feat:Split the admin command out of the main thread #2727
Conversation
|
Warning Rate limit exceeded@chejinge has exceeded the limit for the number of commits or files that can be reviewed per hour. Please wait 25 minutes and 4 seconds before requesting another review. How to resolve this issue?After the wait time has elapsed, a review can be triggered using the We recommend that you space out your commits to avoid hitting the rate limit. How do rate limits work?CodeRabbit enforces hourly rate limits for each developer per organization. Our paid plans have higher rate limits than the trial, open-source and free plans. In all cases, we re-allow further reviews after a brief timeout. Please see our FAQ for further information. WalkthroughThe recent updates introduce a new configuration parameter, Changes
Sequence DiagramsequenceDiagram
participant User
participant PikaConf
participant PikaServer
participant CmdHandler
participant ThreadPools
User->>PikaConf: Reads admin-thread-pool-size
PikaConf->>PikaServer: Sets admin_thread_pool_size
User->>PikaServer: Sends command
PikaServer->>CmdHandler: Determine command type
CmdHandler->>PikaServer: Returns is_admin_cmd flag
alt is_admin_cmd
PikaServer->>ThreadPools: Schedule in pika_admin_cmd_thread_pool_
else not is_admin_cmd
PikaServer->>ThreadPools: Schedule in standard thread pool
end
ThreadPools->>CmdHandler: Execute command
CmdHandler->>User: Returns results
Poem
Thank you for using CodeRabbit. We offer it for free to the OSS community and would appreciate your support in helping us grow. If you find it useful, would you consider giving us a shout-out on your favorite social media? TipsChatThere are 3 ways to chat with CodeRabbit:
Note: Be mindful of the bot's finite context window. It's strongly recommended to break down tasks such as reading entire modules into smaller chunks. For a focused discussion, use review comments to chat about specific files and their changes, instead of using the PR comments. CodeRabbit Commands (invoked as PR comments)
Additionally, you can add CodeRabbit Configration File (
|
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 6
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (10)
- conf/pika.conf (1 hunks)
- include/pika_command.h (2 hunks)
- include/pika_conf.h (3 hunks)
- include/pika_server.h (2 hunks)
- src/pika_admin.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_client_conn.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_command.cc (3 hunks)
- src/pika_conf.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_list.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_server.cc (3 hunks)
Additional comments not posted (14)
include/pika_server.h (2)
181-181: Addition of theis_admin_cmdparameter toScheduleClientPoolmethod.This change aligns with the PR's objective to handle admin commands separately, potentially enhancing performance by offloading these tasks from the main thread.
556-556: Introduction ofpika_admin_cmd_thread_pool_member.This new member supports the dedicated handling of admin commands, which should improve responsiveness and resource management for the main operations of the server.
src/pika_client_conn.cc (1)
275-277: Changes toProcessRedisCmdsto handle admin commands.The modifications ensure that admin commands are identified and processed in the dedicated admin command thread pool, aligning with the PR's objectives to optimize command handling.
include/pika_command.h (2)
293-293: The addition ofkCmdFlagsMonitorto theCmdFlagsenumeration aligns well with the PR objectives to enhance admin command handling.
549-549: The addition of theIsMonitorCmdmethod in theCmdclass is a critical part of the new functionality for handling monitor commands. Ensure this method is used wherever commands need to be identified as monitor commands.
[APROVED]conf/pika.conf (1)
34-38: The addition ofadmin-thread-pool-sizewith a default value of 2 is well-documented and appropriately placed within the thread management section of the configuration. This setting allows for better management of slow user requests by dedicating a specific thread pool for them.include/pika_conf.h (2)
64-67: The implementation of the getter foradmin_thread_pool_sizeis consistent with other getters in this class, using a shared lock for thread safety.
807-807: The addition of theadmin_thread_pool_size_member variable is appropriate and initialized to zero. Ensure that the default value set in the configuration file or during initialization aligns with expected operational defaults.src/pika_command.cc (3)
66-66: The addition of thekCmdFlagsMonitortoPingCmdaligns with the PR's goal of enhancing command monitoring capabilities.
94-94: The addition of thekCmdFlagsMonitortoInfoCmdsupports the separation of monitoring functionalities, enhancing system responsiveness.
102-102: Correctly classifyingMonitorCmdwith thekCmdFlagsMonitorensures uniform handling of all monitoring-related commands.src/pika_server.cc (2)
111-111: Properly stopping the admin command thread pool in the destructor ensures clean resource release.
176-181: Starting the admin command thread pool with proper error handling aligns with the existing patterns. Consider adding comments explaining the critical nature of this operation.src/pika_admin.cc (1)
1499-1503: Add support for the new configuration parameteradmin-thread-pool-size.This addition aligns with the PR's objective to manage admin commands through a dedicated thread pool, enhancing system performance and reliability.
| GetConfInt("admin-thread-pool-size", &admin_thread_pool_size_); | ||
| if (admin_thread_pool_size_ <= 0) { | ||
| admin_thread_pool_size_ = 2; | ||
| } | ||
| if (admin_thread_pool_size_ > 4) { | ||
| admin_thread_pool_size_ = 4; | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Validate the bounds for admin-thread-pool-size.
