Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

This project is DEAD! #380

Open
mbnoimi opened this issue Apr 9, 2019 · 29 comments
Open

This project is DEAD! #380

mbnoimi opened this issue Apr 9, 2019 · 29 comments

Comments

@mbnoimi
Copy link

mbnoimi commented Apr 9, 2019

There are serious bugs reported here but unfortunately it seems the author abandoned this project.

Am I correct?

@thatguy344
Copy link

As of today i am no longer able to download most if not all video files. I have tried randomly downloading videos from 2017, even ones i could download before do not seem to be working anymore... And yes, the author seems to have ceased developing it. Very sad!

@JJRcop
Copy link

JJRcop commented Apr 25, 2019

@thatguy344 Have you tried updating the youtube-dl backend?

@mbnoimi
Copy link
Author

mbnoimi commented Apr 25, 2019

youtube-dl works fine, but it's not a practical choice for a desktop user on daily basis usage. Currently I use uGet but its parameters not fixable like youtube-dlg

@thatguy344
Copy link

thatguy344 commented Apr 26, 2019

@thatguy344 Have you tried updating the youtube-dl backend?

You mean from within the Youtube-DLG folder? How would i go about doing this, just download the new fixed version of youtube-dl and drop everything into the Youtube-DLG folder?

@JJRcop
Copy link

JJRcop commented Apr 26, 2019

You can update youtube-dl directly from the application:
Screenshot_20190426_011949

@thatguy344
Copy link

You can update youtube-dl directly from the application:
Screenshot_20190426_011949

Man, you are a lifesaver... Thanks a bunch!

@JJRcop
Copy link

JJRcop commented Apr 26, 2019

You're welcome. Your point still stands that the Youtube-DLG project appears inactive. The last commit was from October last year: c5c18e5 And the commit before that was Jan 2018: 57eb51c

@nanondev
Copy link

nanondev commented May 7, 2019

Anyone is interested in migrating this project to python 3.7 ? I was considering contributing to the project since I have been using youtube DLG for some time, but as I tried to run it from code, didn't manage to get a working setup for python 2.7 due to some broken dependencies, seems more useful just to migrate to python 3.7. Anyone wants to give it a shot with me ? NaN.

@mbnoimi
Copy link
Author

mbnoimi commented May 7, 2019

Anyone is interested in migrating this project to python 3.7 ? I was considering contributing to the project since I have been using youtube DLG for some time, but as I tried to run it from code, didn't manage to get a working setup for python 2.7 due to some broken dependencies, seems more useful just to migrate to python 3.7. Anyone wants to give it a shot with me ? NaN.

Actually I'm considering to create an alternative in C++/Qt for getting rid of python issues.

@nanondev
Copy link

nanondev commented May 7, 2019

Hello Muhammad, thanks for your response, let me know if you start it, I am specially interested in joining in from an early stage.

@mbnoimi
Copy link
Author

mbnoimi commented May 8, 2019

Hello Muhammad, thanks for your response, let me know if you start it, I am specially interested in joining in from an early stage.

I'll let you know here.

@nanondev
Copy link

nanondev commented May 8, 2019 via email

@nanondev
Copy link

nanondev commented May 9, 2019 via email

@mbnoimi
Copy link
Author

mbnoimi commented May 9, 2019

Hello Muhammad, I have a running YoutubeDLG *running from source with Python 3.7 and wxPython 4.0 *, it's far from complete, but at least is enough to open the GUI and download a youtube sample video. I think it could be of good use to put it in a branch like "port-python37-wxpython40", to make it available to everyone to contribute while the work goes. Would you mind to create such branch ? I don't find the option on GitHub since I don't own the project. I am checking if I can create the branch directly from GIT but I think it can't be done. El mar., 7 may. 2019 a las 17:29, Muhammad Bashir Al-Noimi (< notifications@github.com>) escribió:

Anyone is interested in migrating this project to python 3.7 ? I was considering contributing to the project since I have been using youtube DLG for some time, but as I tried to run it from code, didn't manage to get a working setup for python 2.7 due to some broken dependencies, seems more useful just to migrate to python 3.7. Anyone wants to give it a shot with me ? NaN. Actually I'm considering to creating an alternative in C++/Qt for getting rid of python issues. — You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#380 (comment)>, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AMAMHTQBMRLDEXPBRWWEVJLPUHRBTANCNFSM4HEPWP5A .

