
@@ -3014,19 +3014,36 @@ void advance_sj_state(JOIN *join, table_map remaining_tables, uint idx,
     }
   }
 
-  if ((emb_sj_nest= new_join_tab->emb_sj_nest))
+  update_sj_state(join, new_join_tab, idx, remaining_tables);
+
+  pos->prefix_cost.convert_from_cost(*current_read_time);
+  pos->prefix_record_count= *current_record_count;
+  pos->dups_producing_tables= dups_producing_tables;
+}
+
+
+/*
+  Update JOIN's semi-join optimization state after the join tab new_tab
+  has been added into the join prefix.
+
+  @seealso restore_prev_sj_state() does the reverse actoion
+*/
+
+void update_sj_state(JOIN *join, const JOIN_TAB *new_tab,
+                     uint idx, table_map remaining_tables)
+{
+  if (TABLE_LIST *emb_sj_nest= new_tab->emb_sj_nest)
   {
     join->cur_sj_inner_tables |= emb_sj_nest->sj_inner_tables;
 
     /* Remove the sj_nest if all of its SJ-inner tables are in cur_table_map */
     if (!(remaining_tables &
-          emb_sj_nest->sj_inner_tables & ~new_join_tab->table->map))
+          emb_sj_nest->sj_inner_tables & ~new_tab->table->map))
       join->cur_sj_inner_tables &= ~emb_sj_nest->sj_inner_tables;
   }
-
-  pos->prefix_cost.convert_from_cost(*current_read_time);
-  pos->prefix_record_count= *current_record_count;
-  pos->dups_producing_tables= dups_producing_tables;
+#ifndef DBUG_OFF
+  join->dbug_verify_sj_inner_tables(idx + 1);
+#endif
 }
 
 
@@ -3579,10 +3596,45 @@ bool Duplicate_weedout_picker::check_qep(JOIN *join,
   return FALSE;
 }
 
+#ifndef DBUG_OFF
+/*
+  Verify the value of JOIN::cur_sj_inner_tables by recomputing it
+*/
+void JOIN::dbug_verify_sj_inner_tables(uint prefix_size) const
+{
+  table_map cur_map= const_table_map;
+  table_map nests_entered= 0;
+  if (emb_sjm_nest)
+  {
+    DBUG_ASSERT(cur_sj_inner_tables == 0);
+    return;
+  }
+
+  for (uint i= const_tables; i < prefix_size; i++)
+  {
+    JOIN_TAB *tab= positions[i].table;
+    cur_map |= tab->table->map;
+    if (TABLE_LIST *sj_nest= tab->emb_sj_nest)
+    {
+      nests_entered |= sj_nest->sj_inner_tables;
+      if (!(sj_nest->sj_inner_tables & ~cur_map))
+      {
+        // all nest tables are in the prefix already
+        nests_entered &= ~sj_nest->sj_inner_tables;
+      }
+    }
+  }
+  DBUG_ASSERT(nests_entered == cur_sj_inner_tables);
+}
+#endif
 
 /*
   Remove the last join tab from from join->cur_sj_inner_tables bitmap
-  we assume remaining_tables doesnt contain @tab.
+
+  @note
+  remaining_tables contains @tab.
+
+  @seealso update_sj_state() does the reverse
 */
 
 void restore_prev_sj_state(const table_map remaining_tables, 
@@ -3596,15 +3648,30 @@ void restore_prev_sj_state(const table_map remaining_tables,
     tab->join->sjm_lookup_tables &= ~subq_tables;
   }
 
-  if ((emb_sj_nest= tab->emb_sj_nest))
+  if (!tab->join->emb_sjm_nest && (emb_sj_nest= tab->emb_sj_nest))
   {
+    table_map subq_tables= emb_sj_nest->sj_inner_tables &
+                           ~tab->join->const_table_map;
     /* If we're removing the last SJ-inner table, remove the sj-nest */
-    if ((remaining_tables & emb_sj_nest->sj_inner_tables) == 
-        (emb_sj_nest->sj_inner_tables & ~tab->table->map))
+    if ((remaining_tables & subq_tables) == subq_tables)
     {
+      // All non-const tables of the SJ nest are in the remaining_tables.
+      // we are not in the nest anymore.
       tab->join->cur_sj_inner_tables &= ~emb_sj_nest->sj_inner_tables;
     }
+    else
+    {
+      // Semi-join nest has:
+      // - a table being removed (not in the prefix)
+      // - some tables in the prefix.
+      tab->join->cur_sj_inner_tables |= emb_sj_nest->sj_inner_tables;
+    }
   }
+
+#ifndef DBUG_OFF
+  /* positions[idx] has been removed. Verify the state for [0...idx-1]  */
+  tab->join->dbug_verify_sj_inner_tables(idx);
+#endif
 }
 