The validation for admin-thread-pool-size ensures it's between 2 and 4. Consider documenting the reason for these specific bounds in the code or configuration documentation to aid future maintainers or users in understanding these constraints.
Update related documentation and example configurations.
Please ensure that the addition of the admin-thread-pool-size configuration parameter is reflected in the pika.conf example file and any relevant documentation. This helps users understand how to configure this new feature.
src/pika_server.cc
Outdated
| void PikaServer::ScheduleClientPool(net::TaskFunc func, void* arg, bool is_slow_cmd, bool is_monitor_cmd) { | ||
| if (is_slow_cmd) { | ||
| pika_slow_cmd_thread_pool_->Schedule(func, arg); | ||
| return; | ||
| } | ||
| if (is_monitor_cmd) { | ||
| pika_admin_cmd_thread_pool_->Schedule(func, arg); | ||
| return; | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The changes to ScheduleClientPool method to handle different command types are crucial for proper command routing. Consider adding unit tests to validate correct command identification and routing.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 1
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (8)
- conf/pika.conf (1 hunks)
- include/pika_conf.h (3 hunks)
- include/pika_server.h (1 hunks)
- src/pika_admin.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_client_conn.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_command.cc (3 hunks)
- src/pika_conf.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_server.cc (4 hunks)
Files not reviewed due to errors (1)
- src/pika_client_conn.cc (no review received)
Additional comments not posted (14)
conf/pika.conf (1)
42-42: Configuration Parameter Added: admin-thread-pool-sizeThe addition of
admin-thread-pool-size : 2is aligned with the PR's objective to handle admin commands such asinfoandpingin a separate thread. This parameter sets the size of the dedicated thread pool for admin commands. The default value of2seems reasonable given the context but consider if this needs to be configurable based on the expected load or number of admin commands.src/pika_conf.cc (1)
169-175: Validate the bounds foradmin-thread-pool-size.The validation for
admin-thread-pool-sizeensures it's between 2 and 4. Consider documenting the reason for these specific bounds in the code or configuration documentation to aid future maintainers or users in understanding these constraints.include/pika_conf.h (3)
64-67: Ensure thread safety for the getter ofadmin_thread_pool_size.The method uses
std::shared_lockwhich is appropriate for ensuring thread safety while reading the shared variableadmin_thread_pool_size_. This is consistent with the thread-safety practices used in other getters in this class.
496-499: Verify thread safety and consistency in the setter foradmin_thread_pool_size.The setter method correctly uses
std::lock_guardto ensure thread safety during the modification ofadmin_thread_pool_size_. This is in line with the locking strategy used in other setters within this class.
844-844: Check initial value foradmin_thread_pool_size_.The member variable
admin_thread_pool_size_is initialized to 0. This is a safe default, but it's important to ensure that there is logic elsewhere in the code to set this to a sensible default based on system capabilities or configuration files before it's used.Verification successful
The
Loadmethod inPikaConfindeed sets theadmin_thread_pool_size_variable from the configuration. If the configuration value is less than or equal to 0, it defaults to 2. If it is greater than 4, it is capped at 4.
- Line 169:
GetConfInt("admin-thread-pool-size", &admin_thread_pool_size_);- Line 170:
if (admin_thread_pool_size_ <= 0) { admin_thread_pool_size_ = 2; }- Line 173:
if (admin_thread_pool_size_ > 4) { admin_thread_pool_size_ = 4; }This confirms that
admin_thread_pool_size_is properly initialized from the configuration files.
Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that `admin_thread_pool_size_` is set from configuration files at runtime. # Test: Search for the Load method usage. Expect: Initialization of `admin_thread_pool_size_` from config. rg --type cpp $'PikaConf::Load'Length of output: 70
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Extract the implementation of the PikaConf::Load method to verify if admin_thread_pool_size_ is set. ast-grep --lang cpp --pattern $'int PikaConf::Load() { $$$ }' src/pika_conf.ccLength of output: 81
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Extract the entire implementation of the PikaConf::Load method to verify if admin_thread_pool_size_ is set. rg --context 20 --after-context 20 --line-number 'int PikaConf::Load() {' src/pika_conf.ccLength of output: 200
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Extract the entire implementation of the PikaConf::Load method to verify if admin_thread_pool_size_ is set. rg --context 20 --after-context 20 --line-number 'int PikaConf::Load\(\) \{' src/pika_conf.ccLength of output: 705
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Extract the entire implementation of the PikaConf::Load method to verify if admin_thread_pool_size_ is set. rg --context 50 --after-context 50 --line-number 'int PikaConf::Load\(\) \{' src/pika_conf.ccLength of output: 1775
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Extract the entire implementation of the PikaConf::Load method to verify if admin_thread_pool_size_ is set. rg --context 100 --after-context 100 --line-number 'int PikaConf::Load\(\) \{' src/pika_conf.ccLength of output: 3576
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Extract the entire implementation of the PikaConf::Load method to verify if admin_thread_pool_size_ is set. rg --context 200 --after-context 200 --line-number 'int PikaConf::Load\(\) \{' src/pika_conf.ccLength of output: 7269
src/pika_command.cc (4)
66-66: Updated Command Flag forPingCmdThe
PingCmdhas been correctly updated with thekCmdFlagsMonitorflag. This change aligns with the PR's goal to handle specific admin commands likepingin a separate thread for better performance and isolation.
