5. Concept Evaluation And Product Architecture
01fe21bec205 edited this page Aug 12, 2022
·
16 revisions
Objectives | Weights |
---|---|
Safety | 7 |
User friendly | 8 |
Portability | 9 |
Can be used for any items | 8 |
Automatic | 9 |
Design Objectives | Weights | Design 1 | Design 2 | Design 3 | Design 4 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Safety | 7 | + | datum | + | + |
User friendly | 8 | 0 | datum | 0 | 0 |
Portability | 9 | + | datum | - | - |
Can be used for any items | 8 | + | datum | + | + |
Automatic | 9 | 0 | datum | 0 | + |
Score(+) | 41 | 32 | 32 | ||
Score (-) | 0 | 9 | 9 |
Design No. | Objective | Score Allocated | Justification for the Score |
---|---|---|---|
1 | Safety | 7 | The machine is covered and well protected |
User friendly | 8 | Automatic and does the task by just inserting the roll of tape and label | |
Portability | 9 | Compact and easy to carry | |
Can be used for any items | 8 | Can hold any size of label and tape roll | |
Automatic | 9 | reduces human effort | |
2 | Safety | 7 | The machine is covered and well protected |
User friendly | 8 | Automatic and does the task by just inserting the roll of tape and label | |
Portability | 9 | Light weight and Firm | |
Can be used for any items | 8 | Can hold any size of roll of tape and label | |
Automatic | 9 | reduces human effort | |
3 | Safety | 7 | The machine is covered and well protected |
User friendly | 8 | Automatic and does the task by just inserting the roll of label and tape | |
Portability | -9 | Large in size and is on the heavier side | |
Can be used for any items | 8 | Can hold any size of roll of label and tape | |
Automatic | 9 | reduces human effort | |
4 | Safety | 7 | The machine is covered and well protected |
User friendly | 8 | Automatic and does the task by just inserting the roll of tape and label | |
Portability | -9 | Large in size and is on the heavier size | |
Can be used for any items | 8 | Can hold any size of roll of tape and label | |
Automatic | 9 | reduces human effort |
SL. No. | Subsystem |
---|---|
1 | Holding the label and tape roll |
2 | Dispensing |
3 | Indication |
Subsystem 1 | sub system 1 | sub system 2 | sub system 3 |
---|---|---|---|
spacial | Y | - | - |
Data | Y | - | - |
Material | Y | - | - |
Subsystem 2 | Subsystem 1 | Subsystem 2 | Subsystem 3 |
spacial | Y | N | - |
Data | Y | Y | - |
Material | Y | N | - |
Subsystem 3 | Subsystem 1 | Subsystem 2 | Subsystem 3 |
spacial | N | N | N |
Data | Y | Y | Y |
Material | Y | Y | N |