 
@@ -3831,8 +3898,8 @@ void fix_semijoin_strategies_for_picked_join_order(JOIN *join)
       join->best_positions[first].sj_strategy= SJ_OPT_MATERIALIZE_SCAN;
       join->best_positions[first].n_sj_tables= sjm->tables;
       /* 
-        Do what advance_sj_state did: re-run best_access_path for every table
-        in the [last_inner_table + 1; pos..) range
+        Do what optimize_semi_joins did: re-run best_access_path for every
+        table in the [last_inner_table + 1; pos..) range
       */
       double prefix_rec_count;
       /* Get the prefix record count */
@@ -5086,7 +5153,7 @@ int setup_semijoin_loosescan(JOIN *join)
 
   
   The choice between the strategies is made by the join optimizer (see
-  advance_sj_state() and fix_semijoin_strategies_for_picked_join_order()).
+  optimize_semi_joins() and fix_semijoin_strategies_for_picked_join_order()).
   This function sets up all fields/structures/etc needed for execution except
   for setup/initialization of semi-join materialization which is done in 
   setup_sj_materialization() (todo: can't we move that to here also?)

sql/opt_subselect.h

@@ -314,9 +314,11 @@ class Loose_scan_opt
 };
 
 
-void advance_sj_state(JOIN *join, table_map remaining_tables, uint idx,
-                      double *current_record_count, double *current_read_time,
-                      POSITION *loose_scan_pos);
+void optimize_semi_joins(JOIN *join, table_map remaining_tables, uint idx,
+                         double *current_record_count,
+                         double *current_read_time, POSITION *loose_scan_pos);
+void update_sj_state(JOIN *join, const JOIN_TAB *new_tab,
+                     uint idx, table_map remaining_tables);
 void restore_prev_sj_state(const table_map remaining_tables, 
                                   const JOIN_TAB *tab, uint idx);
 

sql/sql_select.cc

@@ -8663,6 +8663,10 @@ choose_plan(JOIN *join, table_map join_tables)
   {
     choose_initial_table_order(join);
   }
+  /*
+    Note: constant tables are already in the join prefix. We don't
+    put them into the cur_sj_inner_tables, though.
+  */
   join->cur_sj_inner_tables= 0;
 
   if (straight_join)
@@ -8978,8 +8982,8 @@ optimize_straight_join(JOIN *join, table_map remaining_tables)
                                  filter_cmp_gain,
                                  record_count /
                                  TIME_FOR_COMPARE));
-    advance_sj_state(join, remaining_tables, idx, &record_count, &read_time,
-                     &loose_scan_pos);
+    optimize_semi_joins(join, remaining_tables, idx, &record_count, &read_time,
+                        &loose_scan_pos);
 
     remaining_tables&= ~(s->table->map);
     double pushdown_cond_selectivity= 1.0;
@@ -9159,6 +9163,12 @@ greedy_search(JOIN      *join,
     /* This has been already checked by best_extension_by_limited_search */
     DBUG_ASSERT(!is_interleave_error);
 
+    /*
+      Also, update the semi-join optimization state. Information about the
+      picked semi-join operation is in best_pos->...picker, but we need to
+      update the global state in the JOIN object, too.
+    */
+    update_sj_state(join, best_table, idx, remaining_tables);
 
     /* find the position of 'best_table' in 'join->best_ref' */
     best_idx= idx;
@@ -9983,8 +9993,8 @@ best_extension_by_limited_search(JOIN      *join,
         trace_one_table.add("rows_for_plan", current_record_count);
         trace_one_table.add("cost_for_plan", current_read_time);
       }
-      advance_sj_state(join, remaining_tables, idx, &current_record_count,
-                       &current_read_time, &loose_scan_pos);
+      optimize_semi_joins(join, remaining_tables, idx, &current_record_count,
+                          &current_read_time, &loose_scan_pos);
 
       /* Expand only partial plans with lower cost than the best QEP so far */
       if (current_read_time >= join->best_read)

sql/sql_select.h

@@ -1307,9 +1307,15 @@ class JOIN :public Sql_alloc
     Bitmap of inner tables of semi-join nests that have a proper subset of
     their tables in the current join prefix. That is, of those semi-join
     nests that have their tables both in and outside of the join prefix.
+    (Note: tables that are constants but have not been pulled out of semi-join
+    nests are not considered part of semi-join nests)
   */
   table_map cur_sj_inner_tables;
-
+
+#ifndef DBUG_OFF
+  void dbug_verify_sj_inner_tables(uint n_positions) const;
+#endif
+
   /* We also maintain a stack of join optimization states in * join->positions[] */
 /******* Join optimization state members end *******/