94-94: Updated Command Flag forInfoCmdThe
InfoCmdnow includes thekCmdFlagsMonitorflag, ensuring that this command will be processed by the dedicated admin thread pool. This is a crucial update for handling potentially slow or resource-intensive commands separately from the main execution thread.
102-102: Updated Command Flag forMonitorCmdThe
MonitorCmdhas been updated to include thekCmdFlagsMonitorflag. This update is essential as theMonitorCmdcan be particularly intensive and benefits significantly from being handled by a dedicated thread, reducing the load on the main thread.
965-965: Implementation ofIsMonitorCmdMethodThe method
IsMonitorCmdhas been implemented to check thekCmdFlagsMonitorflag. This method will help in determining if a command should be routed to the admin thread pool. The implementation is straightforward and matches the intended functionality described in the PR.
[APROVED]src/pika_server.cc (4)
85-85: Initialization of Admin Command Thread PoolThe initialization of the
pika_admin_cmd_thread_pool_with a size fetched from the configuration (admin_thread_pool_size()) is correctly implemented. This aligns with the PR's goal to handle admin commands likeinfoandpingin a separate thread pool to avoid blocking the main thread.
114-114: Proper Stopping of Admin Command Thread Pool in DestructorThe admin command thread pool is correctly stopped in the destructor of
PikaServer. This is crucial for proper resource cleanup and avoiding potential memory leaks or dangling threads.
180-185: Starting Admin Command Thread Pool with Error HandlingThe admin command thread pool is started, and comprehensive error handling is implemented. If the thread pool fails to start, the database structures are cleared, and a fatal error is logged, which is a robust approach to handling initialization failures.
738-746: Enhanced Scheduling Logic inScheduleClientPoolThe method
ScheduleClientPoolnow includes enhanced logic to determine if a command is a monitor command and schedules it appropriately in the admin command thread pool. This modification supports the separation of command handling based on their nature, which is a key objective of this PR.src/pika_admin.cc (1)
1500-1504: Ensure proper pattern matching inConfigCmd::ConfigGetThe pattern matching logic in the
ConfigCmd::ConfigGetfunction seems to use a case-insensitive comparison for the string "admin-thread-pool-size". Ensure that this is consistent with other configuration keys and aligns with the expected behavior in terms of case sensitivity.Verification successful
The search results from the script confirm that the
pstd::stringmatchfunction is used consistently with the same case-insensitive flag (1) across different configuration keys in thesrc/pika_admin.ccfile. This indicates that the pattern matching logic is uniformly applied in a case-insensitive manner.
src/pika_admin.cc: Multiple instances ofpstd::stringmatchwith the case-insensitive flag (1).No inconsistencies were found regarding the case sensitivity of pattern matching logic for configuration keys.
Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify pattern matching consistency for configuration keys. # Test: Search for similar pattern matching logic in other configuration handling code. rg --type cpp 'pstd::stringmatch'Length of output: 10937
| @@ -554,6 +554,7 @@ class PikaServer : public pstd::noncopyable { | |||
| int worker_num_ = 0; | |||
| std::unique_ptr<PikaClientProcessor> pika_client_processor_; | |||
| std::unique_ptr<net::ThreadPool> pika_slow_cmd_thread_pool_; | |||
| std::unique_ptr<net::ThreadPool> pika_admin_cmd_thread_pool_; | |||
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Tip
Codebase Verification
Initialization and Cleanup of Admin Command Thread Pool
The pika_admin_cmd_thread_pool_ is initialized and used in src/pika_server.cc. However, there is no evidence of its cleanup in the destructor. Ensure that the thread pool is properly stopped and cleaned up to avoid resource leaks.
src/pika_server.cc: Initialization and usage ofpika_admin_cmd_thread_pool_found, but no cleanup in the destructor.
Analysis chain
Initialization and Cleanup of Admin Command Thread Pool
The pika_admin_cmd_thread_pool_ has been added to handle admin commands. Ensure that this thread pool is appropriately initialized in the constructor and properly cleaned up in the destructor to avoid resource leaks.
Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Verify initialization and cleanup of pika_admin_cmd_thread_pool_ in PikaServer's constructor and destructor.
# Test: Search for the initialization and cleanup in the constructor and destructor.
rg --type cpp --multiline $'PikaServer::PikaServer\\(\\)\\s*\\{[^\\}]*pika_admin_cmd_thread_pool_' 'include/pika_server.h'
rg --type cpp --multiline $'PikaServer::~PikaServer\\(\\)\\s*\\{[^\\}]*pika_admin_cmd_thread_pool_' 'include/pika_server.h'
Length of output: 234
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Search for all references to pika_admin_cmd_thread_pool_ in the codebase to verify its management.