Simply fork the project on Github then push your modifications to your forked project, then you can share the modifications by making a Pull request.

BTW, I found someone made same task in this request.

@axcore
Copy link

axcore commented May 9, 2019

I'm working on a fork, written in Python3/Gtk3. It should be ready by the end of May.

@mbnoimi
Copy link
Author

mbnoimi commented May 9, 2019

I'm working on a fork, written in Python3/Gtk3. It should be ready by the end of May.

Fantastic, could you please point to your repository?

@axcore
Copy link

axcore commented May 9, 2019

Fantastic, could you please point to your repository?

I will upload it, as soon as the core features are ready. One or two weeks from now, three at the absolute maximum :)

@silverbacknet
Copy link

Fantastic, could you please point to your repository?

I will upload it, as soon as the core features are ready. One or two weeks from now, three at the absolute maximum :)

I can't tell you how many hundreds of people I've seen fervently promising that they'll up their code as soon as it's ready, and every one of them either disappears forever, never to be heard from again, or comes back with a sob story about how their hard drive died. Stop that. Just make the fork, commit you half-working bits, and if you finish them then great, ready-made fork; if not, someone else can pick up where you left off instead of forcing everyone to reinvent the wheel.

@axcore
Copy link

axcore commented May 27, 2019

I can't tell you how many hundreds of people I've seen fervently promising that they'll up their code as soon as it's ready, and every one of them either disappears forever, never to be heard from again, or comes back with a sob story about how their hard drive died.

Your long run of disappointment is at an end. The code is up here, but it's not very stable. Perhaps you Python gurus can help with that.

https://github.com/axcore/tartube

@mbnoimi
Copy link
Author

mbnoimi commented May 27, 2019

Thanks a lot @axcore
Now you can see the first issue reported by me heheheheh
axcore/tartube#1

@ghost
Copy link

ghost commented May 27, 2019

@axcore
I look forward to an alternate program to Youtube dlgui. Do you release a windows installer also?

@axcore
Copy link

axcore commented May 28, 2019

@Lelle10 There are not installers yet. Check back in a week or two.

Efreak added a commit to Efreak/youtube-dl-gui that referenced this issue Aug 12, 2019
The old url was redirecting to github. The new url is a redirect to the actual file instead.
@MajorBarnulf
Copy link

if you keep having errors, you can try using the alternate app I made,
it's another y-dl gui, https://github.com/MajorBarnulf/graphical-youtube-dl
it is way more primitive, but it should get the job done.
I made it because I kept having errors with this one and they never got solved for long.

@mbnoimi
Copy link
Author

mbnoimi commented Jul 14, 2020

Thanks @MajorBarnulf

Tartube is much mature now I use it on daily bases it's full of features for both newbies and internet geeks.

@MajorBarnulf
Copy link

MajorBarnulf commented Jul 14, 2020

@mbnoimi I understand your point, but I find tartube a bit "too much" and isn't an app you could just launch quickly, paste the url, click a button and continue doing something else, it's a bit more indepth and complex for my use of these tools,
I would prefer keeping my message there in case someone has the same feeling as me

@mbnoimi
Copy link
Author

mbnoimi commented Jul 14, 2020

@mbnoimi I understand your point, but I find tartube a bit "too much" and isn't an app you could just launch quickly, paste the url, click a button and continue doing something else, it's a bit more indepth and complex for my use of these tools,
I would prefer keeping my message there in case someone has the same feeling as me

I agree with you the ui is a little bit complicated but the classic mode works fine for people don't want to deal advanced features (it's a clone ui of this project)

@maxtron95
Copy link

@nanondev Are you still interested in porting Youtube-dlG to Python 3?

@axcore
Copy link

axcore commented Oct 27, 2020

Porting to python 3 is easy; packaging it for various operating systems is the hard bit. Do you know how to do that?

@maxtron95
Copy link

I don't know how to package it for all of the operating systems, but I do want to see this project being worked on again, so I forked it. (https://github.com/creepertron95/yt-dlc-gui)

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

8 participants