# Test: Search for all occurrences of pika_admin_cmd_thread_pool_
rg 'pika_admin_cmd_thread_pool_' --type cpp
Length of output: 482
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 1
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (10)
- conf/pika.conf (1 hunks)
- include/pika_command.h (2 hunks)
- include/pika_conf.h (3 hunks)
- include/pika_server.h (2 hunks)
- src/pika_admin.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_client_conn.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_command.cc (3 hunks)
- src/pika_conf.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_list.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_server.cc (4 hunks)
Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (8)
- conf/pika.conf
- include/pika_conf.h
- include/pika_server.h
- src/pika_admin.cc
- src/pika_client_conn.cc
- src/pika_command.cc
- src/pika_conf.cc
- src/pika_server.cc
Additional comments not posted (2)
include/pika_command.h (2)
293-293: Addition of new command flagkCmdFlagsMonitorThe new flag
kCmdFlagsMonitorhas been added to theCmdFlagsenum to mark commands that should be monitored. This aligns with the PR's objective to improve the handling of admin commands by segregating them into a dedicated thread. Ensure that all relevant commands are updated to use this flag where appropriate.
549-549: Implementation ofIsMonitorCmdmethodThe
IsMonitorCmdmethod has been added to determine if a command should be handled by the admin thread. This method should be implemented to check the command flags for the presence ofkCmdFlagsMonitor. This is a critical addition for the correct routing of commands based on their nature.
[APROVED]
src/pika_list.cc
Outdated
| bool is_monitor_cmd = false; | ||
| g_pika_server->ScheduleClientPool(&ServeAndUnblockConns, args, is_slow_cmd, is_monitor_cmd); |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Tip
Codebase Verification
The variable is_monitor_cmd is conditionally set based on command type and transaction state in src/pika_client_conn.cc. It is recommended to implement similar logic in src/pika_list.cc to ensure is_monitor_cmd is accurately determined.
src/pika_list.cc, lines 174-175
Analysis chain
Verify the handling of is_monitor_cmd in BlockingBaseCmd::TryToServeBLrPopWithThisKey.
The variable is_monitor_cmd is hardcoded to false. Verify if this should be dynamically determined based on the command type or other conditions to accurately reflect the new admin command handling logic.
Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Verify if there are conditions or configurations that should set `is_monitor_cmd` to true.
# Test: Search for conditions that affect `is_monitor_cmd` in the codebase.
rg --type cpp $'is_monitor_cmd = .*;'
Length of output: 306
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Extract and analyze the relevant code segments from src/pika_client_conn.cc where is_monitor_cmd is set.
rg --type cpp --context 5 $'is_monitor_cmd =' src/pika_client_conn.cc
Length of output: 821
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (9)
- conf/pika.conf (1 hunks)
- include/pika_command.h (1 hunks)
- include/pika_conf.h (6 hunks)
- include/pika_server.h (2 hunks)
- src/pika_admin.cc (4 hunks)
- src/pika_client_conn.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_conf.cc (2 hunks)
- src/pika_list.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_server.cc (4 hunks)
Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (9)
- conf/pika.conf
- include/pika_command.h
- include/pika_conf.h
- include/pika_server.h
- src/pika_admin.cc
- src/pika_client_conn.cc
- src/pika_conf.cc
- src/pika_list.cc
- src/pika_server.cc
chejinge
force-pushed
the
admin_thread
branch
4 times, most recently
from
de71413
to
0ee5b70
Compare
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 2
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (4)
- conf/pika.conf (1 hunks)
- include/pika_conf.h (6 hunks)
- src/pika_admin.cc (2 hunks)
- src/pika_conf.cc (1 hunks)
Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (3)
- conf/pika.conf
- src/pika_admin.cc
- src/pika_conf.cc
Additional comments not posted (5)
include/pika_conf.h (5)
64-67: Assess thread safety foradmin_thread_pool_size()getter method.The method uses
std::shared_lockto ensure thread safety when accessingadmin_thread_pool_size_, which is consistent with other getters in this class. This is a good practice in a multi-threaded environment.
448-452: Confirm the usage ofstd::shared_lockinGetAdminCmd().The method
GetAdminCmd()correctly utilizesstd::shared_lockto accessadmin_cmd_set_, ensuring thread safety. The use ofpstd::Set2Stringto convert the set to a string is appropriate and follows the pattern used elsewhere in this configuration class.
[APROVED]
506-509: Evaluate thread safety forSetAdminThreadPoolSize()setter method.The
SetAdminThreadPoolSize()usesstd::lock_guardto ensure exclusive access when settingadmin_thread_pool_size_. This is crucial for avoiding data races in a multi-threaded environment and is consistent with other setters in the class.
862-862: Validate initialization ofadmin_thread_pool_size_.The initialization of
admin_thread_pool_size_to0is consistent with other similar configurations in this class. This ensures that the thread pool size can be configured later without assuming a default that may not be suitable for all deployments.
864-864: Review initialization ofadmin_cmd_set_.The
admin_cmd_set_is correctly initialized with default admin commands. This setup allows for immediate use of the configuration with sensible defaults, which is a good practice.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 3
Outside diff range and nitpick comments (1)
src/pika_conf.cc (1)
169-175: Review ofadmin-thread-pool-sizeboundsThe configuration for
admin-thread-pool-sizecorrectly sets a minimum value of 2 and a maximum of 4. However, the rationale behind these specific bounds is not documented within the code. It's important for maintainability and clarity for future developers or users who might adjust these settings.
- Documentation Suggestion: Consider adding comments in the code explaining why these bounds were chosen. This could be based on typical use cases, system limitations, or performance considerations.
- Configuration Flexibility: If these bounds are derived from empirical data or specific operational constraints, it might be beneficial to allow these to be configurable through another setting or documented in the external configuration guides.
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (8)
- conf/pika.conf (1 hunks)
- include/pika_conf.h (6 hunks)
- include/pika_server.h (2 hunks)
- src/pika_admin.cc (2 hunks)
- src/pika_client_conn.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_conf.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_list.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_server.cc (4 hunks)
Files not reviewed due to errors (1)
- src/pika_admin.cc (no review received)
Additional comments not posted (12)
include/pika_server.h (1)
183-183: Approve the addition ofis_admin_cmdparameter inScheduleClientPoolmethod.This change enables the server to handle admin commands separately, which aligns with the PR's objective to improve command processing by using a dedicated thread pool for admin commands.
src/pika_client_conn.cc (1)
275-276: Approve the addition of admin command identification logic inProcessRedisCmds.The added logic to determine whether a command is an admin command (
is_admin_cmd) and subsequently scheduling it in the appropriate thread pool is crucial for the segregation of command processing as intended by this PR.conf/pika.conf (1)
42-42: Clarify the purpose and usage ofadmin-thread-pool-size.The configuration for
admin-thread-pool-sizeis introduced, but it lacks detailed comments. It would be beneficial to include a brief description about its purpose, especially highlighting its role in handling administrative commands separately from the main thread.- admin-thread-pool-size : 2 + # Size of the admin thread pool. This pool is dedicated to handling administrative commands like 'info', 'ping', etc., separately from the main processing thread. + admin-thread-pool-size : 2include/pika_conf.h (5)
64-67: Validate the retrieval ofadmin_thread_pool_size.The method correctly uses a shared lock to ensure thread safety when accessing the
admin_thread_pool_size_variable. This is consistent with other getters in this class.
448-452: Validate the retrieval of admin commands.The method
GetAdminCmd()correctly uses a shared lock, similar to other getters, and converts theadmin_cmd_set_to a comma-separated string. This is consistent with the handling of other similar configurations.
464-466: Check for admin command presence.The method
is_admin_cmdcorrectly checks for the existence of a command in theadmin_cmd_set_. This method does not use a lock, which is acceptable if the set is not modified after initialization or the modifications are handled elsewhere with proper synchronization.
506-509: Set the size of the admin thread pool.The method
SetAdminThreadPoolSizecorrectly uses a lock to ensure thread safety when setting theadmin_thread_pool_size_. This is consistent with other setters in this class that modify shared state.
862-864: Initialization ofadmin_thread_pool_size_andadmin_cmd_set_.The initial values are set appropriately. The
admin_cmd_set_is initialized with default admin commands which align with the PR's objectives to handle these commands separately.src/pika_server.cc (4)
85-85: Initialization of admin command thread pool.The thread pool for admin commands is initialized with a size specified in the configuration. Ensure that the configuration provides a sensible default and validate the input to prevent potential resource exhaustion.
114-114: Proper shutdown of admin command thread pool.The admin command thread pool is properly stopped in the destructor, ensuring that all threads are joined and resources are released. This is crucial for preventing resource leaks.
180-185: Starting of admin command thread pool in theStartmethod.The admin command thread pool is started here. It's important to ensure that error handling is robust, as indicated by the check on the return value. If starting the thread pool fails, the server clears the databases and logs a fatal error, which is an appropriate response to prevent inconsistent server states.
738-746: Enhanced task scheduling for admin commands.The method now routes admin commands to the dedicated admin command thread pool, which is a crucial part of the functionality introduced by this PR. This separation ensures that admin commands do not interfere with the main operation of the server and are handled more efficiently.
[APROVED]
conf/pika.conf
Outdated
| # Slow cmd list e.g. hgetall, mset | ||
| slow-cmd-list : | ||
|
|
||
| # Slow cmd list e.g. info, ping, monitor | ||
| admin-cmd-list : |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Specify default values and examples for admin-cmd-list.
The admin-cmd-list is introduced to specify which commands are considered administrative. However, it is left empty without any default values or examples. Providing a default set of commands and allowing users to modify this list would be more user-friendly and clearer.
- admin-cmd-list :
+ # List of commands considered as administrative. These commands will be handled by the admin thread pool. Modify this list as needed.
+ # Default commands: 'info', 'ping', 'monitor'
+ admin-cmd-list : info, ping, monitorCommittable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| admin-cmd-list : | |
| # List of commands considered as administrative. These commands will be handled by the admin thread pool. Modify this list as needed. | |
| # Default commands: 'info', 'ping', 'monitor' | |
| admin-cmd-list : info, ping, monitor |
chejinge
force-pushed
the
admin_thread
branch
4 times, most recently
from
4ba3c9d
to
fce9dbe
Compare
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 3
Outside diff range and nitpick comments (1)
src/pika_admin.cc (1)
Line range hint
1499-1520: Review of ConfigCmd::ConfigGet function.The function appears to handle configuration retrieval based on a pattern. Each configuration item is checked against the pattern, and if it matches, the configuration value is encoded into the response. This approach is flexible but could be optimized by using a map or dictionary to store configuration handlers, reducing the number of if-else conditions.
Consider refactoring to use a map where the key is the configuration name and the value is a function or lambda that handles the retrieval and encoding of the configuration value. This would make the code cleaner and more maintainable.
- if (pstd::stringmatch(pattern.data(), "admin-thread-pool-size", 1) != 0) { - elements += 2; - EncodeString(&config_body, "admin-thread-pool-size"); - EncodeNumber(&config_body, g_pika_conf->admin_thread_pool_size()); - } + // Example refactor to use a map + std::map<std::string, std::function<void()>> config_handlers; + config_handlers["admin-thread-pool-size"] = [&]() { + elements += 2; + EncodeString(&config_body, "admin-thread-pool-size"); + EncodeNumber(&config_body, g_pika_conf->admin_thread_pool_size()); + }; + // Usage + auto handler = config_handlers.find(pattern.data()); + if (handler != config_handlers.end()) { + handler->second(); + }
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (8)
- conf/pika.conf (1 hunks)
- include/pika_conf.h (5 hunks)
- include/pika_server.h (2 hunks)
- src/pika_admin.cc (2 hunks)
- src/pika_client_conn.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_conf.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_list.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_server.cc (4 hunks)
Additional comments not posted (16)
include/pika_server.h (1)
557-557: Ensure Proper Management ofpika_admin_cmd_thread_pool_The addition of
pika_admin_cmd_thread_pool_to handle admin commands is a positive change for performance. However, ensure that this thread pool is properly initialized, used, and cleaned up to prevent resource leaks or potential crashes on server shutdown. It would be beneficial to verify the implementation inPikaServerconstructor, destructor, and other relevant methods.src/pika_client_conn.cc (1)
275-276: Correct Implementation of Admin Command HandlingThe addition of
is_admin_cmdcheck and the subsequent scheduling of admin commands in a separate thread pool is a crucial enhancement for handling potentially slow admin operations without blocking the main thread. This change aligns well with the PR's objectives. Ensure that theis_admin_cmdfunction is robust and correctly identifies all admin commands as expected.src/pika_list.cc (1)
Line range hint
185-202: Potential race condition in lock handling.The sequence of locking in
ServeAndUnblockConnsmight lead to a deadlock if not carefully managed. Ensure that locks are acquired in a consistent order across different parts of the application.Consider reviewing all locking mechanisms throughout the application to ensure they follow a consistent order to prevent deadlocks.
conf/pika.conf (1)
42-42: Configuration foradmin-thread-pool-sizeis clear and sensible.The default value of 2 seems reasonable for handling administrative commands, which are typically not frequent but may require prompt processing.
src/pika_conf.cc (2)
169-175: Ensure robust validation foradmin-thread-pool-size.The validation bounds for
admin-thread-pool-sizeare set between 2 and 4. While this is a valid approach, it's crucial to document the rationale behind these specific bounds either in the code or in the configuration documentation. This will help future maintainers or users understand these constraints better.
169-175: Documentation needed for configuration bounds.The bounds for
admin-thread-pool-sizeare set between 2 and 4. It's important to document why these specific bounds were chosen, either in the code comments or in the configuration documentation. This will aid future maintainers and users in understanding the reasoning behind these limits.include/pika_conf.h (5)
64-67: Getter for admin thread pool size is correctly implemented.The implementation uses a shared lock for thread safety, which is consistent with other getters in the class.
448-452: Correct retrieval method for admin commands.The method
GetAdminCmd()correctly retrieves the admin commands fromadmin_cmd_set_using the utility functionpstd::Set2String, ensuring thread safety with a shared lock.
464-466: Correct check for admin command.The method
is_admin_cmdcorrectly checks if a given command is an admin command by looking it up in theadmin_cmd_set_. This is a straightforward and efficient implementation.
506-509: Setter for admin thread pool size is correctly implemented.The method
SetAdminThreadPoolSizecorrectly sets the admin thread pool size. It uses a lock guard to ensure thread safety, which is consistent with the other setters in the class.
854-856: Initialization of admin command set.The initialization of
admin_cmd_set_with default commands {"info", "ping", "monitor"} is appropriate and aligns with the PR's objectives to handle these commands separately.src/pika_server.cc (4)
85-85: Initialization of the admin command thread poolThis line initializes the thread pool dedicated to handling admin commands. Ensure that the size of the thread pool (
admin_thread_pool_size()) is properly configured and validated elsewhere in the system to prevent potential resource exhaustion.
114-114: Proper shutdown of the admin command thread poolThis line ensures the admin command thread pool is properly shut down during the destructor of
PikaServer. It's crucial to ensure all threads are gracefully stopped to prevent resource leaks or abrupt termination issues.
180-185: Start the admin command thread pool with error handlingThis block attempts to start the admin command thread pool and logs a fatal error if unsuccessful. It's important to ensure that the error handling logic (
net::kCreateThreadError) is comprehensive and covers all potential failure modes.
738-746: Enhanced scheduling logic for admin commandsThis method now handles the scheduling of tasks based on whether they are identified as slow or admin commands. This is a key part of the feature to offload admin commands to a separate thread pool. It's important to ensure that the conditions (
is_slow_cmdandis_admin_cmd) are mutually exclusive to prevent any command from being scheduled in multiple pools concurrently, which could lead to unexpected behavior or race conditions.Verification successful
Enhanced scheduling logic for admin commands
The
is_slow_cmdandis_admin_cmdflags are indeed mutually exclusive. Theslow_cmd_set_andadmin_cmd_set_are separate sets, and there is no overlap between them. This ensures that commands are not scheduled in multiple pools concurrently.
slow_cmd_set_is used to identify slow commands.admin_cmd_set_is used to identify admin commands and includes commands like "info", "ping", and "monitor".The code correctly ensures that a command cannot be both a slow command and an admin command at the same time.
Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that 'is_slow_cmd' and 'is_admin_cmd' are mutually exclusive. # Test: Search for the usage of these flags in the condition handling. Expect: No overlap in conditions. rg --type cpp 'if \(is_slow_cmd && is_admin_cmd\)'Length of output: 52
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the definitions and assignments of 'is_slow_cmd' and 'is_admin_cmd' to ensure they are mutually exclusive. # Search for the definitions and assignments of 'is_slow_cmd' rg --type cpp 'is_slow_cmd' # Search for the definitions and assignments of 'is_admin_cmd' rg --type cpp 'is_admin_cmd'Length of output: 1544
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Extract the definitions of 'is_slow_cmd' and 'is_admin_cmd' from 'pika_conf.h' to verify mutual exclusivity. # Extract the definition of 'is_slow_cmd' rg --type cpp 'bool is_slow_cmd' include/pika_conf.h -A 10 # Extract the definition of 'is_admin_cmd' rg --type cpp 'bool is_admin_cmd' include/pika_conf.h -A 10Length of output: 990
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the initialization or population of 'slow_cmd_set_' and 'admin_cmd_set_' to ensure they are mutually exclusive. # Search for the initialization or population of 'slow_cmd_set_' rg --type cpp 'slow_cmd_set_' -A 10 # Search for the initialization or population of 'admin_cmd_set_' rg --type cpp 'admin_cmd_set_' -A 10Length of output: 5173
src/pika_admin.cc (1)
1516-1520: Configuration of admin commands is not dynamic.The configuration for
admin-cmd-listis retrieved from a functionGetAdminCmd(). Ensure that this function dynamically fetches the latest configuration to reflect any runtime changes.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (8)
- conf/pika.conf (1 hunks)
- include/pika_conf.h (5 hunks)
- include/pika_server.h (2 hunks)
- src/pika_admin.cc (2 hunks)
- src/pika_client_conn.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_conf.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_list.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_server.cc (4 hunks)
Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (8)
- conf/pika.conf
- include/pika_conf.h
- include/pika_server.h
- src/pika_admin.cc
- src/pika_client_conn.cc
- src/pika_conf.cc
- src/pika_list.cc
- src/pika_server.cc
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 1
Outside diff range and nitpick comments (2)
src/pika_server.cc (2)
114-114: Proper cleanup ofpika_admin_cmd_thread_pool_in the destructor.Consider adding error handling for the
stop_thread_pool()method to manage any exceptions or errors gracefully.
738-746: Efficient routing inScheduleClientPoolfor admin commands.This separation should help in isolating admin command processing from normal client command processing, potentially improving performance. Consider monitoring the performance to validate the effectiveness of this change.
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (8)
- conf/pika.conf (1 hunks)
- include/pika_conf.h (6 hunks)
- include/pika_server.h (2 hunks)
- src/pika_admin.cc (2 hunks)
- src/pika_client_conn.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_conf.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_list.cc (1 hunks)
- src/pika_server.cc (4 hunks)
Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (6)
- conf/pika.conf
- include/pika_server.h
- src/pika_admin.cc
- src/pika_client_conn.cc
- src/pika_conf.cc
- src/pika_list.cc
Additional comments not posted (6)
include/pika_conf.h (4)
64-67: Review the implementation ofadmin_thread_pool_size()getter method.The method uses a shared lock for thread safety, which is consistent with other getters in this class. This is appropriate given the multi-threaded environment in which this configuration class operates.
448-452: Review theGetAdminCmdmethod implementation.The method correctly retrieves the set of admin commands as a comma-separated string. It uses a shared lock to ensure thread-safe access to the
admin_cmd_set_, which is necessary to prevent data races in a multi-threaded context.
506-509: Review theSetAdminThreadPoolSizesetter method.This method sets the size of the admin thread pool. It correctly uses a lock guard to ensure that changes to
admin_thread_pool_size_are thread-safe. This is important in a multi-threaded environment to prevent data races.
836-842: Correct the handling of admin commands inSetAdminCmd.This method transforms the input string to lowercase, splits it into a set, and stores it in
admin_cmd_set_. The method correctly uses a lock guard for thread safety. The previous comment about modifying the wrong set (slow_cmd_set_) seems to have been addressed in this version of the code.src/pika_server.cc (2)
180-185: Good handling of admin thread pool initialization in theStartmethod.The error handling after starting the admin thread pool is well-implemented, ensuring that the system can respond appropriately to initialization failures.
85-85: Initialization ofpika_admin_cmd_thread_pool_looks good.Ensure that the configuration retrieval (
g_pika_conf->admin_thread_pool_size()) is robust against possible misconfigurations or errors.Verification successful
Initialization of
pika_admin_cmd_thread_pool_looks good.The configuration retrieval (
g_pika_conf->admin_thread_pool_size()) includes validation to ensure the value is within acceptable bounds, making it robust against possible misconfigurations or errors.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check if there's error handling for configuration retrieval in `PikaConf` class. # Test: Search for the method `admin_thread_pool_size()` in `PikaConf`. ast-grep --lang cpp --pattern $'class PikaConf { $$$ int admin_thread_pool_size() { $$$ } $$$ }'Length of output: 456
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Search for the method `admin_thread_pool_size` in the codebase. # Test: Use ripgrep to search for the method definition. rg 'int admin_thread_pool_size\(\)' -t cppLength of output: 97
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Retrieve the implementation of the `admin_thread_pool_size` method from `include/pika_conf.h`. # Test: Use ripgrep to extract the implementation of the method. rg -A 10 'int admin_thread_pool_size\(\)' include/pika_conf.hLength of output: 363
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify how `admin_thread_pool_size_` is set or initialized in the codebase. # Test: Use ripgrep to search for the initialization or setting of `admin_thread_pool_size_`. rg 'admin_thread_pool_size_' -t cppLength of output: 495
| bool is_admin_cmd(const std::string& cmd) { | ||
| return admin_cmd_set_.find(cmd) != admin_cmd_set_.end(); | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Ensure thread safety in is_admin_cmd method.
This method checks if a command is an admin command by looking it up in admin_cmd_set_. However, it does not use a shared lock, which could lead to data races if admin_cmd_set_ is modified concurrently. Consider adding a lock to ensure thread safety.
- return admin_cmd_set_.find(cmd) != admin_cmd_set_.end();
+ std::shared_lock l(rwlock_);
+ return admin_cmd_set_.find(cmd) != admin_cmd_set_.end();Committable suggestion was skipped due to low confidence.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Ensure thread safety in
is_admin_cmdmethod.This method checks if a command is an admin command by looking it up in
admin_cmd_set_. However, it does not use a shared lock, which could lead to data races ifadmin_cmd_set_is modified concurrently. Consider adding a lock to ensure thread safety.- return admin_cmd_set_.find(cmd) != admin_cmd_set_.end(); + std::shared_lock l(rwlock_); + return admin_cmd_set_.find(cmd) != admin_cmd_set_.end();Committable suggestion was skipped due to low confidence.
这个参数是只读不会动态修改，暂时不用关注
There was a problem hiding this comment.
@chejinge, thank you for the clarification regarding the immutability of admin_cmd_set_ during runtime. It makes sense to skip the lock in this context as there won't be concurrent modifications. For clarity and to ensure this understanding persists, consider adding a comment in the code near the admin_cmd_set_ declaration or the is_admin_cmd method to document that it is intended to be immutable. This can help prevent potential issues if modifications to this behavior are considered in the future.
Learnings added
User: chejinge
PR: OpenAtomFoundation/pika#2727
File: include/pika_conf.h:464-466
Timestamp: 2024-06-26T09:50:20.652Z
Learning: The `admin_cmd_set_` in `PikaConf` is considered immutable during runtime and does not require a lock for thread safety when accessed by `is_admin_cmd`.
Note: Learnings are effective only in the context of similar code segments. To apply general coding guidelines, please configure review instructions. You can manage existing learnings in the app.
将pika的info ping 等admin命令拆分出主线程，用单独的线程池去处理
为了避免 config 配置过多 这里考虑用unorderd_set写死 可以通过config修改
#2399
Summary by CodeRabbit
New Features
Improvements
Bug Fixes